EAS Today

EditorialEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS UpdatesEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageJörg Hillebrand @ MastodonEAS @ Facebook

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
19 Jan 2025

Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance

The fandom appears more divided over Starfleet Academy than ever before. Many reject the series outright, criticizing the setting, characters, storytelling and the inevitable "wokeness". The number of naysayers seems even greater than those who opposed Discovery. Either that, or they have simply become more vocal and visible. On the other side, supporters celebrate Starfleet Academy as a fresh opportunity to explore new worlds and seek out new audiences. That's only fair, but some dismiss criticism outright. I also don't think that framing disappointed fans as being of one mind with evil Elon is helpful. In the media, the middle ground is drowned out by the extremes. The episodes themselves almost feel designed to provoke division by alienating long-time fans with broad humor and heavy-handed references. Yet even detractors admit the show looks better than expected. The lingering question is: Can Starfleet Academy become a sustainable Trek series, one that simply requires time for audiences to adjust to its style?

I don't consider myself a detractor, but rather a skeptic. However, it is difficult to escape the framing, and in my case, to set aside grievances in order to enjoy what SFA does well. My reviews of "Kids These Days" and "Beta Test" seem to lean heavily on weaknesses, but as an afterthought, I want to highlight the strengths. The sets are spectacular. Everything is bright, crisp and polished, much like in the Golden Age of the 1990s. Despite occasional lens flares and CGI excess, the cinematography is outstanding. SFA is the best-looking modern Trek show. The cast also impresses. Holly Hunter delivers as expected, but the young actors deserve praise for making the cadets feel alive and likable. Then there's the broader setting. Discovery laid the groundwork, but its constant galaxy-saving missions left little room to explore the 32nd century in depth. SFA already does far more in terms of worldbuilding.

I believe Starfleet Academy has the potential to evolve into a meaningful series in the best Trek tradition, if it can deliver compelling stories while cutting back on the silly jokes, awkward situations and nostalgia overload. That said, one more aspect currently doesn't quite work for me. With the exception of Caleb, every cadet is an alien, yet they all feel essentially human. They are distinguished by special abilities, rather than by different values and traditions. SAM has even been programmed as a 17-year-old awkward human girl. I would expect cultural clashes, but the aliens integrate more seamlessly than a German exchange student at an American college. Ironically Caleb is the outsider in terms of the cultural background.

I try to keep an open mind and resist the polarized framing that surrounds Starfleet Academy. Still, my reviews will probably remain in flux as my perspective is evolving. What I can say with confidence, however, is that the claims of SFA being a "disaster" or a "disgrace" are totally exaggerated. The show certainly has its flaws, but I can only encourage fellow skeptics to give Starfleet Academy a fair chance.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
  • 29 Jan 2026
    Today's Starfleet Academy episode "Vox in Excelso" explores the art of debate, the traumatic experiences of a cadet and the fate of his species, but it doesn't handle any of it as well as it could have.
  • 22 Jan 2026
    Here is my review of this week's Starfleet Academy episode "Vitus Reflux". It fails on so many levels from the silly fungus with a stupid name to the questionable moral that I don't know where to start. I expect that this will remain a one-time misfire, though.
  • 19 Jan 2026
    As I can tell from the fan reactions, Starfleet Academy may be the most divisive Trek series ever. But that doesn't have to be so. I have compiled a few thoughts on the new series that are not yet covered in my reviews: Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance.
  • 18 Jan 2026
    Here are the promised article updates with facts from the first two Starfleet Academy episodes: Classical Music in Star Trek, Locating Starfleet Buildings in San Francisco, The Emblem of Starfleet Academy, The Evolution of the Federation Emblem. Check out the "Pages with Recent Changes" list for even more updates.
  • 17 Jan 2026
    Here is my (less positive) review of the second episode, SFA: "Beta Test". I have added references from the pilot to various sections of the site. "Beta Test" will follow in next couple of days, including the details on the classical music (Mozart's Die Zauberflöte and Beethoven's Fidelio).
  • 15 Jan 2026
    Starfleet Academy is burdened by an unpopular series idea and is additionally set in Discovery's unloved post-Burn era. Read my full review of the premiere "Kids These Days" for a first assessment of whether this series can find its place in the Star Trek Universe.
  • 11 Jan 2026
    More Voyager season 7 retro reviews. Here are "Inside Man" and "Body and Soul".
  • 03 Jan 2026
    On episode index pages such as DS9, the diagrams are now generated automatically from the reviews on the site. This removes the need for manual Excel exports and ensures the data is always consistent.
  • 02 Jan 2026
    It's Voyager retro review time again. Here are "Repression" and "Critical Care".
  • 01 Jan 2026
    Happy New Year 2026! There is no new content yet, but maybe this is a good time to check out the highlights on EAS from 2025. Major new articles look at Design Issues of the Original Enterprise and Voyager's Maquis Crew. Besides innumerable small additions, there are also all-new articles by Jörg, such as Paintings and Photos in Picard's Study or Suliban Emblems and Writing. Almost needless to mention, the Starship Database is up to date with the designs from the latest episodes. Also have a look at the Journal of Applied Treknology that I redesigned from the ground up. Last but not least, there is the configurable and sortable episode master list, complete with the option to show the data in the form of a bar chart or histogram.
  • 30 Dec 2025
    In the final EAS update of 2025, find an investigation of the newspaper pages in modern Star Trek episodes. If you don't already know it, check out what Jörg found on re-used text passages in newspapers in classic Trek.
  • 28 Dec 2025
    The audio web series Star Trek: Khan, written by Kirsten Beyer and David Mack, based on a story by Nicholas Meyer, premiered on September 8. Here is a spoiler-free review.
  • 26 Dec 2025
    Time travel is one of Star Trek's oldest and most enduring themes, and among the the most fascinating ones in my opinion. Here is a list of my favorites: Top Ten Time Travel Episodes.
  • 22 Dec 2025
    Here are two Voyager season 7 retro reviews: "Imperfection" and "Drive".
  • 20 Dec 2025
    Several additions and improvements in Jörg's article on Observations in TNG: "The Drumhead".
  • 14 Dec 2025
    Overhaul of Jörg's old articles on Observations in TNG: "Samaritan Snare" and Observations in TNG: "Up the Long Ladder".
EAS Favourites @ Deviantart
  • 14 Nov 2025

    This is my re-done version of an old, old MSD I did back in 2009 ish. I updated it to my latest quality level.

    I had this up before, but missed it when I had to completely re-upload my gallery due to DA allowing all and sundry to download the hi res copies for free!

    thumbnail
  • 23 Oct 2025

    An efficient layout for tactical operations, the Defiant bridge was significantly smaller than most other ships of the era, and was directly connected to the rest of deck 1 via two egress doors. The captain’s chair sat on a raised platform near the center of the room, giving the CO a commanding view of the entire room, with the helm located directly in front of it. The perimeter stations were, working clockwise from the viewscreen: science, tactical I, tactical II, and engineering. The back of the bridge featured a retractable situation table for mission briefings, above which was the dedication plaque.

    For several additional renders, please visit my portfolio.

    This model was originally created for OTOY and The Roddenberry Archive, you can fully explore this room at https://roddenberry.x.io/2371-uss-defiant-nx-74205/?view=Bridge.

    Software used:

    3D Modeling and rendering: Blender 4.5

    LCARS panels and textures: Inkscape 1.4

    OS: Ubuntu 24.04

    thumbnail
  • 24 Aug 2024

    Additional uniforms from 2373-2378.

    I will be doing my own versions of Starfleet uniforms in chronological order all the way up to the early 25th century. This project is not intended to be for a fanfic. Just doing this for fun. This is my take on the First Contact/ Deep Space Nine/Voyager uniforms, but with some changes for my timeline.

    I changed the dress uniforms to another design, as I never cared for the white uniforms introduced in Star Trek: Insurrection.

    Updated on 8/26/24 to correct minor mistake on cadet uniform.

    Based on a template by Grand-Lobster-King-www.deviantart.com/grand-lobst…

    thumbnail
  • 14 Aug 2025


    thumbnail
Jörg Hillebrand @ Mastodon
  • 01 Feb 2026

    Whenever I watch 's "Kids These Days" (1x01) and "Vox In Excelso" (1x04) on my TV (but not on my computer!) I get these strange light flashes in the first 10 seconds of the end credits. Does anyone else experience that? I feel like I'm being sent a secret message in Ferengi B'Zal! 😅

  • 01 Feb 2026

    Here's a cool shot of the USS Athena with its saucer section separated from the lower part of the ship (and its nacelles, as usual). The section that stays behind contains the Academy dorm rooms and lecture halls. I wonder what that small structure on the outer ring is, kind of looks like a small shuttle.

  • 01 Feb 2026

    Apart from some new bottles, first seen in ' "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield", the episode also features a Saurian brandy bottle ("The Enemy Within"↙️), a Kluk Kluk bottle with a pink liquid ("Dagger of the Mind"➡️), a coffee set ("is There in Truth..."↘️) and a tall bottle ("Journey to Babel"⬅️).

  • 01 Feb 2026

    I love doing research, on old episodes and new episodes. No matter how often I've seen an episode, I always find something new to write about. And sometimes I forget that I already have discovered something and am excited anew. The joys of growing middle-aged with Star Trek! 😊

  • 01 Feb 2026

    We get a brief look at a Klingon heavy cargo carrier in some FNN shots in 's "Vox in Excelso", before the ship crashes on Taurus VII. Both the planet and its surface are seen a little later in the same episode.

  • 01 Feb 2026

    Jay-Den Kraag mentions Klingon love poetry in 's "Vox in Excelso", but we've heard about Klingon love poetry before: Worf talked about it in two episodes, namely "The Dauphin" (2nd pic) and "Up the Long Ladder" (3rd pic). :-)

  • 01 Feb 2026

    's "Vox in Excelso" features several Klingon ships (advanced light battlecruisers) of the QeHpu’ class, originally created for (3rd pic). The episode thus brings the design into the 32nd century and into the canon realm, it's such a cool starship class! :-)

  • 01 Feb 2026

    Here are all of the names, colour-coded by TV show. The first pic shows how the names are arranged on the commemoration wall in , the second pic lists al the names alphabetically and the third pic lists them by show. Compiling this took more than 4 hours...🖖

  • 01 Feb 2026

    features the whole Freeman family plus Tendi, Captain Ramirez and Joshua Albert (listed here and not at because he is only seen on ). From , we have Rok-Tahk, Gwyndala and Zero plus Doctor (and science adviser in real life) Erin MacDonald. 7/8

  • 01 Feb 2026

    From , there's only Cristobal Rios, Liam Shaw and Admiral Whitley. The rest is covered at or . The whole cast of is listed (or already covered at the listing). There are also some recurring characters but Una is sorely missing. 6/8

EAS Timeline @ Facebook
  • 29 Jan 2026
    Review of SFA: "Vox in Excelso" - Today's Starfleet Academy episode "Vox in Excelso" explores the art of debate, the traumatic experiences of a cadet and the fate of his species, but it doesn't handle any of it as well as it could have. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews
  • 22 Jan 2026
    Review of SFA: "Vitus Reflux" - Here is my review of this week's Starfleet Academy episode "Vitus Reflux". It fails on so many levels from the silly fungus with a stupid name to the questionable moral that I don't know where to start. I expect that this will remain a one-time misfire, though. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews
  • 19 Jan 2026
    Editorial: Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance - As I can tell from the fan reactions, Starfleet Academy may be the most divisive Trek series ever. But that doesn't have to be so. I have compiled a few thoughts on the new series that are not yet covered in my reviews: Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance. The latest posts and comments on EAS and its social media pages
  • 17 Jan 2026
    SFA-Related Updates in Several Articles - Here are the promised article updates with facts from the first two Starfleet Academy episodes: Classical Music in Star Trek, Locating Starfleet Buildings in San Francisco, The Emblem of Starfleet Academy, The Evolution of the Federation Emblem. Check out the "Pages with Recent Changes" list for even more updates. Identification of the various pieces of classical music in Star Trek, complete with sound files
  • 17 Jan 2026
    Review of SFA: "Beta Test" - Here is my (less positive) review of the second episode, SFA: "Beta Test". I have added references from the pilot to various sections of the site. "Beta Test" will follow in next couple of days, including the details on the classical music (Mozart's Die Zauberflöte and Beethoven's Fidelio). Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews
  • 15 Jan 2026
    Review of SFA: "Kids These Days" - Starfleet Academy is burdened by an unpopular series idea and is additionally set in Discovery's unloved post-Burn era. Read my full review of the premiere "Kids These Days" for a first assessment of whether this series can find its place in the Star Trek Universe. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews
  • 11 Jan 2026
    Updated Reviews: VOY: "Inside Man" and "Body and Soul" - More Voyager season 7 retro reviews. Here are "Inside Man" and "Body and Soul". Star Trek Voyager (VOY) season 7 episode guide and reviews
  • 11 Jan 2026
    Technical Update: Automated Episode Diagram Generation - On episode index pages such as DS9, the diagrams are now generated automatically from the reviews on the site. This removes the need for manual Excel exports and ensures the data is always consistent. Index for Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode guide and reviews
  • 10 Jan 2026
    Advance reviews of Starfleet Academy are coming in. I naturally don't have access to screeners. So here are a few thoughts based on trailers and other promotional publications. As the premiere of Starfleet Academy approaches, my expectations are low - but not dismissive. I try to keep an open mind, even though the series shows issues in its creative premise. First of all, Starfleet Academy is a show very few fans ever asked for. Ever since the internet has existed, an Academy-centered series has reliably ranked among the least popular options in fan polls. When Discovery premiered in 2017, it followed a long absence of Star Trek from television, and many were still willing to grant it some benefit of the doubt in spite of the unloved prequel/reboot concept. After years of seemingly more downs than ups in new Trek, Starfleet Academy arrives in a different context. Set in the unpopular post-Burn Discovery continuity of the 32nd century, it additionally revives an equally unpopular premise. The trailers and promotional material suggest Starfleet Academy may be something like Starfleet 90210. Teen-focused storytelling may work on its own terms, but it hardly provides the thematic relevance once associated with TNG, DS9 or Voyager. Robert Picardo returns as Voyager's EMH and the trailers frequently namedrop familiar characters, in an effort to invoke the legacy and signal to fans, "This is still the Star Trek you love." Yet, coming-of-age stories against the emotionally distant backdrop of the 32nd century may provide little sense of adventure. SFA tries to compensate by turning the Academy itself into a starship, the USS Athena, perhaps akin to how DS9 introduced the Defiant. Yet, if cadets routinely find themselves in high-stakes missions, the premise begins to strain credibility. One such mission we already know about involves a vengeful villain named Nus Braka, who attacks the USS Athena in much the same fashion as Khan in "Star Trek II". This once again prompts the old question why the people running Star Trek in the past 25 years are so obsessed with Khan and revenge narratives. The franchise has historically been at its strongest when antagonists were driven by ideology, culture or perhaps material interests, rather than by petty personal grudges. SFA's cadets follow well-worn character conventions just as well. Every one of them arrives with a conspicuously "special" backstory: the tragic orphan who finds refuge in the Starfleet family, the president's offspring with extraordinary mental abilities, the admiral's daughter, the first of her kind at the Academy or the alien outsider to confirm/refute common notions about their species. Star Trek has always embraced distinctive personal histories, such as Spock's half-Vulcan heritage, Worf's Klingon upbringing or Seven of Nine's Borg past, but in this case the approach is overdone. The lingering question is where the ordinary cadets are. Where are the O'Briens, the ones who do not benefit from nepotism and whose stories unfold through their actions rather than lineage or trauma? Finally, the cast and characters are designed to be visually diverse. It remains to be seen whether audience connection will arise from superficial similarities or from personality and shared values, as in classic Trek. So, are my objections and apprehensions justified, or will they turn out premature? Advance reviews of Starfleet Academy are coming in. I naturally don't have access to screeners. So here are a few thoughts based on trailers and other promotional publications. As the premiere of Starfleet Academy approaches, my expectations are low - but not dismissive. I try to keep an open mind, even though the series shows issues in its creative premise. First of all, Starfleet Academy is a show very few fans ever asked for. Ever since the internet has existed, an Academy-centered series has reliably ranked among the least popular options in fan polls. When Discovery premiered in 2017, it followed a long absence of Star Trek from television, and many were still willing to grant it some benefit of the doubt in spite of the unloved prequel/reboot concept. After years of seemingly more downs than ups in new Trek, Starfleet Academy arrives in a different context. Set in the unpopular post-Burn Discovery continuity of the 32nd century, it additionally revives an equally unpopular premise. The trailers and promotional material suggest Starfleet Academy may be something like Starfleet 90210. Teen-focused storytelling may work on its own terms, but it hardly provides the thematic relevance once associated with TNG, DS9 or Voyager. Robert Picardo returns as Voyager's EMH and the trailers frequently namedrop familiar characters, in an effort to invoke the legacy and signal to fans, "This is still the Star Trek you love." Yet, coming-of-age stories against the emotionally distant backdrop of the 32nd century may provide little sense of adventure. SFA tries to compensate by turning the Academy itself into a starship, the USS Athena, perhaps akin to how DS9 introduced the Defiant. Yet, if cadets routinely find themselves in high-stakes missions, the premise begins to strain credibility. One such mission we already know about involves a vengeful villain named Nus Braka, who attacks the USS Athena in much the same fashion as Khan in "Star Trek II". This once again prompts the old question why the people running Star Trek in the past 25 years are so obsessed with Khan and revenge narratives. The franchise has historically been at its strongest when antagonists were driven by ideology, culture or perhaps material interests, rather than by petty personal grudges. SFA's cadets follow well-worn character conventions just as well. Every
  • 03 Jan 2026
    Technical Update: Automated Episode Diagram Generation - On episode index pages such as DS9, the diagrams are now generated automatically from the reviews on the site. This removes the need for manual Excel exports and ensures the data is always consistent. Index for Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode guide and reviews
  • 01 Jan 2026
    Updated Reviews: VOY: "Repression" and "Critical Care" - It's Voyager retro review time again. Here are "Repression" and "Critical Care". Star Trek Voyager (VOY) season 7 episode guide and reviews
  • 31 Dec 2025
    Happy New Year 2026! - Happy New Year 2026! There is no new content yet, but maybe this is a good time to check out the highlights on EAS from 2025. Major new articles look at Design Issues of the Original Enterprise and Voyager's Maquis Crew. Besides innumerable small additions, there are also all-new articles by Jörg, such as Paintings and Photos in Picard's Study or Suliban Emblems and Writing. Almost needless to mention, the Starship Database is up to date with the designs from the latest episodes. Also have a look at the Journal of Applied Treknology that I redesigned from the ground up. Last but not least, there is the configurable and sortable episode master list, complete with the option to show the data in the form of a bar chart or histogram. Configurable list of all episodes and reviews at EAS, with links and pictures
  • 30 Dec 2025
    Updated Article: Newspaper Pages in Star Trek - In the final EAS update of 2025, find an investigation of the newspaper pages in modern Star Trek episodes. If you don't already know it, check out what Jörg found on re-used text passages in newspapers in classic Trek. Illustrated list of newspapers that appeared on Star Trek, incl. identification of commonly used filler text
  • 28 Dec 2025
    Review of Star Trek: Khan - The audio web series Star Trek: Khan, written by Kirsten Beyer and David Mack, based on a story by Nicholas Meyer, premiered on September 8. Here is a spoiler-free review. As some sort of preface, I have never been a fan of Nicholas Meyer's idea of a TV series about Khan Noonien Singh and his people's exile on Ceti Alpha V. If there is one storyline in classic Star Trek that feels fully told, it's Khan's. Only tiny gaps remain, and nothing should truly surprise us or....
  • 26 Dec 2025
    New Ranking: Top Ten Time Travel Episodes - Time travel is one of Star Trek's oldest and most enduring themes, and among the the most fascinating ones in my opinion. Here is a list of my favorites: Top Ten Time Travel Episodes. Ranking of Trek's best time travel episodes according to yours truly
  • 22 Dec 2025
    Updated Reviews: VOY: "Imperfection" and "Drive" - Here are two Voyager season 7 retro reviews: "Imperfection" and "Drive". Star Trek Voyager (VOY) season 7 episode guide and reviews
  • 20 Dec 2025
    Updated: Observations in TNG: "The Drumhead" - Several additions and improvements in Jörg's article on Observations in TNG: "The Drumhead". Observations about sets, props and visual effects in TNG: "The Drumhead"
  • 14 Dec 2025
    Updates to Observations in TNG: "Samaritan Snare" and "Up the Long Ladder" - Overhaul of Jörg's old articles on Observations in TNG: "Samaritan Snare" and Observations in TNG: "Up the Long Ladder". Observations about sets, props and visual effects in TNG: "Samaritan Snare"

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery