EAS Today

EditorialEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS UpdatesEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageJörg Hillebrand @ MastodonEAS @ Facebook

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
20 Jun 2026

Farewell Voyager, Hello Enterprise

It took me a long time to revisit my old Voyager reviews, but the effort was well worth it. Many of the episodes I had not seen in more than a decade, and while I changed my opinion on a few of them, my overall impression remained exactly what it had always been: Voyager is an excellent show and is among Star Trek's finest, alongside The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine. Looking back to my first contact with the series in 1995, I merely knew Voyager would be about the eponymous Federation starship stranded in unexplored territory. I embraced the premise and I loved the show from the very first episode. Perhaps I was simply more open-minded back then, because I suspect I would approach such a concept with greater skepticism today. Then again, especially after the disappointments of Discovery, both in concept and execution, I may have good reasons for that mistrust.

What I never understood was why Voyager developed such a poor reputation in certain circles in the emerging internet. It was not the dominant view in the newsgroups and forums I frequented, but it certainly existed elsewhere. I find it troubling how this sentiment, which had largely faded away, has been revived in recent years. My impression is that this often serves to distract from the shortcomings of modern Trek by arguing along the lines that "classic Star Trek was never as good as you remember". I often perceive the treatment of Voyager as unfair. For that reason, it was especially satisfying to analyze every single episode again, paying close attention to both the stories themselves and their continuity connections. My goal was to identify the show's strengths and weaknesses, with now even more diligence, rather than resorting to the blanket judgments that are so fashionable today. I cannot claim perfect objectivity, nor would I want to, but I always try to apply the same standards to old and new shows.

Voyager, in my view, produced some truly outstanding episodes. "Distant Origin" offered a fascinating reversal of perspective on a conceited ideology. "Blink of an Eye" presented the rise and fall of entire civilizations in accelerated time with charm and imagination. "Year of Hell" remains one of the franchise's most compelling scenarios and, in my opinion, is not weakened in the slightest by the fact that it technically never happened. At the same time, the series also had its share of failures. "11:59" is a present-day story with only tenuous connections to what is happening aboard Voyager and feels largely irrelevant. "The Fight" is utterly pointless, while the two Fair Haven episodes are among the dullest hours of the series.

Of the criticisms most frequently directed at Voyager, there are two that I largely agree with. The first is that the conflict between the Starfleet and Maquis crews fades away too quickly. There was enormous dramatic potential there, much of it left unexplored. The second is the gradual decline of the Borg as a credible threat. By the later seasons, Janeway is able to outwit them far too easily.

There are two other common complaints that I reject completely. Those who dismiss Seven of Nine as little more than sexy window dressing cannot have paid much attention, as she undergoes one of the most engaging character arcs in the series. Likewise, many of the attacks directed at Captain Janeway, whether from a feminist or anti-feminist perspective, miss the point entirely. She is only human and sometimes makes mistakes. I agree that the character is not written quite consistently, but transforming those inconsistencies into a political argument strikes me as absurd. Attempts to claim Voyager for one political camp or another miss much of what makes the series interesting. Like Star Trek at its best, it embraces progressive principles while also acknowledging that Starfleet is imperfect, especially under the extraordinary circumstances of a ship stranded alone in the Delta Quadrant.

Having completed Voyager, I have now begun reviewing Enterprise, a show I freely admit I did not embrace at first. The uninspiring character descriptions, the Akiraprise design and the very idea of a prequel were not what I wanted to see from Star Trek at the time. Yet, at latest by the fourth season, Enterprise had become a show I was eager to watch, which makes its cancelation all the more unfortunate. I can tell already that my opinion of quite a few episodes has changed, and almost always for the better. In many other cases, I may reach conclusions similar to those from 25 years ago, but I am now able to express them far more effectively. As a result, many of my old reviews will require substantial rewriting. So stay tuned for the review tour. It will probably take a long time to complete, perhaps two or three years, depending in part on whether there will be any new Star Trek beyond the final seasons of SNW and SFA.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
  • 17 Aug 2026

    This season seems mighty...experimental to me. Dunno what the writers were thinking unless they've been replaced by an AI.

  • 15 Aug 2026

    Added pictograms form SNW: "Human Best Friend".

  • 15 Aug 2026

    K now FOR REALZ I cann0t be the only person out there who is seriously entertaining the notion that an AI got the prompt "Trek plus film noir, and make the doctor 007 for NO reason" and this slop was the result.

  • 15 Aug 2026

    Phoenix may have originally been intended to be an unmanned test flight, prior to the final nuclear exchange, and after, Cochrane decided to make it a manned flight, because he figured it was the only shot he was ever going to have. Thus the scrounging would have primarily been for the materials to modify Pheonix.
    He would have needed to get hold of the base and the missile somehow, and if it had been an operational missile base with missiles carrying nuclear warheads, it presumably would have been launched during the nuclear exchanges.

    Regarding Connestoga, if we theorize that Cochrane had had support from a governmental and/or major university type entity prior to the final nuclear exchange(s), it could have already been mostly built, possibly as a legitimate colony expedition, or as some sort of fallback/escape plan under the cover of being a colony ship.
    On the other hand, Terra Nova had some other major plot holes (it's been 70 years, that's more than long enough for a Vulcan ship, or even an Earth ship, to have swung past to find out what happened), and Connestoga looks like it should be much more recent in terms of design lineage, with all the similarities to the NX and Intrepid type.

    Regarding the Arctic Transport, possibly the ship is/was designed or modified for supporting survey missions on other worlds in the system and beyond, but was being tested for how well it could support a survey mission in an extreme environment where if something went wrong, they're not that far from help. After all, when they went out of contact, Starfleet showed up to investigate, suggesting Starfleet funding, though also justifiable by the presence of alien ship wreckage and corpses, but that would also justify a Starfleet team taking over or at least joining them.

  • 14 Aug 2026

    I got the feeling that they raised the blast shields to help Uhura's disorientation that was related (or due to?) the monochrome. So she may have been helped but the colors stayed the same.

    At the end they said something like "Soon to exit the system, just about to exit Klingon space," which clearly implies the border is inside the system, which as you said is just weird.

    There were a few plot holes and glitches. For example, Kor said to Uhura, "Your ID card checks out," but...she didn't have a card was the whole point. And then he didn't have her followed?

    But overall I did like it. And we got to see where that opening sequence came from. I guess we'll see the rest soon. What is that triangular ship? Gorn?

  • 13 Aug 2026

    SNW merging the Eugenics Wars and WWIII into the same conflict does kinda solve the TOS-TNG discrepancy of when the 'last world war' took place.

    IIRC RDM did admit the 200 years ago for th EWs was a mistake, but he also said the DS9 writers agreed to never give a very specific date for the EWs because they were not happening in real life.

  • 13 Aug 2026

    "Knowing the mindset of the people producing SNW, it is safe to say that this episode's Kor is meant to be the exact same person as in TOS: "Errand of Mercy". Memory Alpha will likely comply and merge them into one article."

    They've already done just that. Sigh.

  • 13 Aug 2026

    I loved episode 4, a 9/10 for me.

    This episode would not have been out of place in TOS. It fits right along side a Piece of the Action, or Patterns of Force. Or any episode of any of the shows where they need to blend in. the Klingons also almost act like TOS Klingons, outside the mention of honor and singing the drinking song from DS9 (which I enjoyed hearing again)

    It felt very much OG Star Trek to me.

    This Kor quite clearly meant to be TOS Kor, nothing in the episode contradicts his later appearance in TOS. He even has his love for the mind scanner, which is originally from Errand of Mercy.

    whose inherited Augment features (that reboot Trek ignores) are not visible.

    I'm glad they're ignoring it, as it was a stupid retcon of another retcon. It should never have been explained.
    The Arne Darvin story in TTWT make much more sense if Klingons don't already look nearly identical to Humans.

    There is no reason to build the detonator in a way that it activates only in the presence of a Klingon control post - any of them.

    Unless I missed something, the episode never said it did? I thought it was on a remote signal.

  • 13 Aug 2026

    Some potentially useful images from the official artbook
    https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c... https://uploads.disquscdn.c...

  • 13 Aug 2026

    https://uploads.disquscdn.c...

  • 13 Aug 2026
    Read my review of SNW: "A Case of Chiaroscuro". The episode is steeped in a visual and narrative style that could be described as "Metropolis meets Casablanca". There is an underlying story beyond the style, even if it doesn't always convince.
  • 09 Aug 2026
    Two more old articles have been updated with new references and better pictures: Observations in TNG: "The Vengeance Factor" and Observations in TNG: "The Defector".
  • 06 Aug 2026
    My review of SNW: "Human Best Friend" is online now. The episode offers a surprisingly decent Scotty and Ortegas storyline. But the campy humor rarely lands and the rest of the character building feels forced.
  • 02 Aug 2026
    Added more references and better pictures to Jörg's article with Observations in TNG: "Redemption I".
  • 30 Jul 2026
    Here is my review of SNW: "The Griffin Incident". I suspect this one will be controversial.
  • 23 Jul 2026
    My review of SNW: "Valles Marineris" is online. The producers promised season 4 would feature fewer "big swings", but the premiere takes a swing so big that discussing it comes with one really, really big spoiler warning.
  • 18 Jul 2026
    Two more Enterprise retro reviews: "Fusion" and "Rogue Planet". One raises more questions than it answers about Vulcan culture and mind melds. The other strikes me as pointless and empty.
  • 12 Jul 2026
    Here are two more revised Enterprise reviews: "Shadows of P'Jem" and "Shuttlepod One". Both were among my least favorite season 1 episodes back in 2002. Read my reviews to find out whether almost 25 years have changed my opinion.
  • 11 Jul 2026
    I've posted two more Enterprise retro reviews: "Dear Doctor" and "Sleeping Dogs". One is among Enterprise's most controversial episodes and perhaps even more problematic than I thought 25 years ago. The other is a straightforward adventure that simply works.
  • 04 Jul 2026
    Here are two more Enterprise season 1 retro reviews: "Cold Front" and "Silent Enemy".
  • 28 Jun 2026
    I have added new references and better pictures to two more old articles by Jörg: Observations in TNG: "The Enemy" and Observations in TNG: "The Price".
  • 25 Jun 2026
    I've posted two more Enterprise retro reviews: "Civilization" and "Fortunate Son". One is an often overlooked episode that perhaps plays it a little too nice. The other is a deserved classic that almost everyone seems to like. Read my reviews to find out whether my opinion of either episode has changed over the past 25 years.
  • 21 Jun 2026
    Two more Enterprise retro reviews are online. Going into this rewatch, "The Andorian Incident" was one of the candidates I firmly expected to reassess. Read the review to find out. I also look at the quieter "Breaking the Ice", an episode about comets, human-Vulcan relations and the first cracks in the ice between T'Pol and Trip.
  • 20 Jun 2026
    With my Voyager review project now complete, here is an editorial reflecting on the series and its enduring reputation. I also look ahead to the next part of the review tour, which has just started: Star Trek Enterprise.
  • 18 Jun 2026
    Two more Enterprise season 1 retro reviews: "Unexpected" and "Terra Nova".
  • 16 Jun 2026
    The official Strange New Worlds season 4 trailer has arrived. After the dismal third season, the bar is admittedly very low, so I definitely expect an improvement. Whether season 4 will keep the promise of being "more serious" is another question. Read my comment.
EAS Favourites @ Deviantart
  • 17 Apr 2026

    Model by

    CaptainWhitmire

    thumbnail
  • 14 Apr 2026

    The tiny Starfleet Blackbird-class scout is a mere 104-meters long and dwarfed even by starships from 100-years ago. Far smaller than famous cruisers like the refit-Constitution-class USS Enterprise, these 22-man vessels scout ahead of Starfleet task groups, conduct months-long sector patrols from local Starfleet Starbases and Federation planets, and conduct anti-piracy patrols along Federation shipping lanes, responding to distress calls from any Federation craft, and performing search & rescue missions throughout the Federation to fill in the gaps left by larger and more capable Starfleet ships.

    The Blackbird-class was created by Bernd Schneider in 1996 and is featured on Ex-Astris Scientia (https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/my_ships/blackbird.htm)

    Exterior views by Bernd Schneider, updated by myself. Cross-sectional views and Deck plans by me.

    thumbnail
  • 13 Apr 2026

    The comet had no name yet, only a string of catalog numbers arrayed on the Astrometric LCARS. But to Lt. Alexa Wolff it felt personal, almost whimsical too. A point of light threading the dark, illuminating their way.

    She leaned forward towards the console, taking all the readings in. Data points left and right, immaculate scans of the surface and ejecta. This was exactly what she imagined as a child beneath the domes of Tycho City. Peering through her first telescope, reading stories of daring captains. Batel, Kirk, Saavik, the golden years. Now she was here, at the very same forefront.

    “Helm, bring us two hundred kilometers closer.” came Captain Han Lo’s voice over the comm. The visual lenses adjusted, Alexa noticing the Rooivalk was moving in closer, thrusters gliding her on. The hull catching faint reflections of the comet’s glow. The captain had not questioned her request, not even hesitated. The confidence in her expertise had startled her more than any formal commendation. Somewhere in the back of her mind, a younger version of herself smiling gleefully.

    Enhanced scans blossomed with new detail. Ice and dust resolved into layers. Ancient volatiles trapped since the dawn of time, now shedding themselves in delicate arcs. Alexa adjusted the filters, isolating elements, mapping a 3d simulation, simulcast to the bridge. “It’s beautiful.” she whispered to herself. Obscure beauty indeed. The kind that required patience, curiosity and faith that meaning existed in the far corners of space.

    “Careful, Lieutenant...” Captain Lo said, with a trace of amusement. “At this distance, we might inspire it. Give it a few million years and it could start its own civilization, studying us in return.”

    Alexa laughed softly, though her eyes never left the display. “Then we’d better make a good impression, sir.” She paused, recording another data stream. “If they ever ask how it all began, I hope it starts like this. With someone choosing to come a little closer.”

    ---

    3ds Max / Photoshop

    Vesper Class from ST: Online

    My Links: https://linktr.ee/jetfreak

    ---

    thumbnail
  • 12 Apr 2026

    The Kumari Battlecruiser (2)

    thumbnail
Jörg Hillebrand @ Mastodon
  • 16 Aug 2026

    ...(William Shatner, Molly Hagan, Bruce Markinson), William Shatner's character is also seen drinking from a glass from the same set ⬅️ as the one Admiral Jarok drinks from in 's "The Defector"➡️. Yes, I am thorough! :-) is everywhere, this makes me incredibly happy! 2/2

  • 16 Aug 2026

    My friend Timo and I are currently rewatching every single episode and I'm always on the lookout for connections. Today, it was time for the second Shatner outing, "Butterfly in Shades of Grey" from 1994. Well, I got my reference! 😊 Apart from the obvious casting parallels...1/2

  • 16 Aug 2026

    Notice how Sela's hairstyle (or the wig that Denise Crosby is wearing) has changed slightly between the end of 's "Redemption I"⬇️ and "Redemption II"⬆️. The new wig looks a little less severe or "pointy"... ;-)

  • 16 Aug 2026

    This is the official emblem of the planet of Mat'Aar (XII), briefly seen in the background on some displays on the planet in 's "A Case of Chiaroscuro". The text translates to "Planet of (top) Mat'Aar (bottom)". I have deciphered the whole alien alphabet (a substitution cypher), more later! 😊

  • 16 Aug 2026

    In 's "Destiny", Yarka's personnel file contains the Bajoran emblem. The full text at the bottom reads:
    "Formerly a member of the Vedek Assembly, recently defrocked. Official explanation states Yarka expelled due to teachings "not in keeping with Bajoran faith". Other sources reveal that Yarka led a series of protests against the Vedek Assembly after they endorsed the peace treaty with Cardassia."

  • 16 Aug 2026

    The text on this Klingon sign on Mat'aar XII in 's "A Case of Chiaroscuro" is actual Klingon text. I tried to translate what it means. Bear in mind, though, that I don't speak Klingon, please!!
    As you can see, the signs tells people to stop, as security has to verify so that people are allowed to the site. A permit to identify people is needed to pass. People's bodies will be searched at the location. They have to be prepared (for something).

  • 15 Aug 2026

    We get a good look at the Bajoran Promenade temple entrance, featuring the Bajoran emblem, in "Destiny". If you remember, this sign replaced the old one roughtly mid-season 2 of the show.

  • 15 Aug 2026

    Be careful what you wish for! ;-)
    's "A Case of Chiaroscuro" and 's "Relics".

  • 15 Aug 2026

    This shot of the USS Enterprise-D and the USS Enterprise-C in 's "Yesterday's Enterprise"⬇️ was re-composited (the two ships are closer together) and re-used in "Redemption II"⬆️ for the USS Enterprise-D and USS Excalibur (including battle damage) shot.

  • 15 Aug 2026

    Content warning:#StarTrekSNW "A Case of Chiaroscuro" spoilers


    Here's a comparison of Mat'Aar XII before ⬆️ and after Klingon invasion ⬇️, as seen in 's "A Case of Chiaroscuro". Quite a difference, night and day! ;-)

EAS Timeline @ Facebook

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery