EAS Today

EditorialEAS UpdatesEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageEAS @ FacebookEAS Blog @ TumblrEAS @ Flickr

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
24 May 2020

Strange Old Worlds

I can't remember any Star Trek announcement of the past two decades that was so well-received in the fan community as the one of Strange New Worlds, the Discovery spin-off series with Captain Pike (Anson Mount), Spock (Ethan Peck) and Number One (Rebecca Romijn).

As much as I personally hate the prospect that the reckless reboot of Star Trek continues, Strange New Worlds (SNW) is proof that the people at CBS are listening to the fans, and willing to revise some of their errors they made with Discovery and, to lesser extent, with Picard:

  • Like TOS end every other classic Star Trek series, SNW is going to be episodic again. This is a clear departure from the heavily serialized concept of DIS and PIC, which at the time these two were announced was deemed the only way to produce a "modern" TV series.
  • As per Akiva Goldsman's affirmations, the new show is "going to try to harken back to some classical Trek values, to be optimistic." This is an implicit confession that these values were not present or not perceptible enough in Discovery and Picard.
  • The example of Captain Pike and his classic virtues illustrates what is wrong with the "edgy" characters of Discovery, most of whom are eccentric, obstinate, deceitful or otherwise unlikable - and simply not Trek-like. The moment Pike comes aboard in DIS: "Brother", it is obvious he is designed as the savior of Discovery, and is well-received by fans and "haters" of the show alike.

On the downside, SNW will be the creatively most limited Star Trek series ever produced. It will have the reboot look and the anachronistic technology of Discovery (at least the one whose existence Starfleet doesn't lie about). It will feature the characters of Pike, Spock and Number One we already know. It will have to fit into the barely eight years from Discovery to the Kirk era. This does not sound at all like the premise Star Trek needs to boldly go and explore strange new worlds (at least not without giving rise to even more major continuity errors).

In this regard, SNW is the logical culmination of a trend. For some reason the producers of new Star Trek are obsessed with "going back to the roots", with reducing the complex universe to a very simple formula and with focusing on known characters from the TOS era.

  • Abrams did it in "Star Trek (2009)" with the formula "Star Trek = Kirk + Spock + Enterprise". An alliance forged by destiny in this alternate universe, and against all logic.
  • All Star Trek movies of the past 20 years did it by designing a villain similar to, or even identical to Khan, because "Star Trek movie = fight against a villain who wants to destroy the Enterprise, Earth or the galaxy" and "ultimate Star Trek villain = Khan".
  • Discovery initially tried something new and brutally anti-nostalgic, I'll give them that. The story would have worked infinitely better in the far future and with a race other than the Klingons, but it was forcibly squeezed in the pre-TOS era, with the only benefit that it could use the punchline "Back to the roots, before Kirk, etc.". When the series went downhill, it was decided to throw in the usual high dose of token nostalgia, because "Star Trek before Kirk = Pike + Spock + Enterprise", which now becomes the premise of SNW.

The people at CBS fail to see Star Trek as a whole, as a universe that has a future and not just a past, that waits to be further explored. Picard is a small step in the right direction but it too lives too much in the past. Strange New Worlds may become a success because of its likable characters and the return to classic values. But it is further sad proof that the Star Trek Universe has become a canvas that no one wants to extend anymore, and that simply gets painted over.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Recent EAS Updates
  • 04 Dec 2020
    Book receives disturbing news from his homeworld, as the Emerald Chain is out for revenge and threatens to destroy the planet. Read my review of DIS: "The Sanctuary".
  • 29 Nov 2020
    I thought it would be fun to compile a complete gallery of Guinan's Outfits (and especially her many hats). And while I was at it, I made some observations.
  • 27 Nov 2020
    In order to solve the mystery of the Burn, the Discovery travels to Ni'Var, the planet formerly known as Vulcan that is now home to the Romulan people as well. Here is my review of DIS: "Unification III".
  • 21 Nov 2020
    Our new article Risian Logos and Design investigates all appearances of actual and potential logos of Risa, as well as writing and typical design elements.
  • 20 Nov 2020
    The retrofitted Discovery is ordered to stand by as a "rapid response" ship. But when Burnham learns that Booker is missing and that there is a chance to trace back the origin of the Burn, she sets out on a rescue mission. Read my review of DIS: "Scavengers".
  • 13 Nov 2020
    Having arrived at Federation Headquarters, the Discovery crew have to prove worthy of staying together. Here is my review of DIS: "Die Trying".
  • 06 Nov 2020
    The Discovery visits Trill, in the hope that Adira may connect with the symbiont Tal and retrieve lost memories. In the meantime, Saru invites his senior officers to a dinner, compared to which the one with the Klingons from "Star Trek VI" is a smashing success. Read my review of DIS: "Forget Me Not".
  • 30 Oct 2020
    After Michael Burnham has rejoined the crew, the USS Discovery sets a course for Earth and is caught in an unexpected conflict. Read my review of the latest episode of season 3, DIS: "People of Earth".
  • 23 Oct 2020
    The USS Discovery too ends up in the 32nd century, and the crew has to deal with different kinds of parasites. Here is my review of the second episode of season 3, "Far From Home".
  • 16 Oct 2020
    Michael Burnham arrives in the 32nd century, only to notice that a lot of things have changed for the worse. Here is my review of the Discovery season 3 premiere, "That Hope Is You, Part 1".
Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
EAS Timeline @ Twitter
EAS Favourites @ Deviantart
  • 05 Sep 2020
    The bridge of the Enterprise as seen in the second season of Star Trek: Discovery under the command of Captain Christopher Pike.

    This image was commissioned by vagarcia74 (with a few minor modifications not shown here).

    Assets used (available to purchase on CGTrader):
    Modelled and rendered with Blender. Computer display textures made with Inkscape.
    Based on and inspired by original designs from:
    -Star Trek (CBS)
    thumbnail
  • 11 Aug 2020
    Holy flippin' moley, Lower Decks managed to be something Discovery and Picard (especially Picard!) failed at: being a real Star Trek series!
    Okay, it's comedic, it's meant to be light-hearted, but it's real Star Trek! I was surprised, I was amazed, and I was hooked!

    So, I had to do a "realistic" version of the USS Cerritos. Given that the show is heavily stylized, I thought to myself, the ship must also have more details in a "real world" setting. So I added some classic Trek greebles and nurnies, just for the fun of it. I tweaked some proportions, played with deck layouts, and here we go: my own California class design.

    BTW, don't you think this ship is the love child of my Polaris and a Nebula class ship? ;)

    Model by me

    thumbnail
  • 22 May 2020
    This is the crew from Star Trek The Motion Picture, including the original Star Trek Diamond Select Toys action figures + some customs. This figures are in scale to Diamond Select Toys/Art Asylum action figures, 7 inches high.
    thumbnail
EAS Timeline @ Facebook
EAS Blog @ Tumblr
Screen Caps@ Flickr
TNG Remastered

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery