Star Trek Discovery (DIS) Season 3
The year 3188: Upon arrival through the wormhole, Michael Burnham collides with a ship. Both crash land on a nearby planet. Burnham sends the Red Angel suit back through the closing wormhole to transmit the final signal to Spock, and also activates its self destruct. She walks to the crash site of the ship where she gets into a fight with the pilot, who will later introduce himself as Cleveland "Book" Booker. They come to terms when Burnham offers Book her ancient tricorder to barter for dilithium. The substance used in all warp drives is scarce since a cataclysm known as "the Burn", which destroyed almost all dilithium in the galaxy and ultimately made the Federation collapse. The two walk to a place called Requiem. Once they have arrived in the city, Book has Burnham confined and takes the rest of her equipment too. Burnham is interrogated and reveals, under the influence of a truth serum, that the man she came with stole his cargo from another courier. As the guards try to apprehend Book, Burnham switches sides. Using a portable transporter, they escape from the city. Burnham gets injured, whereupon Book connects to a plant that releases an anti-inflammatory substance to treat her wound. He also allows her to use his subspace communicator to call the Discovery, but it is in vain. Once they have arrived at his ship, the guards from Requiem materialize and demand his cargo. Book opens his cargo bay with a huge trance worm, an endangered species that is traded as food. The worm attacks the other people and eventually swallows Burnham too. But Book can appease the animal and get it to release her. He is an environmental activist, whose intention is to transfer the worm to a sanctuary. Book takes Burnham to a Starfleet station that was abandoned a long time ago. Here, she is greeted by Aditya Sahil, who acts as a Starfleet liaison, although he was never officially commissioned. The two hope to find the Discovery and to rebuild Starfleet.
I have to admit that Star Trek Discovery's first two seasons were exciting. But they were also bumpy because of a writing that indulged itself in intrigues that made no sense, in mysteries that were not solved and in other attention-grabbing stunts, instead of telling a coherent story. It suffered from unlikable characters that we wouldn't want to have as crewmates and from a Starfleet that is sneaky and hypocritical. And last but not least, the series struggled with its own premise. After systematically ignoring established visuals and historical facts in its first season, the second season went on a continuity repair tour that culminated in a big conspiracy initiated by no one else but Spock. The fans would have deserved a series that honors the canon and characters of the franchise from the start and that doesn't require doublethink to accept it as a part of the classic universe. I'm not going to delve deeper into this rant, I just want to recall where Discovery comes from and where I come from regarding my history with the series.
Discovery's third season takes place in the 32nd century. In-universe, this is so far in the future that the AI Control can't acquire the unerasable data stored on the Discovery. In the real world, it is so far in the future that the series can't damage the existing continuity any more than it already did. In other words, it is a setting that was chosen to escape from the self-imposed creative dead end. It is a setting that easily could and should have been chosen from the start. I am willing to let the past go and give Discovery a new chance, but as already mentioned I would expect more than its continuity to change for the better.
"That Hope Is You, Part 1" is a spark of hope indeed that the people in charge of Discovery have learned something. No other crew members except for Michael Burnham appear in the episode, and I'm fine with that decision. The story is all about her first contact with the 32nd century, is told from her perspective in its entirety and accordingly straightforward. Although the new setting naturally requires a good deal of exposition, this is mostly accomplished in a "show, don't tell" fashion. There is no mystery-mongering and no distracting side plot of the kind that only would make sense five episodes later, if at all. "That Hope Is You, Part 1" is a pleasant watching experience of the kind I didn't know yet from Discovery. This may still change as the other characters appear and the story gets more complex, and perhaps once again so complex the writers can't handle it any longer. But let's wait and see.
I hate how the destruction of established planets, organizations and characters is a key element in every single modern incarnation of Star Trek (with the notable exception of Lower Decks). For now, I will give Discovery's third season a chance because this time it might strike the right chord. And even if I don't like the story at all, the future is not yet written. Neither the "Burn" nor the Discovery's involvement is bound to happen; it is just one possible future.
It is a pretentious idea that Michael Burnham, who has just saved the galaxy from Control, would arrive in the 32nd century, only to be up to save the galaxy once again. However, with the exception of the too sentimental flag raising with Aditya Sahil, the lonely Federation liaison, Michael Burnham doesn't have the air of a superhero in "That Hope Is You, Part 1", but rather of a woman who struggles to survive and to find her crewmates in an unknown new galactic environment. That part of the episode, including the chemistry with Booker (David Ajala), works well for me. Sonequa Martin-Green's overacting my not be everyone's cup of tea but somehow it befits this episode. And even the reference to (and reverence for) the once big and noble Starfleet is appropriate, at least if we apply it to the Starfleet of TOS or TNG (rather than to the sinister one of DIS).
Booker turns out to be the 32nd century equivalent of an environmental activist. I like that idea, especially since environmental protection has never been as a big a topic in Star Trek as it could have been (not even when it started to become a mass movement in the 1980s). Well, the episode becomes a bit preachy considering the double moral lesson to stick together and reunite the Federation, while protecting endangered species. Maybe one of the two themes should have been addressed at a later time.
One of my concerns about the season 3 premise was that the ludicrously advanced technology of the Discovery would surpass that of the 32nd century. Well, Burnham disposes of her almighty time travel suit for that matter, although there would have been good in-universe reasons to keep it. Anyway, the writers and designers had some nice ideas which innovations the future may come up with. The portable transporter is clearly the most notable new technology to date. I only have a problem with its visualization. The transporter converts people to something like shards, which is a similar effect as the deadly weapons. The first time I watched, it took me a while to recognize what was beaming and what was somebody getting killed. Furthermore, most devices of the far future just don't look any more advanced than those from over 900 years ago. The new interfaces and viewscreens are even very clunky, and proof of the dilemma to visualize something that is beyond the "incredibly futuristic" standard of the series.
On a note about the killing, it seems many of the guards get vaporized when something non-deadly, such as ancient phasers on stun or the 32nd century "shockwave weapon" would have been more appropriate. After all, it was no question of life or death, but just a fight for the possession of some cargo. The fact that Booker killed many humanoids to save one worm doesn't sit well with me, even if he can argue he had no choice because they otherwise would have killed him. Similarly, the murdering of Cosmo Traitt just because of his failure is totally disproportionate and reminds me of a bad gangster film.
I am glad that Discovery is done altering the make-ups of species without a good reason. The Lurian we briefly see among the pursuers has a look that is reasonably close to Morn's. And we can also glimpse an unchanged Cardassian. Only the Andorians and the Orions keep their altered appearances from season 1. I don't know why it was done this way, but the members of these two species look particularly odd in this episode, as they were both given a plastic-like glossy skin that makes them look like androids, rather than living people.
The season 3 opener is an episode with lots of eye candy, exciting action, a credible hero, a mostly credible story and a moral lesson. It is not flawless but avoids many of the mistakes that previous episodes of this series usually suffered from. In many ways, it is like a second pilot episode for Discovery and the fresh start that it urgently needed.
- Two statements in the episode refer to events in the 31st century, the time of Crewman Daniels and of the "Temporal (Cold) War" from Enterprise. The first is that the Burn took place 100 to 120 years before the episode. The second is Book's mention of "Temporal Wars", after which time travel technology was outlawed, but without giving an exact date. It appears that the Burn took place at a time when the Temporal Wars were already over, rather than being the incentive.
- After "Such Sweet Sorrow II", there was a mystery when and from where Michael Burnham would send the seventh signal that she promised to Spock (besides the even bigger riddle how this one could appear simultaneously with all six others as soon as in "Brother"). In the 23rd century, Spock picked up the signal 124 days later, and from a planet on the other side of the galaxy. This likely doesn't refer to Hima, the crash site in the 32nd century, because the suit still transmits through the closing wormhole. So the exit point of the wormhole in the 23rd century has shifted in the meantime, to the other side of the galaxy? And the 124 days? Well, at least the latter may be an uncertainty caused by the wormhole.
- Nitpicking: Burnham doesn't end up at Terralysium as intended, but close to another Class-M planet. What are the odds? She crashes into a ship that is just flying by. What are the odds?
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "You guys have a real problem if your couriers are stealing stuff and then colliding with thousand-year-old women in space!" - "What cargo was he hauling?" - "I don't know, but it was temperature-sensitive, and really valuable, so it's probably ice cream." (Burnham and Orion guard)
- "I may have broken your nose earlier. I apologize." - "Are you saying that in case we die?" - "Yep." (Burnham and Booker)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Commander Burnham, now I'll tell you a secret. I'm not a commissioned officer. You see, my father was. His father before him. But unlike them, I was never officially sworn in. There has been no one to do it. Yet I watch this office every day, as I have for forty years, believing... one day others like me would walk through that door, that my hope was not in vain. Today is that day. And that hope... is you, Commander Burnham." (Aditya Sahil)
- "I don't know how much of the Federation still exists, I simply do my part to keep it alive." (Aditya Sahil)
- Remarkable scene: Aditya Sahil begins every day with classical music, gets up from his programmable matter bed, brushes his teeth with a beam, takes place at his programmable matter desk and scans in vain for signals.
- Remarkable scenery: The exterior shots of the planet Hima were filmed in Iceland. It gives this episode a scenic dimension that probably no other Trek episode had before.
- Remarkable technology: The future comes with tactile interfaces and other objects made of programmable matter, portable transporters and non-lethal weapons that create a shockwave. Quantum slipstream drive appears to be a standard (provided there is dilithium).
- Remarkable species: Cosmo Trait, the man Booker stole the trance worm from, is meant to be a Betelgeusian, a species that was created for "Star Trek: The Motion Picture" but was barely visible in the film. We also see a Lurian, Morn's race, among the guards. And a Cardassian.
- Remarkable facts:
- The Burn took place some 100 to 120 years prior to 3188.
- All time travel technology was outlawed after the Temporal Wars.
- The Gorn recently destroyed two light-years of subspace.
- Aditya Sahil assumed his position 40 years prior. His sensors are capable of scanning a radius of 600 light-years. The long-range sensors of the station failed decades earlier.
The year 3189: The crew of the USS Discovery regains consciousness after passing through the wormhole. The ship crash lands in an ice field on an unknown planet. Main systems including sensors and communication are down, so it is not possible to determine the current location and time. Lt. Detmer does not feel well, but Doctor Pollard registers no injuries and sends her back to duty as there are more serious cases to take care of. Stamets too returns to his work. Acting Captain Saru dismisses Georgiou's requests to tend to the communications with priority and take what they need from a nearby settlement by force. He assigns her to just support the repairs. Saru himself departs for the settlement with Tilly, in the hope to barter assistance for the rare dilithium that the ship still has a supply of. The two arrive in a bar in a Coridan mining colony, whose inhabitants are afraid of someone named Zareh. A man named Kal repairs the damaged transtator with programmable matter. Meanwhile on the Discovery, work is progressing but the ice is parasitic and slowly encompasses the ship. Zareh and his henchmen materialize and enter the bar. He murders Kal and demands to be taken to the Discovery, with the obvious intention to pillage the ship. Saru proposes a deal: dilithium in exchange for their freedom. Then Zareh's henchmen capture Georgiou, who was on the way to the settlement against her orders. She and Saru team up and kill all but Zareh with martial arts. Georgiou intends to shoot Zareh, but Saru interferes and leaves the decision to Os'ir, the bartender, who chooses to spare Zareh's life. On the Discovery, Stamets manages to restore main power despite his injuries, and the ship prepares to lift off. Another ship appears and uses a tractor beam to release the Discovery. The crew prepares for a fight, but then Michael Burnham shows up on the viewscreen. She has been waiting for a year for the Discovery to arrive in her time.
"Far From Home" begins much like "That Hope Is You, Part 1", with the Discovery navigating an asteroid field and then crashing down on planet Iceland (even literally this time). In some way, this is a similar story of a first contact with the 32nd century as last week, only told from a different perspective. In most other ways, it isn't.
"That Hope Is You, Part 1" was marked by a wonderful chemistry between Burnham and Booker and by refreshing mood swings of the main character, even if they were overplayed. It all came across as natural as the arrival at an unknown place in an unknown time with unknown people could be. In contrast, "Far From Home" feels heavy-handed, although the episode could have profited from less need for exposition. Much of the character interaction doesn't work because it gets lost in unwieldy dialogues. Many of Saru's and Georgiou's lines consist of phrases, and they sound like they are primarily speaking to themselves (which, in Georgiou's case, doesn't surprise me though). I agree with everything Saru says and does in this episode, but he has too few good lines, and none when arguing with Georgiou. Most of what Stamets and Reno talk sounds like a competition in sarcastic one-liners, rather than something real people would say. Their interaction already worked better in the second season. The writing hits its low when Reno refers to a low-ranking crew member cleaning the blood-covered reaction cube as "Hazmat", in a quite condescending tone. (And yes, I believe that the cleaning guy actually named Gene is a reference to Lower Decks.)
Furthermore, it gets tiresome how everyone keeps reminding everyone else of how shitty the situation is, instead of saying or doing anything encouraging. I just don't feel entertained by how this story is scripted, whether everyone's bad temper is justified or not.
I wouldn't have expected to ever write this in a review, but Tilly somehow guides me through this story. What she does, what she says and what she feels is relatable, including her fear. Tilly still makes awkward inconsiderate comments, but in her case this is in character. Moreover, other than in his stilted disputes with Georgiou, Saru doesn't appear like a jerk when talking to her: "We are introducing ourselves to the future. You, Ensign Tilly, are a wonderful first impression." Also on the positive side, in this episode just as in the series in general, we have the enjoyable interaction of Stamets and Culber, although they too speak too much in phrases this time.
On another note about Stamets, I neglected to count but his weak condition was frequently hinted at in the episode. With everyone including himself saying all the time he shouldn't climb up ladders and shouldn't crawl through Jefferies tubes, I simply don't get why someone else (such as Nilsson, who was standing by, or perhaps a drone) couldn't do the work - other than for the melodramatic impact that only he could save the ship and is still the best choice even when he can hardly move. Such a plot twist should be served in a more decent fashion than by repeatedly foreshadowing it.
Another redeeming quality of the episode is its Starfleet spirit, as it shows when Saru keeps Georgiou from killing Zareh, which apparently impresses Os'ir so much that he too chooses not to pull the trigger. While commonplace in classic Star Trek, this act of mercy and the faith in the good in people is worth mentioning every time it shows up in Discovery. In hindsight it justifies some of Saru's too preachy lines in his conflict with Georgiou because it turns out they were not only lip service. However, just as in the case of the ailing Stamets saving the ship, the foreshadowing is a tad too blatant.
We can only speculate at this time what is up with Keyla Detmer, whose implant may be malfunctioning, which is shown with an ominous "acute hearing loss" effect. I hope that the writers don't pull yet another computer virus infection stunt with her. This is idea is extremely hackneyed after appearing twice already in the second season of Discovery, and recently in Lower Decks. Please, keep Control dead and buried!
After Burnham's visit to Mos Eisley, this week's episode heavily draws on the Western genre. The saloon door and Zareh's look and demeanor are maybe too obvious references, but I like them as they provide some distraction in a story that is otherwise devoid of fun. Also, the location shots of Iceland benefit the episode, although they are not quite as extensive as last week and although the effect of the Discovery engulfed in "parasitic ice" doesn't look very realistic.
I didn't find this episode nearly as enjoyable as last week's season premiere, although the plot is not bad either. I think this is mostly the fault of the dialogues, many of which bored or downright annoyed me. I still like the idea of Discovery having escaped
the canon Control to the 32nd century, but the writers should have left behind the abundance of phrases and metaphors just as well.
- The Coridanites (or people who were affiliated with the planet Coridan) previously appeared in ENT: "Shadows of P'Jem" and "Demons". The make-up used in DIS: "Far From Home" is similar to the one from "Shadows of P'Jem".
- "V'draysh", the corruption of "Federation", first appeared in SHO: "Calypso" where Craft said he had fought against the V'draysh for years and then took one of their escape pods. Since "V'draysh" in Pidgin means pretty much the same as "Federation" in the future season 3 and Starfleet design and symbols are still highly recognizable, we have to wonder why Craft wouldn't identify the Discovery as an enemy ship.
- Why would the ship that appears above the Discovery be identified as an enemy vessel, other than for the dramatic impact? It is an unknown planet and time, so if anything it would an "unknown ship".
- What happened to Saru's announcement to hand over Zareh's vessel to the miners? Just a few moments later, after Os'ir has spared his life, Zareh is free to go, beams down and might well return to his ship.
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "A one-woman tactical response? V'draysh has officially reached its nadir." - "A fancy vocabulary doesn't mean you're scary. It means you have a thesaurus." (Zareh and Georgiou)
- "Hugh, thanks. Jett, thanks for nothing." - "Back at you, bobcat." - "Bobcat?" - "I don't know, I'm on drugs." (Stamets, Reno, Culber)
- Remarkably hokey quotes:
- "Uhm, you have some, uh, Leland on your shoes." (Tilly, to Georgiou)
- "I'm gonna enjoy this new world. If this idiot can run a settlement, then imagine what I can do in my sleep." (Georgiou, about Zareh)
- Remarkable technology: After appearing in various forms in the previous episode, programmable matter is explicitly mentioned for the first time when Kal repairs the ancient transtator.
- Remarkable facts:
- The Discovery currently has a crew of 88.
- Coridanites apparently have blue blood.
- Linus, the Saurian, says that he can see a spectrum of 74000 nanometers (or simply 74 micrometers), by which he implies that he perceives mid-infrared radiation.
- Zareh gained control of the settlement after decapitating the former courier.
After spending a year working as a courier and learning more about the 32nd century, Michael Burnham reunites with the crew of the Discovery. Saru officially takes command of the ship. Using the spore drive, the Discovery heads for Earth, from where a Starfleet admiral named Senna Tal sent a message twelve years ago. Booker hides the Discovery's dilithium on his cloaked ship inside the shuttlebay. Upon their arrival, the Discovery is boarded by the United Earth Defense Force for inspection. Earth has become isolationist, and very protective of its supply of dilithium. An alien named Wen, who is known for frequently trying to raid Earth, appears with five ships, in the hope of finding dilithium on the Discovery. The UE boarding party tries to beam back, but something blocks their personal transporters. Without consulting with Saru, Booker and Burnham take the courier's ship and turn it into a decoy for Wen. United Earth Captain Ndoye says she can't allow Wen to acquire the dilithium and opens fire on Booker's ship, but Saru orders the Discovery to take the hit. Burnham contacts Wen and offers him to beam over the dilithium to his ship but actually kidnaps him once he lowers his shields. On the Discovery, it turns out that Wen is human and comes from the abandoned research colony on Titan. After a previous attempt to ask Earth for support ended in the destruction of the ship, he now tries to get what his people need by force. Ndoye promises to help Titan. In the meantime, Stamets and Tilly have found out that the blocked transporter was sabotage, obviously carried out by 16-year-old Adira, a member of the United Earth forces. Adira reveals that they just wanted to buy themselves more time to investigate the ship. They joined the United Earth forces with the intention to find a Starfleet ship one day. Adira is actually the human host to Admiral Senna Tal, a Trill symbiont. Saru gives his crew time to visit the surface of Earth, and then orders to continue the search for Starfleet Headquarters.
It is one of the longest-standing clichés of Star Trek that the gallant Starfleet crew, most of whom are human, comes along and teaches a previously unknown alien planet-of-the-week a fundamental lesson in how to overcome wars and other conflicts. I think the writers of "People of Earth" take a special pleasure in the fact that the planet is Earth this time - and that, although it's Earth, the crew doesn't care as much as they perhaps should and doesn't consider to stay there. This twist works in the new setting of the galaxy in disarray after the Burn. In fact, in the course of the episode it is rather easy to forget the name of the xenophobic planet, and "People of Earth" comes across much like a classic, self-contained Star Trek episode.
Although isolation is not a desirable future, in the context of the Burn it is comforting that Earth wouldn't end up in anarchy like apparently so many other worlds. When I saw the "wall" that was erected around the planet I was concerned that the story may get preachy, but fortunately the analogies to the real world were kept subtle.
Just like last week's episode, "People of Earth" comes with a lot of character interaction. The reunion of the crew is a tad too tearful, but it resonates with me. It is something that could not have been shown like this in the first season, and still not half-way through the second season without being dishonest, since Burnham was not really close to the crew back then. Although the focus is on Burnham and Saru, everyone among the cast has one or two nice scenes. Quite unlike "Far From Home", this episode doesn't get drowned in phrases but has much more natural dialogues, and a good deal of banter. The only exception once again is Georgiou, whose sole purpose is to wait for cues for her to do something drastic or to utter something sarcastic.
I'm not content at all with how the three-way confrontation between Earth, the Discovery and Wen's pirates ensues and is further complicated by Adira's sabotage. After the first viewing and prior to further scrutiny, it leaves way too many open questions and plot holes. The probably biggest issue is how Wen's people on Titan couldn't transmit signals to Earth but could build armed ships (apparently without communication systems?) and credibly pose as aliens that want to raid the planet (by simply wearing silly helmets). And even if there are facts or possible excuses I didn't catch, the whole story ultimately suffers from Burnham and Booker's reckless plan to use a ship full of dilithium as a decoy. It is a stupid idea to start with to present the pirates with exactly what they want and with something the ship urgently needs, although it would have been possible to keep hiding it indefinitely, especially since the situation has been relatively peaceful until this escalation. Furthermore, it is inexcusable not to consult with Saru beforehand, who needs Georgiou's advice to react the right way. Burnham, Booker, the cat and the dilithium survive the totally incalculable stunt only with a huge deal of luck.
The character Adira is played by Blu del Barrio, who is non-binary. According to the announcements by CBS, the same applies to the character. For some reason, however, Adira is consistently referred to as "she" in this episode, rather than "they". It remains to be seen whether this happens in-universe because of mere ignorance or secrecy, and whether Adira will still have a coming out. In addition, Adira is a human host to a Trill symbiont, which further complicates the gender issues. We are already very familiar with Trill symbionts switching to hosts of a different sex. Showing analogies in alien societies is the traditional way that Star Trek addresses present-day social issues, rather than aiming for direct representation as it happens in more recent years. As a result, Adira comes with no less than three layers of gender identity: the nature of the alien symbiont who can switch to hosts of any sex (and species?), the gender identity of the host character and the real-life gender of the actor. I hope for the sake of the credibility of the character that this is not too much of a burden. Maybe the first two aspects are in some way related. We will likely find out later this season. Adira is currently still a bit of a mystery but definitely an interesting one.
The script of this episode indulges in self-irony on several occasions. When Stamets deems the simultaneous destruction of all dilithium impossible, Georgiou remarks that this comes from "a man who jumps a starship through mushroom space", essentially echoing one of the frequent complaints about the show's implausible technology. Saru alludes to the name of his ship, and to the fact that it has not really been on journeys of discovery in the first two seasons. Booker hints at the spinning of the Discovery on spore drive, a silly effect that the series so far tried to deal with seriously, by simply not mentioning it. Although it doesn't help solving the problems by only hinting at them, I like how Discovery lightens up in this regard. Just like Michael Burnham, who appears "lighter" to Saru and who has definitely lost some of her grimness.
As already mentioned, Earth is much like a planet-of-the-week in this episode. Unfortunately this also applies to Earth's whole technology and styling. It is simply unremarkable and could be used for any alien civilization in any era. The United Earth Defense Force uniforms are particularly bland. At the very least, they should have been given a different color than those of the Discovery crew. Considering this is over 900 years in the future, it is almost frightening how little has changed. Even the solar panels on the Golden Gate Bridge are still there.
"People of Earth" does a solid job to establish Adira as a possibly permanent character, to reintroduce us to Earth in the fashion of an alien planet, to solve an unnecessary conflict and to get a moral lesson across on the way. It almost feels like the good old episodic Star Trek in this regard but is only average if we use the old Trek as a yardstick. The episode comes with a light-handed directing by Jonathan Frakes and enjoyable character interaction. The depiction of the various conflicts, on the other hand, is a mess. It leaves me the less satisfied the more I think about it. Last but not least, after the very emotional reunion of the crew, Burnham's breach of Saru's confidence leaves a bitter taste, even more so as it is simply ignored in the end.
- What happened to not using the spore drive any more, to protect "May's" realm and/or to protect Stamets?
- Michael Burnham mentions that she met Trills in the exchange program but didn't know they are hosts joined with symbionts. This is apparently an attempt to make sense of one of the irreconcilable discrepancies between TNG and DS9 Trills: No one in the Federation was aware of the true nature of TNG Trills until TNG: "The Host", whereas DS9 Trills such as Dax had been a familiar sight for over a century. The DIS episode uses the concept of a human host from the TNG episode, although in "The Host" Odan took complete control and left Riker dormant, whereas the exact opposite seems to apply to Tal and Adira, respectively. In DS9, Trills were always a blend of the host's and the symbiont's personality, with all previous hosts leaving their traces, but DS9 didn't show human hosts at any time.
- Talking to Burnham immediately after her arrival on the ship, Saru pretends to have a good idea of how his crew copes with "the enormity of what we have done". He says that at a time when his ship and crew have spent barely a day in the 32nd century, and under dramatic circumstances. There is no way anyone could have pondered about their situation, and that Saru could have noticed that, much less talked to anyone about it.
- The excuse for the Discovery having survived the Burn is that they were not at warp when the dilithium exploded. But even when not a warp, starships would usually keep the warp core powered up. In fact, in the flashback in the same episode we see many starships getting destroyed while at rest.
- The plan is to deactivate the spore drive of the Discovery outside Earth's scanning range, in order to appear like a ship that made its way home on impulse drive. The Discovery pops up near Saturn, implying that Earth would not be able to detect a ship approaching at warp until it is well inside the Sol system. While this makes sense in the story, as it explains why the origin of Wen's ships can't be tracked to Titan, it is not realistic at all. Moreover, how could anyone on the Discovery know the scanning range is so extremely limited, considering that there was no recent information on the planet?
- A further part of the cover story is that the people on the Discovery are the descendants of the original crew. And that for some reason it would raise suspicion if not all of them, without a single exception, are in uniform all the time, even when they are off-duty. This is more like a lame excuse for the scenes in which Book feels uncomfortable in his uniform and in which Georgiou poses as an admiral.
- What do you do when you have just caught a saboteur in the act? Report them to security immediately? No, you let them in on the best-kept secrets of the ship! Such as that the Discovery is equipped with a revolutionary spore drive, that you are the only one who can operate it, and that you are a time traveler!
- How did Adira want to get away with what they were doing on the Discovery anyway? They endangered and effectively betrayed their own people, and they sabotaged the very ship they planned to join!
- The camera zooms out from the huge tree on the Starfleet Academy grounds that has survived for over 900 years. In the 23rd (Discovery) and 24th centuries (Picard), however, there was no such park and no such tree in this location.
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "That's impossible. Nothing could affect all dilithium all at once." - "Says a man who jumps a starship through mushroom space." (Stamets and Georgiou)
- "You're Lieutenant Booker now." - "Aye, aye, commander." - "One 'aye'. We're not pirates." (Burnham and Booker)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Cake is eternal." (Burnham)
- "This ship bears the name Discovery. Never has that been more fitting, or more prescient. She has carried us into the future, and it will be our privilege to make that future bright. Let us begin. Together." (Saru)
- "Oh shit! Hey, you didn't tell me about the spinning part!" (Booker, about the ship spping on spore drive)
- Remarkably cheesy scene: Georgiou appears in an admiral's uniform.
- Remarkable technology: The Discovery's shields are no obstacle for 32nd century personal transporters. The inspection team beams aboard through the raised shields. Only due to Adira's sabotage they can't beam back.
- Remarkable facts:
- The stardate (of the year 3188, in the flashback) is 865211.3.
- The dilithium supplies dried up around 2960 before the substance eventually went inert. This obviously led to a direct contact of matter and antimatter inside the warp cores and destroyed all warp-capable vessels that were powered up.
- After the Burn, Starfleet Headquarters was moved away from Earth. The planet has since become self-sustaining and isolationist.
- Burnham contacted Terralysium and waited for a response for months, but no one had ever heard of her mother.
The crew of the Discovery continue their search for the Federation Headquarters. Adira's symbiont Tal may have the decisive information, but Adira can neither communicate with Tal nor access their own memories. Therefore the ship jumps to Trill, in the hope of finding support with this issue. Burnham accompanies Adira to the surface where they talk with Leader Pav, Commissioner Vos and Guardian Xi. The planet has been hit hard by the Burn, which decimated its population. There are only few viable hosts left. Whereas Vos is appalled by the idea of an alien carrying a Trill symbiont and demands Tal to be extracted from Adira, Xi is willing to allow them into the sacred Caves of Mak'ala so they can reconnect. Pav can't resolve the conflict and rules that Adira has to leave Trill. On their way to the shuttle, Vos tries to kidnap Adira, but Burnham disables him and his guards. Xi appears and leads them to the caves. On the ship, Saru invites his senior officers for dinner, in order to thank and encourage them. The event, however, ends prematurely with a quarrel between Detmer and Stamets. In the caves on Trill, Adira enters the pool to connect with their symbiont. But after a while they sink to the bottom. Burnham is worried and follows Adira. The two establish a telepathic link. Burnham encourages Adira to allow the symbiont to connect with them, even though the memories are painful. Tal was previously joined with Gray, Adira's boyfriend. The two were on a generation ship on the way to the Federation Headquarters. Gray was fatally wounded after an asteroid collision, and the medical drones could only save Tal by implanting the symbiont into Adira. Following the successful reconnection with the previous hosts, including Senna Tal, Adira turns down the offer to stay on Trill and returns to the Discovery. After the failure to boost the team spirit with the dinner, Saru arranges a slapstick movie event in the shuttlebay at the suggestion of the ship's computer, which is a success. Back on the ship, it turns out that Gray is still present in some fashion, and Adira can talk to him.
All episodes of season 3 so far are meaningful. They show key events, key places and key characters. They do so without much sidetracking and they answer more questions than they raise. After two seasons of mystery-mongering and dangling threads, this is a pleasant new way of storytelling in the series. It is a bit like a quest now, rather than a maze run. "Forget Me Not" overall continues this positive development. The episode revisits another familiar planet, adds further pieces to the puzzle of the Burn and solves the mystery of Adira's past for the most part, an outcome that leaves me content.
I'm not so fond of the B-plot, which comes across as very contrived. The episode starts with Hugh Culber's log. It sets the tone for the things to come as the doctor observes that the crew slowly recognize they have hardly anything to cling to and feel lost, although many (and notably Detmer) wouldn't seek help. His assessment of the psychic condition of the crew may defy the "show, don't tell" principle, but it leads over nicely to Detmer's refusal to talk about her trouble. This is still the best part of the plot thread. Everything that follows doesn't work for me.
One of my gripes is how some of the crew act like it's season 1 again. Saru seeks advice on the basics of leaderships much like he did in "Choose Your Pain". He suddenly can't tell from experience what his crew needs, and he doesn't have anyone but the computer to ask for advice. In much the same vain, Stamets' ego clashes with Tilly, who dares to suggest something to the Master of the Spores, and later with Detmer. The last time he reacted like that was in season 1. I just don't think that temporarily reverting character development is a good idea, only to demonstrate that something is wrong with the morale on the ship. I am relieved that Detmer is not possessed by an alien consciousness or even by Control but supposedly suffers from emotional emptiness (and perhaps PTSD). Yet, her conduct at the dining table, when she tries to phrase a haiku with the words "Stamets' blood" is simply awkward - probably intentionally so but I don't buy into it, especially since she never had any business with Stamets. She too has a relapse to generic unwarranted season 1 animosities, rather than this being anything that could be interpreted as a feeling of being disconnected.
Stamets' and Detmer's bad temper vanishes as quickly as it appeared, just because they make up their minds and because a movie night is uplifting, whereas a dinner with the captain, where he expresses his high esteem of the crew, obviously isn't. I am sorry for Saru, who doesn't deserve to be let down like that when he does everything in his power to encourage his people. But the whole plot is just too contrived to resonate with me.
The episode solves the probably biggest part of the mystery about Adira and elegantly combines this with a visit to a popular alien species, whose planet we last saw on DS9, more than 20 years ago. Like Earth in "People From Earth", Trill too has to cope with the aftermath of the Burn, which has left only few viable hosts (rather than symbionts, although we may infer from the statements of how precious Tal is that they too were decimated). Like Earth, Trill is a bit xenophobic, although the idea that a human may serve as a host might have been offensive as soon as at the time of DS9 (if we disregard the pre-reboot events of TNG: "The Host"). It feels a bit formulaic how in both episodes the leaders of an important planet learn from Burnham's example and eventually admit they were stubborn. Still, I like the new old Trek spirit that pervades this season, so I have no objection if this persists.
On a note about the telepathic connection of Burnham and Adira inside the pool, this is a new and bizarre aspect of the Trill, but the zhian'tara in DS9: "Facets" was arguably more unrealistic, so I wouldn't have a reason to complain. Yet, while I like the visualization with the threads that represent the attempts of the symbiont to connect with Adira, the idea of an illusory realm where people can walk around and talk with each other is trite by now, considering that we already know it from many occasions, most notably from the Prophets and only recently from the spore network.
It comes as a surprise that Gray (Ian Alexander) is already dead and initially only appears in flashbacks, considering that the Trill was announced as a regular character prior to the launch of season 3. Immediately killing off Star Trek's first transgender character seems like a very counterproductive decision. Yet, in a second surprise, Gray returns in person at the end of the episode as if he were still alive. So Gray will stay a series regular as some sort of ghost. A trans ghost? Sounds like a stretch to me. Future episodes will show if this works out, but just like with Adira's non-binary nature that is overshadowed by them hosting a "squid", it may have had more of an impact if the character was simply trans, without a caveat.
The one part of the episode that doesn't sit well with me at all is how Culber makes up reasons for Michael Burnham to join Adira on her visit to Trill. Why Burnham? She had no interaction with Adira so far. Why not Stamets? Or Culber himself? Why does it have to be Burnham every time? Culber tries hard to get it across but he absolutely fails to convince me. The reasoning that Burnham arrived in the 32nd century and, unlike everyone else, already gathered some experiences and that this would somehow give Adira more confidence is bullshit - especially since this comes from a doctor who might want to be present in case there are problems with whatever procedure Adira undergoes on Trill. It is too obviously a shameless attempt to ascribe a special qualification to her and to give Burnham the usual special significance she actually shouldn't have. It would have been a great opportunity for her to take a back seat and leave the action to someone else this time. And even with Burnham eventually making the shuttle trip with Adira anyway, it isn't worth making such a fuss about it, for like five minutes. Simply saying that she is the first officer after all would have been more than sufficient to justify her presence on the planet.
The more I think about it, the more I dislike the fabricated Burnham personality cult and the awkward B-plot. Still, "Forget Me Not" is an overall solid episode that I enjoyed a bit more than "People of Earth" with its overall comparable theme and tone.
- Vos says that "in 2000 years there hasn't been a single recorded instance of a successful joining between a symbiont and a non-Trill species." Implanting Odan into Riker's body in TNG: "The Host" was never meant to be permanent, and would hence not qualify as "successful", although "Will Odan" could access Odan's memories, whereas Adira has no connection to Tal.
- The Caves of Mak'ala previously appeared in DS9: "Equilibrium".
- Also in "Equilibrium", it was established that the Symbiosis Commission maintains the position that only a small percentage of humanoid Trills can act as a host, although it is actually more like 50%. At the time of DS9, there were far more aspiring hosts than symbionts, despite the efforts to limit access to the program. If hosts, rather than symbionts, are rare after the Burn, this could mean that the Trill officials still or again lie about the percentage of viable hosts among the population, as counterproductive as this is for the survival of the species.
- It looks like the computer of the Discovery begins to evolve to the AI Zora we know from SHO: "Calypso", thanks to the data from the Sphere. The voice actress is Annabelle Wallis, just as in "Calypso".
- Nitpicking: "Starfleet" and "Federation" are used totally interchangeably in the first four episodes of season 3, although there should be a difference between the two. While one could not exist without the other by the understanding of the Discovery crew, this may have changed by the 32nd century. Perhaps there are still planets that attempt to maintain the alliance but they mostly rely on their own ships? Vice versa, perhaps there is still a Starfleet out there but their scarce presence is not sufficient to tie together any planets that are in disarray or in isolation?
- Remarkably awkward dialogue: "The crew would benefit from exercise, medication, limited dairy..." - "Uh, beyond the standard parameters." - "Yoga, hyperbaric chamber, therapeutic coloring books, interstellar shopping." - "I do not need an endless list of activities. I-- I need something meaningful to heal my crew." (Computer and Saru, just before the AI kicks in with the suggestion to watch 20th century comedians)
- Remarkably awkward quote: "Okay, I have a squid, and you threw up in a wormhole. Things are pretty weird out here." (Adira, to Burnham)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Medical officer's log, supplemental. Our trip to Earth was eye-opening. A reality check, such as reality is. It's starting to hit everyone just how little we have to hold on to. The personal moments we use to define ourselves. Birthdays. Anniversaries. Graduations. Funerals. We've jumped past all of them. They feel lost. Disconnected. I tell them I've been alone. I've been lost. Both are survivable, and surviving can become living again. But first, they have to accept help." (Culber's log, interrupted by Detmer who pretends to be all fine)
- "The symbionts are a gift for everyone, not just the Trill, and I think I'm supposed to be that messenger." (Adira)
- Remarkable technology: The Mynh'ta orb serves to track Adira's isoboraline levels as she has entered the pool. The neural stabilizers are used after the globe has cracked and Adira has vanished.
Using the information obtained from Adira Tal, the Discovery finds its way to the combined Federation and Starfleet Headquarters. Saru, Burnham and Adira are beamed over and are greeted by Commander-in-Chief Charles Vance and Chief of Security Lt. Willa. Vance is mistrustful about the ship from the distant past. He says that the Discovery is going to be refitted, and the crew to be reassigned. A medical crisis ensues as Kili refugees are brought in, who suffer from a failure of their nervous system because of mutated proteins. Saru and Burnham see a chance for their crew to prove themselves and ask for the travel roster of the Kili. Among the planets they visited is Urna, which is deserted but used to be heavily industrialized and has a mutated plant life. The Kili can only be cured with the help of healthy plants from that planet, the seeds of which are stored on an a ship called Tikhov in a remote region of space. When Vance disapproves of Saru's proposal to take the Discovery there with the spore drive, Saru agrees to staying behind and letting a Starfleet security team with Willa join the mission. The Tikhov is caught in an ion storm, and there is initially no sign of the crew, a Barzan family. Culber and Nhan find three members of the family in cryostasis pods, the mother and her two daughters, but they are dead. Only Attis, the father, is still alive. Reno muses that when a coronal mass ejection (CME) hit the ship, he was just in a transporter beam and survived, but is out of phase since that event. The crew cuts power on the Tikhov and uses the transporter to put Attis into phase again. With his pass code, Burnham accesses the plant vault. Attis doesn't want to leave, a decision that Nhan understands. When Burnham says that they wouldn't leave Attis behind, Nhan decides to stay. Back at Federation Headquarters, the Kili can be cured. Burnham is puzzled by a melody that Adira played, that she heard on the Tikhov and that everyone in this otherwise disconnected galaxy seems to be familiar with. Also, Georgiou appears to be mentally absent after her debriefing with a Federation official.
The crew of the Discovery are on a very clear quest since they arrived in the 32nd century. Finding the Federation Headquarters and rejoining Starfleet is the next logical step on their journey. The arrival at the headquarters becomes an awe-inspiring moment for the crew, superficially because of the sheer amount of unknown technology but probably also because of the anticipation. Is Starfleet still the same at its heart after over 900 years? It seems so. Although coming home and taking time to let old wounds heal seems like a desirable goal, it becomes clear that at least Burnham is up to something far greater. She is not content with just being in Starfleet again but wants to solve the mystery of the Burn and ultimately to reunite the Federation.
The Discovery crew are honest about what brought them to the 32nd century and about all the crazy details. I think that they wouldn't have had another choice, considering that the goal is to continue to use the secret spore drive for Starfleet's benefit and that the existence of the Sphere data may come to light rather sooner than later. Likewise, Georgiou's true identity is not concealed any longer. So sincerity and transparency, as we would normally expect it from a Starfleet crew anyway, seems to pervade the story now. On the other hand, Saru says that "everything we have ever done was in accordance with the ideals of the Federation", which leaves me speechless because the violations of rules and principles in the first two seasons are too many to count. Saru may not agree with everything bad that was going on. But he, and to lesser extent his crew, is at least partially responsible for it.
The act set on the "jungle ship" is contrived. It was too clearly designed to add creepiness and danger to an otherwise relaxed story, without making much sense. I like how Nhan defends the views of her people a couple of times, which gives her a feeling of coming home and foreshadows that she would eventually stay on the Tikhov. Yet, I don't like the fabricated dichotomy that she would have to give up her career if she stayed behind. Also, while it is understandable that Airiam's sacrifice had an impact on Nhan as she already said in "Far From Home", I don't think that Burnham inspired her a lot. But for some reason, everyone is always immensely grateful for everything that Burnham did personally for them.
The perhaps biggest surprise about "Die Trying" is that Terran Emperor Philippa Georgiou can be an interesting character, for the very first time in the whole series as I think. She finally finds an equal opponent in the still unnamed interrogator with the glasses (the credits call him Kovich), played by David Cronenberg, who is both amusing and frightening. He is the probably best secret agent in Star Trek since Sloan. Georgiou's debriefing with this guy gives her the opportunity to say more than just the usual one-liners to people who either are afraid of her or wouldn't listen anyway. Their dialogues are very entertaining and among the highlights of the episode. And the fact that Georgiou is apparently weakened in some fashion at the end of the episode seems to point to her very first character development. Even though it is possible at this point that the interrogator belongs to Section 31 and may serve to kick off a new series that I don't want to see, there is a chance that the people in charge have reconsidered their idea that Star Trek needs mustache-twirling villains in monstrous starships to be exciting.
It is a bit disappointing that Adira more or less vanishes in the course of the episode, although their being the host to the Tal symbiont should give them a special significance. I may read too much into it, but the fact that Vance brushes them aside, saying something along the lines that he knows Senna Tal and that Adira still has to earn his trust, points to a possible conflict.
"Die Trying" is the Discovery episode that so far most definitely connects the chaotic 32nd century with the glorious past of the Federation. As already mentioned, there are countless spoken or visual references that point to things that are still the same and traditions that still exist despite all the hardships. In a way, it is also the episode with the most definite ties between this reboot series and the classic Star Trek. Even if we may see it as mere fan service in the first place, ship names such as USS Voyager and USS Nog, as well as other factoids, indicate that the timeline is supposed to be the same and that this 32nd century is the very future of the universe we known from Enterprise, TOS, TNG, DS9 and Voyager. Although we shouldn't forget Discovery's past of downright ignoring the canon, we might say that the series finally acts like it is a part of the family - a bit like the Discovery crew is eager to rejoin Starfleet.
The story about the Discovery arriving at Federation Headquarters, with the initial enthusiasm, the exasperating debriefing and the persisting mistrust is a bit of a no-brainer, maybe predictable but accordingly convincing. I was worried about how the Discovery crew possibly wanted to outperform 32nd century medical technology and help the Kili refugees but this plot thread too is resolved to my satisfaction, although much about it is contrived. We still have to wait what Georgiou is up to in the 32nd century, but for the first time I care a bit for her character. "Die Trying" is a comfortable episode that makes us feel at home in the 32nd century, albeit with some unnecessary fan service. This may be the so far best outing of the season.
- Saru explicitly mentions that the Federation and Starfleet are effectively one and the same in the 32nd century, explaining the mix-ups in the first four episodes.
- Vance says that Saru is likely the only Kelpien left with traces of the vahar'ai (DIS: "An Obol for Charon", "The Sound of Thunder"), which seems to imply that the generations that followed would not undergo this transformation, or that it would not leave such traces.
- When the crew spot USS Voyager NCC-74656-J, they muse about the ten or eleven design generations since the first ship of this name. The thing is, they can't know the original Voyager NCC-74656, they have no idea when the first ship of that name was commissioned, and they can only guess what the "J" means because appending a letter to the number is not a regular registry scheme.
- Georgiou says about holograms that "blinking at their harmonic rate disrupts their holo protocols, creating a reference loop that shuts them down". One would firmly expect that holographic technology has totally changed after 930 years, and that any old tricks she knows should be futile.
- The Tikhov has been around for over 930 years. This is a stretch, especially since nothing on the inside or on the outside looks remotely like it could be from the 23rd century. The ship is apparently supposed to have been replaced over and over again, as indicated by the registry "NCC-1067-M" that is briefly visible on Tilly's display. This should have been made clear, instead of saying "the Tikhov is still around", implying it is the very same ship.
- If the CME kills the crew immediately, wouldn't it also destroy the seeds, or lead to mutations? And even if the seeds are absolutely safe, wouldn't it be worth the effort to protect the crew likewise? Wouldn't it be a good idea to transfer the seeds to a bigger, stronger ship anyway? Wouldn't it be a good idea to have any kind of backup for the seeds, the ship, the crew or the password?
- Why is it that Nhan has to stay on the seed storage permanently when all the Federation needs is a temporary replacement? Especially considering that Nhan wouldn't have the required qualification and that someone would have to come and clean up the mess anyway?
- It is just an odd stylistic choice, but why does every visual effect involving real or artificial characters in the 32nd century look like pixel chunks or shards, whether they are being beamed, phasered, projected in the form of programmable matter or projected in the form of a hologram? Even Attis, who is out of phase, leaves a trail of shards as he moves.
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "So... you were dead?" - "Yes, as I said." - "Clinically dead?" - "Well, I was emotionally dead, too. And I was murdered. That can really do a number on you. But my murderer and I are good now." (interrogator and Culber)
- "So... you were on an asteroid, and...?" - "Commander Burnham fell out of the sky. With Captain Pike. It was raining Starfleet officers. Did you bring any snacks? I'm- I'm starving." (interrogator and Reno, who will get the snacks)
- "Dysfunction aside, you all make a pretty good team." - "Dysfunction is the team." - "We've just accepted it." - "No, we haven't." (Willa, Reno, Stamets)
- Remarkable quote: "Captain's log, supplemental. After a journey of 930 years and a return to Earth that we could not have anticipated, we are finally on the verge of reaching our destination: Federation and Starfleet headquarters. Separate entities that must now abide together. A sign of this new time, I suppose. I can only hope that they are as eager for us to arrive as we are to be home." (Saru's log entry)
- Remarkable scene: After Georgiou's "blinking out" of the interrogators sitting at the table, who turn out to be holograms, the only real person left is the elderly man, who initially looked like he was a hologram.
- Remarkable technology: The Federation of the 32nd century uses neutronium alloy fibers, ships with organic hulls, ships with holographic containment walls, detached warp nacelles, and scanners that are capable of picking up the symbiont in Adira. One Federation ship looks like a "flying rainforest".
- Remarkable ships: There is a "new Constitution", a USS Voyager NCC-74656-J, a scout with unknown range, a USS Nog NCC-325070 and a USS Armstrong.
- Remarkable homage: The USS Nog NCC-325070 is named in honor of Aron Eisenberg (1969-2019).
- Remarkable facts:
- Scientists found a "chimeric strain on the subatomic level in the Terran stem cell". The last known crossing between the two universes was as long as 500 years ago.
- The Emerald Chain is the name of the Andorian-Orion Syndicate. The USS Cuyahoga picked up their traces at Sigma Draconis.
- Nhan's serial number is SFB534-0679.
- The two Barzan girls were named Amma and Tolpra, after two moons in their home system.
- The Burn occurred around 3069.
- After a peak of 350, only 38 Federation member worlds are left. Kaminar and Barzan joined the Federation and are apparently still members as of 3189. There may be more worlds that consider themselves members but are out of communications range.
The USS Discovery NCC-1031-A has been retrofitted with 32nd century technology, including detached warp nacelles, programmable matter interfaces and personal transporter badges for the crew. As the ship is waiting to be dispatched to Argeth, where it may be needed to resolve a crisis, Booker's ship arrives at the cloaking field perimeter, with just his cat Grudge aboard. A pre-recorded message from three weeks ago says that he was going to a salvage yard of the Emerald Chain on the planet Hunhau, to retrieve a black box from a ship that was destroyed in the Burn. Michael Burnham is eager to retrieve this third box to triangulate the origin of the Burn. Against Saru's direct order, Burnham and Georgiou take Booker's ship and set a course for his last known coordinates. When they arrive at the salvage yard, they pretend to be traders and are welcomed by Tolor, a nephew of Emerald Chain leader Osyraa. Burnham spots Book among Tolor's workers and is waiting for an opportunity to talk to him. A system that kills anyone who is accordingly tagged and crosses the perimeter assures that the inmates wouldn't escape, which Tolor demonstrates on a Bajoran inmate who is caught stealing. Meanwhile on the Discovery, Adira has upgraded the spore drive interface and also offers Stamets to improve his implants. They reveal that Gray is still present in their mind although he was killed, which sounds familiar to Stamets. On Hunhau, Burnham and Book use a moment of distraction, in which Book says that he has the black box and that the shift change in 43 minutes may be an opportunity to escape. Burnham tells Tolor she would need more time to examine the merchandise. Having waited long enough, she sets off an alert and is apprehended by Tolor, together with Georgiou. As Tolor and his guards are investigating Book's ship, the prisoners, led by Book and an Andorian called Ryn, use the shift change for their revolt. Ryn is wounded when he takes a shot meant for Book. Burnham tries to profit from the distraction and to overwhelm Tolor, as the prisoners are waiting for someone to deactivate the perimeter pylons. But Georgiou experiences a flashback and passes out. When she regains consciousness, she grabs the control unit and takes the fence down just before Tolor manages to beam away. Burnham and Georgiou take Book's ship to help the prisoners and attack the guards. They beam up Book and Ryn, while the rest can escape in a transport. Back at Federation Headquarters, Saru relieves Burnham of duty as his first officer.
Cleveland Booker is the Running Man! I have a soft spot for classic Arnold Schwarzenegger movies and I don't mind that this Discovery episode takes some cues from the prison escape from "The Running Man" (1987). It works for me that the obligatory scene in which the villain demonstrates the efficiency of his perimeter fence is unusually graphic for Star Trek. And it comes as a positive surprise that Ryn, the usual tragic character, survives after catching the phaser beam meant for Book. Overall, this part of the story of "Scavengers" is a solid action thriller, a bit clichéd but quite entertaining and visually impressive. There is also a pattern of sorts in the so far six season 3 episodes that whenever Book shows up, things don't go by the book, and we are in for a lot more action.
One detail I don't like about the prison escape is that Burnham gives Book a cue about something they did on Iso VII. As already a similar reference in "People of Earth", this serves to establish a plan without revealing anything about it while insinuating a familiarity of the characters that exactly know what the other one is talking of. It is a lame excuse for not wasting time to explain things and shouldn't be used repeatedly.
"Die Trying" already foreshadowed that Burnham's mission is not fulfilled by finding Starfleet, and that she, apparently unlike anyone else, is determined to find out what caused the Burn. A third black box salvaged from a destroyed ship may be a decisive clue on her quest because each explosion happened at a slightly different time, which may allow to pinpoint the origin of the Burn via triangulation. This is a pleasantly realistic scientific concept after all the crap that pervaded the first two seasons of the series, especially when compared to the mess about the timing of the Red Angel signals that never made any sense.
Regarding Burnham's insubordination when she leaves the ship against her orders, Saru really seems to have ignored or forgotten what happened in "People of Earth", as I already mused in the review of that episode. While not acting against a direct order, her conduct back then was reckless; it endangered everyone on the ship and the whole mission. But it remained without any consequences. Other than continuing to ignore that, the story of "Scavengers" becomes both more complex and more consequential in this regard than we may have hoped for.
Book's disappearance gives Burnham an additional personal motivation to set out and find him and the black box. As Admiral Vance points out, he may have agreed to the mission, had he been asked in advance. Still, it is understandable that Burnham would rather act without authorization, as have many other Trek characters before her in similar situations, perhaps most notably Captain Kirk's crew in "Star Trek III". It also stands to reason that Saru would seek someone's advice in this matter, although Tilly, as a junior officer and as Burnham's closest friend, doesn't exactly seem the best choice. But Tilly unexpectedly recommends Saru to report Burnham instead of trying to cover up her absence. While I still don't think that he should have asked Tilly of all people for advice, what better confirmation could Saru find for his course of action? That is why this part of the story works for me. It was obvious that this time neither Vance nor Saru would simply forget what happened, and I acknowledged with a certain satisfaction how Burnham lost her position as the first officer. Sometimes you do the right thing, and yet you are penalized for it. It happens to many of us at some time in our lives and shouldn't be glossed over in a TV series either. While I am glad she accepts the decision, I only wish that Burnham could have done it without crying. This is becoming just too much. My impression is that since season 2 she bursts out in tears every time she experiences a strong emotion, be it pain, guilt, desperation, happiness or anything else.
As for Georgiou's role in the episode, it makes sense for her to join Burnham's mission because she has nothing to lose and she can be useful when dealing with thugs. I am also delighted that, a bit like in last week's interrogation, Georgiou does more than react sarcastically to cues. I think it may be the first time in the series she has a no-nonsense conversation with someone of the crew. At some point, it even seems like Burnham likes her and confides in her. On the other hand, this looks like a further steps in Georgiou's unwarranted redemption that I already criticized in my season 2 reviews. We must not forget that she was Space-Hitler! And just like Hitler was not a nice guy because he loved dogs, Georgiou does not become a better person as Burnham or we get to know her, or as we feel with her with regard to her obvious suppressed trauma.
In a small B-plot, Adira impresses Stamets with their engineering knowledge, and reveals that Gray, the dead former host of the Tal symbiont, is still present in their mind. Although what happens is rather predictable (knowing that Stamets of all people has experience with not-so-dead lovers) and not very conclusive either, I like this little diversion in an overall suspenseful story. And regarding the continued existence of Gray, it is overall a lot more credible in comparison with what happened to Hugh Culber.
Regarding the detached nacelles, I can't say I'm a fan of the idea to give up physical connections between parts of the ship. The necessary forcefields to keep the programmable matter in place expend energy for something that duranium would provide for free. But more importantly, the free-floating nacelles just don't look good.
I enjoyed "Scavengers", and especially its action-loaded parts. The episode confirms that Discovery is on a good course in its third season, with character-focused stories that make sense and have consequences, without excessive sidetracking and with a decent amount of action. None of the episodes so far really stood out, but the improvement since the deplorable seasons 1 and 2 is considerable.
- When the USS Cuyahoga returns from a mission, the ship is to undergo a baryon sweep, as prominently seen in TNG: "Starship Mine".
- Georgiou and Burnham express an interest in "self-sealing stembolts from the late 24th century", which of course is a reference to DS9: "Progress". Furthermore, one of the ancient items is a late 24th century Type-2 phaser as used on Voyager.
- Relabeling the Discovery to "NCC-1031-A" may be an attempt to hold up the official story that the ship was destroyed 930 years ago. Either that, or the very rare letter suffixes are not used consistently anyway and don't necessarily denote a new ship of the same name.
- Nitpicking: Did anyone authorize Adira to retrofit the spore drive? Stamets is obviously surprised but doesn't mind at all, just as already when Adira tampered with the ship's systems in "People of Earth".
- Remarkable dialogue: "Oh shit. Sh... shit... shit. Sorry." - "My sentiment exactly." (Tilly and Saru, on Burnham's unauthorized departure)
- Remarkably cheesy dialogue: "All right. You're cleared to land. But I've got my eyes on you." - "I don't care about your eyes unless they're dangling from my belt." (Tolor and Georgiou)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "I rather regret something I did than something I didn't." (Burnham)
- "This is not the Terran universe. A vulnerability is not a death sentence." (Burnham, to Georgiou)
- Remarkable cat quotes:
- "That cat can't get lost. It's got its own gravitational pull." (Georgiou)
- "Did you eat her?" (Tilly, to Grudge, while looking for Burnham)
- Remarkable running gag: While trying to familiarize himself with the personal transporter, Linus materializes in various unexpected places.
- Remarkable technologies:
- The detached nacelles are said to "improve maneuverability" for a "more efficient flight".
- The new comm badge comes with an integrated holographic interface, a tricorder and a personal transporter.
- Adira upgrades the spore drive interface with "nanogel as a quantum transducer". Stamets says it feels gooey but it leaves no residue.
- Remarkable ships: We can see several Discovery-style ships from the 23rd century(!) above the salvage yard, among them a Cardenas class, two Hiawatha types and two Hoover classes.
- Remarkable facts:
- Admiral Vance calls the upgraded Discovery a "rapid responder" and keeps the spore drive a secret.
- A woman named Osyraa is a leader of the Emerald Chain.
- The antennae of the Andorian Ryn were hacked of as a punishment when he spoke out against the Emerald Chain.
- It appears that Georgiou once lost someone called San (or son?).
The data from the three black boxes is not sufficient to triangulate the origin of the Burn in three-dimensional space. But it looks to Michael Burnham like SB-19, a research project that Admiral Vance so far assumed to have caused the disaster, cannot be responsible. Vance sends the Discovery on a mission to Ni'Var, formerly known as Vulcan. The Vulcans had reunited with the Romulans, as a result of Spock's diplomatic initiative. When dilithium became scarce, Ni'Var built SB-19 to investigate new forms of space travel. They decided it was too dangerous, but the Federation urged them to carry on regardless. The planet eventually left the Federation. In orbit of Ni'Var, President T'Rina refuses to share the data about SB-19. Burnham invokes the T'Kal-in-ket, a traditional scientific discourse based on pure logic, to discuss her new theory about the Burn, which would require Ni'Var to release the data once her theory is taken into consideration. The Vulcan leader arrives on the Discovery with a quorum consisting of N'Raj, a Romulan elder, V'Kir, a Vulcan purist and Shira, a representative of the Romulo-Vulcans. The shalankkai or sha-set, Michael Burnham's advocate, turns out to be no one else but her mother, who has joined the Qovat Milat after arriving in the 32rd century. During the T'Kal-in-ket, particularly V'Kir is opposed to Michael's theory, although she attempts to reason with as much logic as possible. The meeting is quickly adjourned because of the obvious lack of progress. Gabrielle Burnham notices that her daughter is not honest about her motives. When the T'Kal-in-ket resumes, she calls out Michael's lack of openness, ostensibly acting against her. The discourse gains momentum up to a point when N'Raj is ready to share the SB-19 data, against V'Kir's vehement objections. In order not to endanger the peace on Ni'Var, Michael decides to retract her request. Back in her quarters, her mother reveals that her plan was to win over T'Rina, rather than the three members of the quorum. She hands Michael the requested data. In the meantime, Saru has offered Tilly the position as his first officer, which she accepts after consulting with her higher-ranking crewmates.
Let me preface this review with a midterm evaluation. Although Discovery's third season is set in an entirely unclaimed era where everything would be possible to happen, it so far has the air of a "Star Trek's Greatest Hits" album, featuring new recordings of the Orion Syndicate, Earth, Trill, Starfleet, and now Vulcans and Romulans. As much as they all have changed, as much they stay the same. It seems that every planet, every species and every concept that mattered in the past gets revisited. And that they all have the same significance 930 years later, despite the dramatic paradigm shifts because of the Burn and despite anything else that may have happened during this very long time. The album comes with remixes for that matter, but there are not the promised new songs. There are neither fundamentally new perspectives nor previously unknown threats in this universe, whose ships have whimsical detached warp nacelles but can hardly go to warp at all. Everyone in the 32nd century seems to be look backing, only waiting for Michael Burnham, a person from the distant past, to bring dilithium and lift the spirits. I never would have thought I'd say this, but Discovery plays safe and plays nice in its third season. This is not to the disadvantage of the series, as it finally has a clear direction and respects the canon. But I would expect more from it. More of a vision of the future instead of one of the past, and just as well more obstacles or even setbacks on that way. I appreciate how Saru and Burnham are trying to put the band back together, but I am still waiting for them to perform a gig.
"Unification III" continues the trend of going where no one has been in a long time, 790 years in the case of the Vulcans and Romulans. As soon as I spotted the episode title a few weeks ago, I was apprehensive because this blatantly direct reference to the classic TNG episode with Leonard Nimoy as Spock feels presumptuous. Yet, I think that the references are apt and don't insult or damage the original. Overall, Discovery has never before been so deeply rooted in Trek lore, but that doesn't mean it is automatically great Star Trek.
I didn't really expect Michael Burnham to become less important in season 3 and I don't even think it would have been desirable. But I would have hoped for her to excel as a Starfleet officer and to grow as a human being, instead of always having a sui generis status. Unfortunately, Discovery is The Michael Burnham Show all over again, maybe even more clearly than ever before. Since "People of Earth", Burnham keeps musing about how much she has changed since her arrival in the 32nd century and how she is uncertain that the Discovery is still her home. For me, this raises the question if she has ever been an integral part of the crew and if anything about her has changed at all (besides her hairstyle). In season 1, Michael Burnham was an outsider, a "specialist" who for some reason knew and did everything and was crucial for every single mission of the ship. In season 2, she had regained her rank but still acted like a renegade on many occasions because she felt like she had to save the galaxy single-handedly. The Michael Burnham of season 3 isn't different in these regards. Her alleged change and the doubts about where she belongs are unwarranted sidetracking in hindsight, and there is currently no sign she could actually become a more modest and more relatable character.
We are told that no one but Michael Burnham could possibly lead the diplomatic talks with the Vulcans. It makes sense in the story, but that is because the whole plot was constructed in the first place with her as the pivotal point. And even if we accept her invariable role as a very special person that everything in the series is subordinated to, it would have been a lot more agreeable without it being mentioned repeatedly. In "Unification III", this culminates in several statements along the lines of "Michael Burnham saved the whole galaxy" or "Without her, Spock would never have become such a great man". Book's ironic remark of her (and subsequently Spock) being "chronic over-achievers" doesn't really help to make the melodramatic character worshipping more acceptable.
This story tries to show the downside of being awesome too. In fact, many uncomfortable truths about Michael Burnham are spoken out, by her mother, by Saru, by Tilly, by Booker and by herself. She is not honest about what she really wants, neither to herself nor to others. She tries to fill the emotional void in her with taking responsibility for each and everything. She doesn't recognize that life consists of duty and joy that complement each other. I agree with everything that is said about her. On second thought, however, it doesn't fit together to a bigger picture. Everyone just states the obvious. We know she was always like that, it was repeatedly mentioned in the past and it most likely won't change in the future. Also, it doesn't help to explain why Burnham would have doubts about her being on the Discovery in the first place, and why she would suddenly make up her mind. It only works well regarding Gabrielle Burnham's unexpected ad hominem arguments against her daughter in the T'Kal-in-ket.
Well, the T'Kal-in-ket isn't exactly the occasion where Michael Burnham's emotional state should have a bearing anyway. The Vulcans (at least the ones before the time of the reunification) simply wouldn't care about her motivation when the goal is to find out the truth. It should have been more about facts and less about candor. Likewise, on the side of the quorum from Ni'Var it should have been less about politics and more about science. Other than that, the T'Kal-in-ket is a welcome addition to the Vulcan lore. Discovery was marked by haphazard decisions and actions in its first two seasons, and whenever an issue was seriously discussed, it lacked profoundness and felt like squeezed in more like a filler. This has changed in the third season, and the battle of words with the quorum from Ni'Var is the best proof so far, although it is not quite as meaningful as it perhaps could be.
Saru's decision to appoint Tilly to his first officer only makes sense if we take into account that Discovery has no ensemble cast and that the ensign is the only available character. It would have been more realistic for Saru to ask Nilsson, Owosekun, Detmer, Rhys or Bryce, but they are just not meant to have bigger roles.
In an episode that takes its inspiration and title from a classic TNG episode and that tells us of the reunification of Vulcans and Romulans, I would have expected to see a bit of the planet. Unfortunately "Unification III" was turned into a bottle show and is set entirely aboard the ship.
The only completely satisfying aspect of the episode is to see Saru as a skilled diplomat. I take it that his unassumingness, respectfulness and astuteness made just the same or even more of an impact on T'Rina as Burnham's "being special".
As already hinted at in the introduction, "Unification III" is a remix on the "Star Trek's Greatest Hits" album. Unfortunately the reunification of the Vulcans and the Romulans is rather gratuitous so far, and doesn't have a further significance, except perhaps boosting Burnham's ego. The episode definitely could have been better, had it not been conceived as yet another tearful melodrama about Michael Burnham. Also, it is a pity that the striking premise was turned into a bottle show that takes place on the Discovery. Still, I appreciate that Discovery can be Star Trek and can honor its rich history.
- The Romulans and Vulcans were reunited after a process that probably lasted centuries, but as a result of an initiative that Ambassador Spock started, as seen in TNG: "Unification I + II". The recording of Spock (Leonard Nimoy) is from that double episode.
- Gabrielle Burnham arrived in the 32rd century on the planet Essof IV, just like already in DIS: "Perpetual Infinity". She then joined the Qovat Milat, as seen in PIC: "Absolute Candor".
- Like Star Trek: Picard, Discovery makes no mention of Spock's futile effort to save Romulus in "Star Trek (2009)". The fact that Romulus was destroyed is hinted at only indirectly, by the fact that the Romulans now live on Ni'Var.
- Tabloid journalists use unwieldy units such as "millionths of a microsecond". Everyone who knows science would say "picoseconds". And what is "seven one millionth of a microsecond" anyway? 71 picoseconds, 7.1 picoseconds, or rather 7 picoseconds? This is very indefinite.
- The way Admiral Vance talks about it, it is an open secret that SB-19 is believed to have caused the Burn. So why is it that no one has told Michael Burnham about that theory, especially since it has been known as her pet peeve for quite a while? She stumbles across SB-19 in a database more by accident, so there is no secrecy about it.
- Likewise, why is it a total surprise to Saru and Burnham that the Vulcans and Romulans are related, that they reunited and that they left the Federation? It must have been several weeks since they rejoined Starfleet and had access to all official data (such as the recording of Spock on Romulus, which isn't classified any longer). Sure, there may have been more urgent tasks at hand, but checking out a few basic facts about which planets are members and what happened to former members and enemies would have been of importance, not to mention a very personal matter for Burnham.
- Going to Ni'Var without an acting first officer is a bad idea.
- Although the Vulcans have been apprised of the mission, it is another bad idea that the Discovery, on a diplomatic mission, jumps directly into the orbit of a non-member planet, circumventing all of its sensors and defenses.
- Just like back in the days of Star Trek: Voyager, the writers of Discovery don't seem to understand the difference between power generation and propulsion. Dilithium is used in the warp core, and as such a part of the power generation. The propulsion takes place in the nacelles, and the plasma flowing through it is nothing more than some form of electric current that powers the warp coils. It is impossible to build a transwarp or slipstream drive by just making some adjustments to the warp core. Vice versa, exploring new kinds of propulsion such as the Vulcans did with SB-19 would be of no help, unless they also find a new power source that doesn't require dilithium. That being said, we already know of alternative power sources on starships, such as the quantum singularity. It almost definitely doesn't need dilithium because it doesn't operate on antimatter and its existence sort of refutes the whole premise of season 3. Hinting at this Romulan technology and at possible reasons why it can't be used would have made a lot more sense in the story of "Unification III".
- Remarkable dialogue: "In its desire to serve the many, the Federation ignored the needs of the few." - "Did your ancestors not coin the phrase, 'The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few'?" - "When the people of Vulcan welcomed the Romulans home, we were forced to confront centuries of mistrust and brutality on both sides. Over time and with much effort, we earned the wisdom to know when to let go of maxims and proverbs." (T'Rina and Saru)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "You guys are chronic over-achievers." (Book, about Spock and Michael)
- "Part of leadership is the acknowledgment that one is suited to it." (Saru, to Tilly)
- "It has been my experience that we learn our greatest lessons when we pay a heavy price." (Saru, to T'Rina)
- Remarkable homage: The USS Yelchin is named in honor of Anton Yelchin (1989-2016).
- Remarkable facts:
- The three black boxes that Burnham recovered are from the USS Yelchin, the USS Gav'Nor and the USS Giacconi.
- Ni'Var left the Federation over a hundred years ago. There were disagreements before, but the failure of SB-19 was the final straw.
- The Romulo-Vulcans, represented by Shira, appear to be Vulcan-Romulan hybrids.
Talking to Dr. Culber, Georgiou is very reluctant but eventually agrees to a complete scan of her body to get to the bottom of her neurological disorder. She hacks into the scan results and it looks like she is dying. Book receives a message from his homeworld Kwejian that Osyraa, the Emerald Chain leader, threatens the planet with destruction. He requests the Discovery to interfere, but Admiral Vance only approves of an observer mission. On the Discovery, Stamets and Adira combine the already known data about the Burn with the new one obtained from Ni'Var, tracing the origin to the Verubin nebula. They also discover an audio signal that is being sent from there, which manifests itself as music but is heavily distorted. After filtering out natural sounds from a neutron star, it all boils down to a Federation distress signal. Adira sets out to also decode the embedded message. Burnham beams down to Kwejian with Booker where they meet Kyheem, his old friend. Unlike Book, Kyheem maintains an old deal with the Emerald Chain that provides the planet with a repellant against sea locusts that would eat the harvest, in exchange for the valued tranceworms. After killing her nephew for his failure on Hunhau, Osyraa sets a course for Kwejian. When her heavily armed cruiser shows up in orbit, she demands the extradition of the Andorian Ryn, the former Emerald Chain member, who is still aboard the Discovery. Saru refuses. In order to emphasize her demands, she fires photon torpedoes at the protective shields of the Sanctuary on Kwejian, which begin to weaken. In order not to cause a diplomatic incident, Tilly comes up with the idea that a "rogue Federation officer" could attack the cruiser with Book's ship and target the vulnerable spots that Ryn knows of, a task that falls to Detmer. On the planet, Kyheem gets into a fight with Book over the question of Ryn, but they eventually agree to work together. Osyraa has to retreat after her ship has taken damage. Book and Kyheem establish a telepathic link with the sea locusts, which is boosted with help from the Discovery to drive the creatures back into the sea. Back on the Discovery, Book tells Burnham that he considers to stay on the ship.
Like every previous episode of season 3, "The Sanctuary" further fleshes out topics that have been addressed before, Book's homeworld and the Emerald Chain in this case, while continuing the search for the origin of the Burn. I appreciate that the series remains on track. However, we have to consider that the Discovery is now a Starfleet ship on standby for missions that Admiral Vance should have to decide about (and a bit like a precious battleship confined to the harbor because the sea is swarming with enemy torpedo boats). Yet, for the fourth week in a row he has to recognize that this ship and crew operates outside the chain of command. This doesn't have to be bad, but it is becoming formulaic how the Discovery crew always overrule the good admiral and turn out to be right after all. He, like the rest of Starfleet, is reduced to a mere bystander.
I appreciate how Michael Burnham's role is cut down to a normal Starfleet officer this week, who is capable and responsible. Even more than the mere fact of her being a VIP by virtue of her history and her personality, it has become exasperating how everyone isn't getting tired to mention just that. In "The Sanctuary", she prudently leaves most of the talking and of the action to Booker, which makes a lot of sense because it is his home planet and his old friend after all. I would even go as far as saying that Burnham initially follows Book into this adventure a bit like a teenage girl in love, who finds everything related to her boy just awesome and who only steps out of his shadow as his old gang gets him into trouble.
Adira's coming out as non-binary to Stamets at this point of the season may seem contrived. It may have been better to simply establish Adira as a "they" from the start. Is LGBTQ still a thing in the 32nd century, so much that they could only confide in a fellow "marginalized" person? Well, but I don't mind if they break the fourth wall. Rather than that, I am relieved that Adira really is non-binary and that in the press releases the actor and the role weren't mixed up in a way that would have given certain people a reason to attack the series for not keeping promises.
It doesn't come as a surprise that Georgiou's brain dysfunction is not just a temporary trauma. Whether the guy with the glasses infected her with a deadly disease or whether it has to do with the interdimensional thing, Discovery returns to the old tradition of mystery-mongering in this regard. Unfortunately, the tradition of Georgiou's hackneyed supervillain speak is back as well. After a couple of episodes in which she sounded half-way like a human being, Georgiou is a cruel and overbearing cartoon Nazi all over again: "If I had time, I'd poison your children." Culber endures all this with his professional tenaciousness when she is his patient. For anyone else on either side of the TV screen it is a needless pain to listen to Georgiou. And the perhaps biggest mystery is why Michael Burnham should feel attached to a person who frequently threatens to kill her friends - and might just do that for all we know! While it is very annoying, at least I am glad for the reminder of who Georgiou really is.
Regarding mysteries about characters, I am grateful that there seemingly isn't one about Detmer any longer. I think now that she has shown what she can do in terms of piloting, her PTSD will likely not be an issue any longer. This is unrealistic but it is how TV series always used to work.
I enjoyed the action sequence with Detmer and Ryn on Book's ship against Osyraa's cruiser and how it is visualized. However, it comes with the four probably biggest space battle clichés:
- You take a tiny ship into the fight you have never piloted before.
- Your big mean enemy ship has exactly one weak spot, and there is exactly one person who knows about it.
- You fly close to the enemy ship's hull because it has no close-range defense.
- You switch to manual control because automatic stuff is too slow or unreliable (and not enough fun).
Speaking of clichés, the planet on which everyone and everything is connected and is in balance is nothing new. We've already had a similar story along the lines of "Avatar" in the first-season episode "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum". Fortunately the idea is not wasted this time but is an essential part of Book's backstory that was established in "That Hope is You, Part I" and that will hopefully be further explored in future episodes. It may not have been clearly established, but I take it that Book is an alien and not human as I initially thought.
One general point of criticism is that the technology of the 32nd century is selectively limited. Sure, there are nifty devices such as the personal transporter, and we may buy into the reasoning that interstellar travel without dilithium is impossible. But Kwejian is another example of a planet that just doesn't seem to use its resources. They do have the technology to erect an impermeable shield to protect their wildlife, but driving away the sea locusts from their crops or finding an alternative that they wouldn't eat isn't possible for some reason. The Emerald Chain may not want their planets to become too independent, but then they would care more and wouldn't have allowed Kwejian to build the protective shield in the first place. The organization has formidable ships, but rather than building industries (or controlling the ones on their planets) they engage in small-scale bartering and only seem to be interested in scrap metal, memorabilia and livestock.
It is obvious that we will see her again, but Osyraa is an underwhelming villain so far. It is clichéd how she gruesomely kills her nephew for his failure just as in about every cheap gangster flick. And despite her big ship she poses a relatively mild threat to Kwejian and to the Discovery. Maybe there is more to Ryn than his secret(!?) knowledge about the Emerald Chain running out of dilithium. But for now, it doesn't make sense that Osyraa would bother to apprehend and kill him.
Lower Decks unexpectedly beat Discovery to the idea of a captain pondering about a catchphrase like Pike has one with "Hit it!" I take it that Discovery, originally set to air first, was meant to be the serious version. I don't really notice a difference though.
Overall, "The Sanctuary" is an enjoyable episode with a decent amount of action and of science fiction themes, but not a great one. While Burnham is pleasantly humble this time, Georgiou becomes a major nuisance all over again. There is some progress regarding the mystery of the Burn, but the "one step at a time" approach in B-plots isn't very rewarding. We learn more about Book's homeworld and about the Emerald Chain, but nothing really exciting or unexpected.
- Is it a good idea to give Detmer Book's ship that she most likely never piloted before? How could she enter or activate it anyway? I doubt that Booker would leave his keys behind.
- So the "big secret" that Osyraa has to kill Ryn for is that the Emerald Chain is running out of dilithium, a substance that is known to be extremely scarce? Uhm, yes.
- Remarkably cheesy dialogues:
- "If I had time, I'd poison your children." - "If I had time, I'd have children." (Georgiou and Culber)
- "Her heart rate is elevated." - "It's rage." (Culber and Georgiou)
- "Can you tell us what you experienced?" - "I was having a beautiful dream about how your head would look on my wall." (Culber and Georgiou)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "There's a problem in my brain. Ergo, I dressed like a human spermatozoon." (Georgiou, as she wears the highly conductive suit)
- "What is this? What's that noise it's making?" (Ryn, about Grudge, the cat)
- Remarkable facts:
- When the Burn struck, subspace damage shifted the orbit of Kwejian's moon, which changed the tides and made the sea locusts travel landward and devour the harvest. In order to fight the famine, Kwejian accepted help from the Emerald Chain to repel the creatures without killing them. In exchange, however, the Emerald Chain received tranceworms that are native to the planet.
- According to Admiral Vance, 50 other star systems are in the same predicament as Kwejian.
- Kwejian is two weeks away from Federation Headquarters at maximum warp. Using the transwarp conduit has a chance of survival of barely 50%, according to Burnham.
According to Kovich, who lets Dr. Culber in on the problems of interdimensional travel, there is no cure for former Emperor Georgiou, who has traveled both to another time and another universe and therefore increasingly loses cohesion. Culber is not content with this assessment and asks the Discovery's computer for possible help. The computer, which has accumulated the Sphere data, suggests that there is a small chance of success on the planet Dannus V, but without giving any details. Although Saru disapproves of the mission because of the needs of the many in light of the threat posed by the Emerald Chain, Admiral Vance complies with Burnham's wish to take Georgiou to that planet. In the meantime, Stamets and Adira have completed the decoding of the embedded message from the Verubin nebula. It dates back to the time just before the Burn and comes from the Kelpien Starfleet vessel KSF Khi'eth. On Dannus V, Burnham and Georgiou walk through an ice desert. Suddenly, a door appears, along with a man named Carl who is reading about Philippa Georgiou's death in tomorrow's newspaper. Georgiou steps through the door and finds herself on the ISS Discovery, back in the 22nd century of her universe. It is the day of the christening ceremony of the imperial flagship ISS Charon, the day when Lorca betrayed her with the help of Michael Burnham. Georgiou notices that Saru is among her servants, and she spares his life so he can spy for her. As the christening ceremony ensues, Georgiou unexpectedly kills Stamets for conspiring with Lorca and Burnham. But she decides to spare Michael Burnham...
Since the time Star Trek is serialized anyway, I have given up my tradition to wait for the conclusion of two-part episodes so I can review them as one. I don't want to change the policy yet again. However, it is hard to assess "Terra Firma I" because the direction it will be going next week is still totally open. Much of what currently doesn't make sense may turn out logical, and vice versa. Much of what annoys me right now may be just a red herring. At least that is what I hope. This is quite a contrast to "Such Sweet Sorrow I", an episode that readily gave away almost everything that would happen in its second part.
I am aware that uncertainty by design is the spice of two-parters, in an effort to perhaps create something as memorable as the cliffhanger in "The Best of Both Worlds I". But the lack of a veritable cliffhanger is one of the minor problems of "Terra Firma I".
Most frustratingly, the episode gambles away its relevance by picking up the story arc of the Mirror Universe from the first season, which was the absolute low point of the whole series for me and which I would have hoped was buried for good. The Mirror Universe had little to do with Discovery, at a time when Discovery had little to do with Star Trek in the first place. I just don't care for Emperor Philippa Georgiou Genus Falsum Stupidus Podex quidquid and her universe at all, where everyone human is a grimacing villain - a fun part for the actors, aggravating for me. It is bad enough that, in preparation of this stunt, since last week Georgiou is suddenly overly spiteful and unnecessarily violent all over again. A whole universe filled with this unwarranted viciousness is something that defies the very idea of Star Trek. The excuse that it has been done before doesn't work, especially since the bulk of Mirror-themed episodes in classic Trek in DS9, as much as I disliked some of those too, still had characters in different shades of dark gray and had a tongue-in-cheek undertone to it. In Discovery, the difference between humans and Terrans is not a "what if" scenario any longer but is marked by pure racism, such as in the statements of Kovich about Georgiou. As much as I hate Georgiou's conduct when she becomes all Terran again, judging people by their origin is utterly unworthy of Star Trek.
Only Georgiou's interaction with Saru, who is not perverted like the human/Terran characters, accounts for some decent moments. And although I loathe the ship design, I sort of like the christening ceremony of the Charon. Quite a show!
Furthermore, the episode returns to the mystery-mongering about what is actually happening and why. We will learn next week whether Georgiou really is in the past of the Mirror Universe, and whether she really changes history (which I doubt). We will see whether Jason Isaacs appears as Lorca or whether the frequent mentions of his name will appear as anticlimactic in hindsight. It may be revealed who this Carl guy is and why he would offer a portal to another time, dimension or whatever. And it is still open whether the "temporal soldier" in the season 1 TNG uniform will remain a throwaway note to create continuity or will have further relevance. Only one thing is clear. It seems like Georgiou will survive but will leave the series one way or another, to be available for the Section 31 show that Kurtzman still pursues in spite of the overwhelmingly negative feedback from the fanbase.
For the first 20 minutes, before it gets confusing and eventually irritating, "Terra Firma I" is much like the preceding four episodes. Although it is the clear intention of Admiral Vance to keep the ship out of harm's way, the crew wants to go on a mission with a personal motivation. The only advancement is that this time Vance agrees immediately to try to save Georgiou, even against Saru's concerns. Vance as the ultimate yes person of Star Trek is very uninteresting and weak, unless the writers still have something up their sleeves regarding his agenda.
Once again, the arguably much more interesting part of the story arc, the search for the origin of the Burn, takes place only in the B-plot. I would love to see how Stamets and Adira's efforts pay out, or have any kind of consequences. The story is drawn out way too much by now.
"Terra Firma I" may appear less annoying in hindsight, after seeing the second part. But right now it is the definite low point of the third season, with a dreary part set in our universe, followed by an exasperating one in the Mirror Universe.
- This is the very first time in Star Trek that the Kelvin Timeline is referred to from without. In Star Trek: Picard's first season, only the Romulan supernova was mentioned, and was described very differently than in "Star Trek (2009)", and without the slightest hint of Spock's futile effort and a possible time travel. "Terra Firma I", in contrast, directly confirms the existence of the timeline from the Abrams movies. Moreover, it is now clear that it is a different universe not unlike the Mirror Universe, and not one of the usual instances where time travels generate parallel timelines that annihilate the known history.
- What is the reason for Commander Yor, the "time soldier" from the Kelvin Timeline, to wear a Starfleet uniform from the early 2360's? I don't think that Kovich establishes when exactly Yor arrived in the Prime Universe, but Yor purportedly came from the year 2379 and traveled forward, to a time when the universes were already further apart. So the Kelvin Timeline has the same uniforms in 2379 as the Prime Timeline in 2364, instead of anything very different that would have been more plausible?
- We don't know when exactly Emperor Georgiou killed "her" Burnham, which may still happen, but the fact that she stabs Stamets establishes the events of "Terra Firma I" as a different history than the one in Discovery's excursion to the Mirror Universe in the first season. According to Georgiou, the future is still unwritten. That is, if this whole scenario is real at all...
- The Star Dispatch is the same newspaper as in TOS: "The City on the Edge of Forever", giving away that Carl is the Guardian of Forever. However, this is a rather an Easter egg than true continuity.
- As racist as Kovich's assessment of Georgiou as a Terran is, her aggressive conduct proves him right and she should be put in the brig by all means.
- So the Sphere data says "go to these coordinates on the planet to save Georgiou" but gives no indication whatsoever why this could be useful? Did the Sphere assimilate too many mystery stories?
- Remarkably cheesy joke: "What do you call a cute portal? A-door-able. A clown held a door open for me, it was a nice jester." (Carl)
- Remarkable poem: Stamets recites the following as the ISS Charon is launched, supported by dancers who re-enact the life of Emperor Georgiou.
Attend, attend, all foe or friend
She planted steel and glory sowed
When Klingon forces, savage, vile
A then unknown, a peasant girl
Honorable, kind, demure
Her blade was swift, her aim was true
Then armies of evil assembled against us.
Guided by light against forces perverse
- Remarkable facts:
- The Interdimensional Displacement Restriction is part of the Temporal Prime Directive and forbids interdimensional travel.
- Mirror Burnham says that on a mission to Kepler-174d she blinded artists and amputated their hands so that their works would rise in value.
- The Charon is christened in a shipyard at Epsilon Indi IV.
In the Mirror Universe, Emperor Georgiou is determined to alter history. After sparing her life, she continues her efforts to get Michael Burnham to pledge allegiance to her. Burnham finally gives in. Whereas Lorca remains untraceable, she agrees to kill all other co-conspirators. In the meantime, Georgiou has revealed to Saru that his upcoming vahar'ai doesn't mean the end of his life. As the ISS Discovery has intercepted a vessel with a co-conspirator who is still in contact with Lorca, Burnham uses the chance to turn against Georgiou again. But officers who are still loyal to the Emperor, plus Saru and fellow Kelpiens, quickly put down the rebellion. Georgiou is forced to kill Burnham - and wakes up in the 32nd century again. The whole scenario was a test, arranged by Carl, who reveals to be the Guardian of Forever. After being misused in the Temporal Wars, the Guardian wanted to assure itself of Georgiou's good intentions. After passing the test, Georgiou is sent to a time when the Prime and the Mirror Universe were still aligned. She is officially listed as deceased. On the Discovery, Booker installs an Emerald Chain device that allows to establish a link with the Kelpien vessel inside the Verubin nebula, to Admiral Vance's displeasure.
The mere fact that "Terra Firma I/II" spends almost an hour of screen time on a fake scenario (or in a disposable timeline) doesn't bother me. TNG: "The Inner Light" proves that it is possible to tell great stories, even if everything turns out to be an illusion in the end. "Terra Firma II" doesn't give me that satisfaction at all. What happens in the Mirror Universe is not interesting in any way and has no significance, other than perhaps illustrating that Emperor Philippa Georgiou has changed (at least in a way that she now saves Saru and "only" tortures Mirror Michael, while killing everyone else).
Even if the stint in Emperor Georgiou's home in "Terra Firma II" had any consequences, this still would be the most boring Mirror Universe episode of all times. Nothing of note happens in the first 15 minutes. Evil people doing evil things to other evil people, who only react with an evil grin. Is that what I always loved Star Trek for? Anyway, Captain Michael Burnham does not relent, she prefers to be tortured in the agony booth and to turn a deaf ear on Georgiou's motherly pleas. She endures all this with a blend of masochism and a crude Klingon-like interpretation of honor, as if especially the latter had ever been a part of the Terran ethos. When Burnham finally gives in, it all becomes the usual story of deceit, betrayal and massacre. It is obvious that when Burnham vows to kill all co-conspirators, she would get rid of just anyone who stands in her way, and not necessarily of the ones that are opposed to Georgiou. It is also clear that unlike Georgiou, Burnham wouldn't change and would ultimately turn against her again. Star Trek's Mirror Universe stories have always relied on the cheap recipe of perverting the regular characters to cardboard villains, of making them switch sides erratically and of killing them off at the writers' whim. But it has never been that predictable before. And even though Mirror Burnham's death may have been supposed to have an emotional impact, it left me cold - even before it was revealed as fake.
As I already anticipated last week, it adds to my frustration that we wait in vain for Lorca to appear in person, although he is talked about all the time.
Once again, I have misgivings about how everything bad in the Mirror Universe is solely attributed to the genes of the Terrans. While the Mirror Universe of TOS and DS9 still allowed the interpretation that things and people are randomly different in that other universe and that personalities are shaped by the circumstances as well, ENT: "In a Mirror, Darkly" first established that it's only a problem of the Terrans. DIS provides plenty of evidence that Terrans are invariably evil by their very nature. Emperor Georgiou's change of mind appears much like an unlikely exception to the rule. It would have been a lot more revealing, a lot more realistic and a lot less racist if at least one or two other Terrans had been decent characters in the many DIS Mirror Universe episodes. "Terra Firma II" may not be quite as disgusting as "Vaulting Ambition", but it is just as disappointing in this regard. Even though (or just because) it was only a timeline created by the Guardian of Forever, it should not have perpetuated the racist depiction of Terrans.
I thought the meaningless and unemotional excursion to a place I don't care for was the worst part of the episode. Yet, the revelation that followed annoyed me even more. Harking back to Star Trek's rich history can be fun and can create a stronger continuity, if done the right way. However, the Guardian of Forever (just like the Mirror Universe too) should have better remained untouched. Not only was the Guardian "visually updated" (consisting of the now omnipresent shards), relocated and supplemented with "Carl", an avatar it didn't have in TOS: "The City on the Edge of Forever" or TAS: "Yesteryear". The whole nature of the time portal was totally redefined. The new Guardian can read the minds of his clients and creates custom-made timelines for them! Just to test them! It subjects those who want to cross to an infallible trial of whether they are worthy of time travel. It acts like a god-like authority that assesses the morality of people and thereby grants Georgiou her absolution. Although aliens putting the crew to a test of character is a common motif in Star Trek ever since TOS: "Arena", it is simply not how the Guardian of Forever used to be. Revealing Carl to be yet another never-seen-before alien entity, or perhaps even a Metron, would have been a far better choice, without changing anything about the story except for two lines and a few visuals.
Unlike it was in TOS and TAS, the Guardian now also decides where it sends people, without showing any kind of preview. Of course, this is done to keep the exact setting of the upcoming Section 31 series a secret. For all we are told, it could be set any time in the past, when the two universes were still closer together.
An adequate obituary for a hateful former dictator and an overall antisocial person, who happened to become a member of the crew, would have been something like this: "Philippa Georgiou was not a decent human being. She was mean-spirited and violent. It is not up to us to forgive the crimes she committed in her universe. But she adapted to some extent, and at least she never killed anyone of us. Wherever she is now, we hope that she further reconsiders her life and perhaps finds atonement (or enlightenment)." In contrast, what everyone, not only Michael, says about Georgiou in the actual episode is just cringeworthy. Yeah, Hitler was a stubborn guy, he was tough, he was badass, he was honest, he had an awesome mustache, he was not so bad after all. The more I think about it, the more alienating is this whole scene.
As in all recent episodes, the search for the origin of the Burn makes very little progress, and Admiral Vance comes across as a weak superior officer, who has objections about the "lax standards" but ultimately doesn't mind if the people on the Discovery don't follow the protocols.
I can't tell whether "Terra Firma I/II" rather bores or annoys me. Had Discovery been as decent as recently from the start, I would say it has just jumped the shark. But with the past history in mind, the double episode is much like a relapse to former habits - thematically, tonally and with regard to its lax handling of the canon. Here's hoping that the writing will improve again now that Emperor Georgiou, who never really belonged to the series and seldom felt like a real person anyway, is gone for good.
- Continuity: Emperor Georgiou has a viewscreen in her quarters that closely resembles the Tantalus field monitor from TOS: "Mirror, Mirror". This is an Easter egg and not true continuity because her device is not shown and would not be allowed to be used to eliminate people at the press of a button.
- The frequent glitches in the holographic transmission of Admiral Vance drive me crazy. This is 930 years in the future, but it works less reliably than in the 2150s, before it was decided to get rid of the holograms because they looked like ghosts. Well, the Discovery is a half a galaxy away at this time if I understand correctly, which readily excuses the bad transmission, but if done consequentially there should have been no communication with Federation Headquarters at all!
- Carl makes it sound like he sent Georgiou to another timeline just to test her. So if the Guardian itself creates disposable timelines with real people in them to be messed with just to prevent tampering with the "real" timeline, this is okay?
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Why do they only learn from pain?" (Georgiou)
- "My corpse would already be eaten to bones if I could not accurately judge between loyalty and flattery." (Georgiou)
As the Discovery approaches the Verubin nebula, scans of the Khi'eth, the Kelpien ship that crashed there 125 years ago, show one lifesign aboard. Saru concludes that this has to be Dr. Issa's child, as he recognized her pregnancy in her holographic message. After the Discovery's shields have almost failed, Book takes his ship inside the nebula. However, he barely survives the trip, and only the auto-pilot saves him and Grudge. Based on the data gathered by Book, Saru plans to jump with the ship close to the planet, drop an away team consisting of himself, Burnham and Culber, and then jump out again. As the away team has beamed down, they notice that they are in a holographic environment and they have been altered: Culber is Bajoran, Burnham is Trill and Saru is human. They find a Kelpien, obviously Dr. Issa's son, who is afraid of some "monster". Saru and Culber run into a group of Federation officials, who celebrate the admission of Kaminar to the Federation and who reveal the purpose of the program, to educate and entertain the boy while waiting for a rescue team. They learn from a Kelpien elder that the boy's name is Su'Kal. Burnham confronts the "monster" and tries to convince Su'Kal, who does not seem to be aware of the existence of the outside world, to allow to be rescued. In the meantime, Osyraa's ship arrives at the edge of the nebula, upon which Tilly orders to cloak the Discovery. Then a disturbance erupts from the planet, upon which the cloak fails. When Book takes his ship into the nebula again to save the away team, Adira sneaks aboard with a medication and beams down to the crash site. Booker beams back Burnham, whereas Saru and Culber choose to stay behind because Su'Kal somehow is the cause of the Burn, and it may happen all over again. Outside the nebula, Osyraa's people have boarded the Discovery. Using some kind of mind-control device, Osyraa coerces Stamets to activate the spore drive. Just as Book and Burnham return from the nebula, the Discovery and Osyraa's ship jump away, with the Federation Headquarters as their destination...
Discovery's third season started with several installments that evoked classic Trek, both in their episodic format and in their tone. After the needless excursion to the Mirror Universe in the past two weeks, it seems like the old Discovery of season 2 is back in "Su'Kal". The story is serialized, it features conflicts on multiple levels, it is on adrenaline and is over the top in various regards. Furthermore, there are several similarities with DIS: "Brother" in the plot. Although this all reminds me of the inglorious past of Discovery, it is perhaps the paradigm shift the series needs at this point. As successful as the worldbuilding in episodes 1 through 8 was and as pleasant it was that everyone and everything had a clear goal, it was becoming formulaic how conflicts were solved with ease in the course of one episode and how the answer to the big question of the origin of the Burn was protracted. It is probably good, just for a change, that the crew faces existential perils now.
Also on the plus side, after her apparent failure in "Sanctuary", Osyraa is a formidable enemy in "Su'Kal", one who knows the weaknesses of the ship and crew and exploits them. The clever plan she pursues to achieve control of the Discovery reminds me of Seska in VOY: "Basics I". Only her overplayed childish pleasure to humble Tilly is farcical. It is sad anyway that Osyraa's triumph is made possible, at least in part, by Tilly's inexperience. Even though it is debatable whether Tilly should have become Saru's first officer, I have come to like her character, and her first time in the captain's chair shouldn't have ended so miserably.
I have repeatedly criticized the reckless actions of Discovery's crew members. It wouldn't have surprised me if Burnham had beamed down to a hazardous environment without authorization. But I don't recognize what Adira's plan and what their motivation is. Adira's character has not been developed very consequentially so far, except for their role as an engineering prodigy and the interaction with their new friend Stamets. Maybe helping Culber is something that they feel they owe to Stamets, maybe it has to do with Gray suddenly showing up again. I hope it will be further elucidated next week.
One aspect that doesn't sit well with me is that Michael Burnham mistrusts Saru's judgment. This is almost hypocritical, considering that she has a past of acting out of an emotion, quite unlike the usually thoughtful Saru. Only recently, in "Terra Firma I", Saru was the only one with a cold but very reasonable stance about whether to take the slim chance to help Georgiou or whether to tend to the needs of the many. While I agree that Saru takes the matter of the Kelpien survivor in need a tad too personally, it is simply not up to Burnham to judge her captain like that (and to insinuate she goes with him because she is more capable of making the right decisions). Other than in this matter, however, Burnham is an exemplary officer this time. Her careful attempts to communicate with Su'Kal by posing as a hologram are among the best scenes of the episode.
The permanent holographic environment on the ship is plausible in a way to teach Su'Kal and to preserve his mental health. But there is no reason why it would not include a way to be terminated in case a rescue team arrives, and why it would even transform the rescuers to different species. This all comes across as gratuitous, as an excuse for further plot complications and for more impressive visuals. Well, at least in one regard it was a good idea. Although the Kelpien make-up (unlike the one of the Discovery Klingons) allows the actors to work with facial expressions, the great Doug Jones manages to get out even a bit more of his role when playing a human Saru.
It is a big letdown that the Burn was apparently caused by the fear of a Kelpien infant, and not by some villainy, not by some megalomaniac experiment and not by some time travel accident. I expect that if and how Su'Kal can be responsible will become more plausible next week, and perhaps there will be still a surprising twist about it. I really hope that the story will become more rewarding in this regard. Also, it currently doesn't make much sense for Saru and Culber to stay behind to appease Su'Kal, although they could survive for just a few more hours (unless, as the ultima ratio, they consider to kill the "boy").
This episode returns to a serialized storytelling and raises more questions than it answers. Even if "Su'Kal" were the first part of a two-parter like only recently "Terra Firma I", I would have expected more things to add up. I liked the cliffhanger though. The whole setting that enables the story has a credibility problem because of the location of the dilithium planet at the very "edge" of a nebula, unless this will still be explained just as well (I doubt it). Anyway, I hope that the conclusion will follow next week and won't be dragged out. We will see what happens to Su'Kal, Saru, Culber and Adira, but even more importantly I would like to know what motivates them to act like they do. I enjoyed the action and the various tactics employed by the Discovery crew and by Osyraa. Discovery can afford such a fulsomely adventurous episode once in a while.
- The crash site of the Khi'eth on the dilithium planet is 200 kilometers into the Verubin nebula. It is a general problem in Star Trek that vast interstellar nebulae have sharp limits beyond which there is an abrupt increase in radiation. In this regard, a transition zone of just a few kilometers is a very implausible stretch, even more so as a planet is located at this very edge of the nebula. The mere math is ridiculous: 200 kilometers from the edge of the nebula to a planet, which itself measures at least 10 times as much in diameter! At least, we know for sure the planet isn't spinning.
- It is clear that Su'Kal has somehow adapted to the radiation and it was hinted at that the program is degrading. But the mere fact that the ship has been powered up for 125 years and that life support, food and projections have never failed for other reasons either is an unexplained miracle.
- The holographic environment was created in anticipation of a possible rescue of Su'Kal from the outside, as evidenced by the Federation officials speaking of the "anticipated input". Why doesn't the program include any way to end it in such an event, one that would be easy to accomplish for the rescuers? Especially since it was clear that the rescuers would have no time to lose?
- Saru, Burnham and Culber have been altered to be "consistent with the program", in order not to frighten Su'Kal. But what would be so frightening about two humans and a Kelpien, as opposed to a Bajoran, a Trill and a human?
- Why is it that Adira, as a member of the crew, has no badge and needs to borrow it from Reno? The Tal host before Gray was an admiral, and while Adira may not inherit the rank, they have some sort of qualification despite their young age. Otherwise, why would Adira be aboard and have access to engineering at all?
- Remarkable Tilly quotes:
- "Well, it's like my Grandma Adele always used to say: 'Until you've flown a starship into a flaming nebula and gotten everyone out alive, you haven't lived.' She didn't actually say that." (Tilly, to Burnham)
- "A certain 19th-century Earth neurologist would say that you've just proven the idea of projection. You tell me I'm a fraud because, deep down inside, you kind of feel like a fraud. It's interesting. It's not just a human defense mechanism, it's galactic." (Tilly, to Osyraa)
- Remarkable facts:
- It is 125 years, 3 months, 17 days, 4 hours after the crash of the Khi'eth (or after the creation of the program).
- Su'Kal means something like "beloved gift" and is traditionally the name given to a Kelpien child after a tragedy, as a sign of hope.
As Osyraa's ship Viridian and the Discovery arrive at Federation Headquarters, the former begins to fire at the latter. Under the impression that the Discovery is under attack and its comm systems are damaged, Admiral Vance orders to open the protective shield just enough to let the Starfleet ship slip through. Booker and Burnham emerge from the courier network and grasp the last chance to get aboard, by crash landing in the Discovery's shuttlebay. Book has one device to mask lifesigns, which he gives to Burnham, while he himself gets captured. Osyraa contacts Federation Headquarters and demands negotiations. Talking to Vance, she makes the proposal to unite the Emerald Chain and the Federation, upon which Vance demands many concessions. On the Discovery, a scientist named Aurellio investigates the spore drive and possibilities to operate it without Stamets as a navigator. Burnham crawls through the Jefferies tubes, but the Emerald Chain bridge crew led by Zareh locate her and send "regulators" to apprehend her. After securing herself, she sets off a fire, and the pursuers are blown out into space by the fire suppression system. In the meantime, the Starfleet bridge crew including Booker and Ryn have overwhelmed their guards. Ryn hacks into the Discovery's systems that have been purged and reprogrammed by Osyraa's people. After Burnham has freed Stamets, the two get into an argument about whether he should stay on the ship and jump to the Verubin nebula to save Culber, Adira and Saru, or rather get off the ship immediately, so it would be worthless for Osyraa. As the transporters are still blocked, she stuns Stamets, envelops him into a forcefield and sends him to Federation Headquarters. Osyraa returns to the Discovery after the fruitless talks with Vance. Book and Ryn have been apprehended in the meantime. She kills Ryn, although Book proposes that he could show her a passage to the dilithium planet. The rest of the remaining crew under Tilly prepare to retake the ship. They receive unexpected help from the repair robots of the type DOT-23, which now hold the Sphere data...
"There Is A Tide..." aptly begins with a ruse that is almost immediately obvious to an attentive viewer and that wasn't unnecessarily explained or hinted at. The episode thereby picks up the suspense from last week's cliffhanger and continues really seamlessly. The suspense persists for the whole rest of the episode, and is palpable in the negotiations between Vance and Osyraa just as well, although or just because these are obviously pointless.
Some aspects of the story are rather gratuitous, however. Most notably, the return of Zareh, whose life Saru spared in "Far From Home" earlier in this season, makes the galaxy of the 32nd century appear like a village. The only explanation that doesn't involve another huge coincidence is that, after surviving in Iceland, the third-rate villain notified the Emerald Chain, without previously knowing Osyraa, of the arrival of a ship with dilithium supplies. Still, he doesn't know anything else about the Discovery. So why would he suddenly rank so high in Osyraa's organization? Why does Booker even know him? Zareh was and still is underwhelming, something that the writers should have anticipated when they laid out the storyline for season 3.
Invigilator Aurellio, played by Kenneth Mitchell, whose face so far was unrecognizable in his various Klingon roles, is a second character that doesn't turn out as interesting as he was meant to be. It becomes clear that he is opposed to violence, and that he only works with Osyraa because he is indebted to the Emerald Chain. His idea that the proliferation of the spore drive may be for the benefit of the galaxy is naive, and fits the stereotype of scientists working for the wrong side. It is obvious that Aurellio will switch sides, and he will possibly be killed next week, just like the unfortunate Ryn. Furthermore, Aurellio forges some kind of bond with Stamets. They both have a child (does Stamets refer to Adira or rather to the spore drive?), they both love classical music and, as a commonality that breaks the fourth wall, both Rapp and Mitchell belong to a marginalized group in real life and carry that over to their roles. Kenneth Mitchell was diagnosed with ALS, and is in a wheelchair since 2019. But as Burnham transfers Stamets off the ship, it doesn't seem like their bond will still play a role in the season finale.
Many previous Star Trek stories dealt with enemy forces taking over the ship. In some cases the crew didn't strike back with the due vehemence, the worst example of this kind clearly being TNG: "Rascals". Considering of how much is at stake, only Burnham is really consequential. Although her perilous, painful and emotional involvement makes sense in the story, it was once again written in a way that she bears more of a burden than the rest of the crew combined. She's much like Discovery's John McClane here, I was only waiting in vain for her stepping into glass shards after she had lost her shoes. Anyway, for quite some time, Burnham is the only one in this episode, who is willing to risk their life and ready to take lives. It is quite noticeable that she is the only one who kills any of the intruders. But for some reason this determination dwindles in the course of the episode (fortunately just as Tilly and her people get ready for the fight). While it is absolutely appropriate to only stun the guards in engineering, she doesn't even try to keep them as prisoners. Burnham makes considerable efforts to get Stamets off the ship, but perhaps she should have done more to retake the ship and support the rest of the crew. She also releases Aurellio, instead of stunning him, locking him up or sabotaging his hoverchair, which is a rather plot-driven negligence because it will contribute to the scientist's decision to switch sides.
Don't get me wrong, I appreciate that this episode is Trek-like in that it comes with comparably little violence and in that everyone tries to avert the big shoot-out (which may be only deferred until next week though). But the air of benevolence is contrived. Everybody should recognize immediately that Osyraa is up to no good, and Osyraa herself should not overextend the patience of Starfleet and of her own people, who have orders to keep the ship under control without harming anyone of the Discovery crew. There is no hint yet if and what she may still have up her sleeve. Maybe a fleet of Emerald Chain ships is approaching? Maybe she is waiting for a coup d'état in Starfleet to take place? I think we're still in for a major plot twist regarding what her real goals are and who may be unexpectedly on her side. Otherwise, her plan would be lame, and the loss of time because of her pointless negotiations with Vance would only help Starfleet to retake the ship.
Vance is my favorite character in this episode, although he makes the error to fall for the ruse in the first place (probably thinking, "we are one big happy fleet"). The admiral has been rather passive and hesitant so far, but his following actions in this crisis are commendable, especially since he counters Osyraa's absurd proposals with a good deal of sarcasm, while he ostensibly remains open for talks. I only don't quite understand why he would make such a big deal of Osyraa's prosecution, and why he would hit such a weak spot with it, so much that Osyraa would want to leave. Could he possibly have anticipated that, in the hope of getting rid of her? Or is he just trying to achieve the opposite and buy himself more time with more conditions, whereas Osyraa uses the opportunity to be a sorehead and beam back to the Discovery where things are not going smoothly? This remains too indefinite, although it may make more sense next week.
"There Is A Tide..." is a solid action thriller. It keeps up the suspense for its whole run time. It never becomes boring or totally implausible. There are several gratuitous aspects about it, however. Also, I would have expected more things to add up right now, instead of postponing the explanation to next week or (more likely) simply forgetting about them. In this regard, it may seem like a serious omission not to switch to the dilithium planet once in this episode. But I don't really mind that the story focuses on the conflict with Osyraa and is not unnecessarily sidetracked. I think that Stamets's desperate attempt to make a jump back to that planet is an even stronger reminder of what else is going on than it would have been to show one or two scenes with Saru, Culber and Adira.
- Burnham's pursuer in the Jefferies tubes belongs to the same unnamed species as the young Kima from SHO: "Children of Mars".
- The wreck of a Wanderer-class ship almost blocks the courier network. The Orion Wanderer class first appeared in FASA manuals, and only became sort of canon in the form of graphics in TNG episodes of season 1, where its name, origin or purpose were not recognizable.
- Burnham and Book arrive only a minute after the Discovery. So the courier (slipstream) network apparently allows to travel just as fast as the spore drive, which is not consistent with what has been established so far and with the visuals of the slipstream passage in this very episode (unless we involve time dilation).
- Wouldn't we expect the 32nd century to have superb dermal regenerators that Burnham could have used to treat her knife wound?
- Remarkable quotes:
- "It's made of our shit, you know." (Vance, about the food Osyraa is eating)
- "Some of your regulators decided to go for a spacewalk without their EV suits." (Vance, to Osyraa)
- "I'm not afraid of you any more. I've seen real bravery, real strength and loyalty. And love. You're nothing compared to that. All you have is fear, and no one is feared forever." (Ryn, to Osyraa)
- Remarkable facts:
- According to Stamets, space tardigrades are extinct by the 32nd century (but he may just claim that to discourage Aurellio).
- The markings behind Aurellio's ears are of Orion origin, and they indicate that he has children.
- According to Osyraa, Deep Space 253, an outpost that no one from Federation Headquarters has visited in 87 years, has been trading with the Emerald Chain for nearly a century.
On the dilithium planet, Saru and Culber continue their efforts to get Su'Kal to overcome his fears of the outside and end the simulation, in order to escape the radiation and prevent another Burn from happening. Adira, who brings the injections against the radiation burns, materializes as a Xahean. Gray too appears, in a Vulcan guise. Osyraa is still in control of the Discovery, and fires on the shield generators of the Federation Headquarters in order to escape. She cuts off life support to the deck where Tilly and her team have begun to retake the ship. The Discovery eventually breaks through the shields, but a fleet from Ni'Var arrives and prepares to attack. On Burnham's request, in order to avoid further bloodshed, Vance allows the Discovery and the Viridian to withdraw. In sickbay, Aurellio uses a truth serum on Booker to find out the way to the dilithium planet. When this effort fails, Osyraa orders Zareh to torture him. Burnham asks to speak with Book, erects a forcefield around his biobed and escapes with him. She gives Tilly a cue about sabotaging the warp nacelles, in order to stop the ship and regain control. On the dilithium planet, Saru reveals to Su'Kal that he a is Kelpien too. Culber, with the support of Adira, muses that Su'Kal is a polyploid and formed a genetic connection to the dilithium. When he screamed, the sound propagated through subspace at the resonance frequency of dilithium and thereby caused the Burn. On the Discovery, Burnham proceeds to the computer core to reboot the system, while Booker is stuck in a turbolift with Zareh. With little oxygen left on their deck, only Owosekun makes it to the nacelle and successfully disrupts its connection. The ship drops out of warp. Burnham arrives in the computer core where she faces and eventually kills Osyraa. She reboots the computer and beams off the regulators. But the ship is inside the Viridian by now. Burnham suggests to eject the warp core to destroy the Viridian, while Book connects with the spore drive to preform a jump. The Viridian gets obliterated in a huge explosion. On the dilithium planet, Su'Kal enters the room that frightens him and ends the simulation. Gray disappears, but with the promise that the crew would work on a way to make him permanently visible. The death of Su'Kal's mother is replayed, which terrified the boy and led to the Burn. The Discovery arrives and beams up the away team and Su'Kal. The Emerald Chain fractures after Osyraa's death, whereas more worlds consider to rejoin the Federation. The dilithium planet is going to be mined, helping the worlds to reconnect. While Saru stays on Kaminar with Su'Kal for the time being, Michael Burnham becomes the new captain of the Discovery.
The episode title foreshadowed that Aditya Sahil, the lonely Starfleet officer from the first part, would show up again. Although he has just one line in the finale, I appreciate that the season comes full circle in this regard. Other than that, "That Hope Is You, Part 2" is not a great episode at all.
The scenes on the Khi'eth are less interesting than they still were in "Su'Kal". With the mystery about the Burn having been explained in essence, there is very little progress about this part of the plot, although it gets a decent share of the screen time. I like the scenes in which Saru connects to Su'Kal and tries to get him to overcome his fear with fatherly patience, but what happens and what is spoken out is more or less the same as already in "Su'Kal". Only Adira and Gray bring new life to the storyline.
In my review of "Su'Kal", I criticized the species-switching performed by the holographic simulation as gratuitous because there is no good in-universe reason. The same applies to the fact that Gray, besides being a Vulcan, suddenly materializes as a person that is separate from Adira, the Xahean. The two unintentionally look like cosplaying teens, rather than like serious Trek characters anyway. Yet, it ultimately leads to some character development, as Adira recognizes that they are not crazy and Gray expresses the wish to be permanently visible to everyone. The latter breaks the fourth wall, representing how, in real life, transgender people want to be seen as what they identify as. So although the whole idea of an intelligent and empathic simulation that turns real as well as dead people into cosplayers is contrived, perhaps it was worth it. At least, it still works better for me than the new nature of the Guardian of Forever that assesses the personalities of its users by creating custom scenarios. It is a recurring idea of this season anyway how people emotionally connect not only with each other but also with animals, with ghosts and with inanimate things.
It is impossible to miss that "getting connected" is the one big theme of this season finale. Everyone connects with everything: Owosekun with a repair robot, Su'Kal with the dilithium, with Saru and with his holographic mother, Booker with the spore network, the Federation planets with each other. In addition to just alluding to it, the word "connection" is explicitly spoken out several times, and the episode even closes with a statement by Gene Roddenberry about how important communication is. Less would have been more. It is well possible that some of the references were included in light of the corona situation. But I think that especially the concept that certain people, if they are genetically gifted, can form a bond with the universe or with chemical elements belongs into the realm of esotericism. Discovery had that problem from the beginning, thinking of Stamets and the spore network, and I would have preferred if the series had not expanded on the idea, or had restricted it to Book only being special when it comes to animals and plants.
Aurellio's involvement in this episode is a disappointment. It was obvious that he would change his mind, but unlike in "There Is A Tide...", his role in "That Hope Is You, Part 2" is insignificant. His clash with Osyraa remains undramatic, his contribution to the plot is negligible, his previous exchange with Stamets had no further significance than setting up his defection, the trust that Michael Burnham suddenly has in him is unwarranted.
In my review of "Su'Kal", I still complimented Osyraa on her clever preparation to capture the Discovery. Her strategy in last week's "There Is A Tide...", on the other hand, appeared as awkward, so much that I was convinced she still had something up her sleeve. Unfortunately, that was it for her idea to conquer the Federation, which quickly falls apart in the course of "That Hope Is You, Part 2". And speaking of disappointments, I think there isn't anything worth mentioning about Zareh in this episode.
Once again, like already so often in this season, Burnham saves the day, and Burnham takes all the credit for it. Well, this time she herself remains relatively decent (at least as decent as a Willis-type action hero can be), does not talk too much and does not burst out in tears over any kind of emotion. Burnham is a controversial character because of her statements and actions, including her occasional problems with discipline. But making errors is just human. I think another important reason why Burnham appears to many fans as such an unlikable and exaggerated person is because of the narrative, which always puts her in the center of the universe, and of the points of view of other characters, who keep worshipping her. In this vein, Tilly steps down as the commanding officer in awe immediately after retaking the ship, and Vance even more or less praises her problems with his orders in his enthusiasm. Burnham's merits may earn her the highest medal of honor, after all she gave everything for her friends and for Starfleet. But that doesn't automatically qualify her to command the ship!
"That Hope Is You, Part 2" ties up some of the many loose ends and establishes a new, optimistic premise for the next season. Furthermore, it is a decent action thriller, albeit not as tense as "There Is A Tide...". Unfortunately, most of its aspects just don't work as well as they could: The story about Su'Kal is dragged out, Osyraa and her people turn out to be utterly disappointing as antagonists, whereas Burnham is once again shown as larger than life.
Overall, all seasons of the series start with a promising outing ("The Vulcan Hello", "Brother", "That Hope is You, Part 1"). They then stay true to the new tone and storyline for a couple of weeks, until they throw everything overboard in a WTF episode ("Despite Yourself", "Through the Valley of Shadows", "Terra Firma I"). All three seasons close with very disappointing finales that barely manage to clean up the whole mess and whose happy endings are manufactured. Well, after season 1, which ended with almost hypocritical backslapping in "Will You Take My Hand?", and after season 2, whose events were erased from the history books in a big conspiracy in "Such Sweet Sorrow II", at least "That Hope Is You, Part 2" is the so far most honest finale, but the bar was very low.
Also, let me still address the elephant in the room. The absurd CG scenes in the infinite empty space inside the Discovery (including Burnham's physically impossible stunt) are very disruptive, as they lead to a temporary disconnection of the viewer with the story. Even though the corona pandemic may have hampered the post production, there is no excuse for the moronic "creative decision" to make the ship a thousand times larger on the inside than on the outside. Other than that, the producers, writers and artists of Discovery have learned a few lessons from their past mistakes and know how to make a series that feels a bit like Star Trek by now and can be taken seriously, which they have proven in almost all other episodes in the third season.
- A look at some of the many dangling threads and open issues prior to this season finale, and if and how they are resolved:
- The Burn: This big question is resolved, but not any more satisfactorily than already in "Su'Kal". "That Hope Is You, Part 2" adds only technobabble to an explanation that essentially still is "a crying boy made all dilithium in the galaxy go boom". A genetic bond to dilithium? Seriously? At least, it fits the "everyone connects to everything" theme of this episode.
- Osyraa's "unification" proposal: It is the perhaps biggest letdown to learn (from Osyraa herself) that she was either honest about what she said to Vance (after all, she didn't execute anyone of the Discovery crew for that matter), or had no better plan of defeating the Federation but to get the Discovery trapped and giving Vance time to destroy or retake the ship.
- Osyraa's insider knowledge of Federation technology and protocols: There apparently isn't any mole working for her, although she once again knows more than she should, when she pinpoints the exact spot to hit to disable the shield generators. This leaves quite a few unanswered questions, which likely won't be addressed now that she's dead.
- Ryn's apparent importance: No news. So he was just some guy who ran away from the Emerald Chain, which raises the question why Osyraa would hunt him with such a passion. Just because, like everyone else in the galaxy, he knows that dilithium is scarce? That's ridiculous. Well, he could have been the mole, but then she wouldn't have attempted to kill him on multiple previous occasions.
- Gray's nature: So Gray is a separate personality indeed, because a holographic environment can't be wrong about that. Although this is all very contrived, it may work for me. It still leaves the question if and how Gray can be transgender, as officially announced by CBS, and whether this is relevant for a hologram.
- Grudge ("She's a queen!"): Although there were a few hints that Grudge may be more than just a cat, this doesn't seem to be the case.
- The President of the Federation: For a moment I thought Kovich, the somewhat mysterious guy played by David Cronenberg, is the president, who was repeatedly referred to last week. But that may have been just a red herring.
- The AI Zora: It was hinted at a few times this season and also in the finale that Zora is evolving. Zora will stay on the ship, which will be abandoned still further in the future, as seen in SHO: "Calypso". The big problem is that the Short Treks episode showed the pre-refit Discovery. This may still be explained, but I doubt the writers have a concept and simply decided that the cool idea to refit the ship justified a major in-series continuity error.
- Continuity: The Discovery gets the 32nd century standard uniforms in the end, thereby abandoning the last permanent reminder of the very unfortunate styles created when the series was launched.
- The other Starfleet ships keep firing on the 900-year old Discovery, without once breaking through the shields. Even though the implicit order may have been to disable and not destroy the ship, it doesn't make sense to fire with minimum power.
- Maybe I simply missed something in the heat of the battle, but there is no explanation what kind of damage the pesticides released from the Viridian could do to starships. It is a bizarre idea to use them as a weapon in a space battle.
- Why would Osyraa waste time with interrogating Book? Shouldn't she take one step at a time, with the fleet in pursuit and Tilly's people trying to retake the ship being more pressing problems?
- How could Burnham crack the regulator badge? Wouldn't it have an access protection? While it is still credible that Adira could operate Reno's badge (perhaps only with Reno's explicit approval), taking an enemy's badge and getting full control over it is a stretch.
- After the refit, the Discovery doesn't have rollercoaster tracks for the turbolifts any longer. They are now free-floating, like everything else, inside the ship. The interior is now bigger than that of a Borg cube! The official size of the Discovery has to be adjusted to some 10 kilometers, making the Viridian some 100 kilometers long! This is so stupid it hurts, a new apex of cringe in the series.
- If I were to take over an enemy ship, I would not reprogram its operation system on the fly, but overwrite the boot sector and/or OS storage, especially if it contains command codes that only the rightful crew has access to.
- When Burnham orders all regulators to be beamed off the ship, the computer conveniently forgets Aurellio or classifies him as "not a regulator".
- Another creative choice besides the turbolift flight seems to be that the warp core of the Discovery is ejected through a tube without constriction, hitting the walls several times, always on the verge of exploding while still inside the ship.
- Isn't it a rather bad idea to replay the recording of the exact moment when Su'Kal screamed and caused the Burn? I don't know much about Kelpien psychology, but if he were human, he might relive the moment and scream again.
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Let's fly." (Captain Burnham)
- "In a very real sense, we are all aliens on a strange planet. We spend most of our lives reaching out and trying to communicate. If during our whole lifetime, we could reach out and really communicate with just two people, we are indeed very fortunate." (Gene Roddenberry quote at the end of the episode)
- Remarkably cheesy scene: Fighting with Osyraa, Burnham gets swallowed by the huge chunky pixels of a 32nd century monitor. I wonder if this has a symbolic meaning, and if only unintentionally.
- Remarkable facts:
- The Orion heart has six valves, and pumps blood in two directions.
- Cleveland Booker took his name from his mentor.