Ex Astris Scientia
  Home  Info  Starships  Fleet Yards  Treknology  Episodes  Database  Fandom  Community    Classical Music   FAQ   Site Map 
 

EAS Today

EAS Random Page & Image
Starship Gallery - Galaxy
galaxy-christies2.jpg, 1600x1200 pixels
EAS Timeline @ Google+
EAS Timeline @ Twitter
Screen Caps @ Flickr
Editorial

Willkommen, jolan tru, welcome!

It took me two weeks until I decided to go and see "Star Trek Into Darkness", although it is shown exclusively in 3D and I can't focus my eyes on 3D movies. Watching STID was a surprisingly pleasant experience for my eyes, at least technically speaking. But the movie could have easily done without the almost unnoticeable 3D effects that were inserted into the live action scenes in post production.

Regarding the story of STID, I was prepared that the villain would be Khan, the justification being that the fans wanted him to return. It is clear that when Harrison reveals who he really is, saying "I am Khan", he is breaking the fourth wall. His true identity has no impact whatsoever on the story. On the contrary, it would make a lot sense if he were any other person, because Khan 2.0 (Cumberbatch) looks and feels very different than version 1.0 (Montalban), because Khan 1.0 never was a fighting machine with miraculous blood, and because Khan 2.0 has a weak back story, as opposed to the 15 years that Khan 1.0 spent on a desert planet.

But the worse rip-off was still to come. STID repeats the death scene from "Star Trek II", the sequence of events and the dialogues being almost exactly the same, only with switched roles. At this point the movie lost me. Abrams has given himself carte blanche to create a Trek universe it its own right, but all he does is recycling characters, stories and plot devices. It is bad enough that he includes all kinds of gratuitous references, as if he was saying, "Look, this is still Star Trek. We've even got Khan for you." When Kirk and Spock (who know one another for just one year in this universe) press their hands on the glass pane, it is an unintentional parody, and what was supposed to be the emotional highlight of STID drowns in deserved laughter.

The perhaps most definite failing on the long term is that Star Trek has stopped exploring and is just about chasing villains. Agreed, this tendency is anything but new and was already visible in the last few movies set in the Prime Universe. But isn't it dishonest that STID, like already "Star Trek (2009)", ends with the famous words "Space - the final frontier..." when true fans would rather ask, "Can anyone remember when we used to be explorers?" Extremely little of the old spirit is left in this new Star Trek, and the brief musings about friendship or the human nature feel like fillers between the action scenes.

STID had great action, but that is not what I want to see in Star Trek in the first place. Much less do I have a desire to see Kirk, Spock and the other characters jump around as if they had supernatural forces. In an effort to keep up with other summer blockbusters, Abrams has sacrificed the essence of Star Trek, and has turned STID into yet another superhero flick.

Read the complete review.   

Bernd Schneider

Recent EAS Updates
  • Easy and Safe Sharing of EAS Pages in Social Media

    17 Apr 2014

    I have found a way to enable easy sharing of EAS pages without allowing a third party to track my visitors. Go to the bottom left of any page to share it using Twitter, Facebook, Google+ or e-mail.
  • Observations in TNG: "Galaxy's Child"

    16 Apr 2014

    Here are our Observations in TNG: "Galaxy's Child". See Junior's birth and how his milk becomes sour in the HD screen cap gallery at TrekCore.
  • New Ship Side Views

    15 Apr 2014

    Alice Orbán has sketched up better side views of some Delta Quadrant vessels: Sikarian ship, Bothan ship, Serosian ship, Nyrian habitat vessel, Etanian ship, Species 6339 shuttle. Also, I have added a new side view of the Vengeance by The-Didact.
  • Observations in TNG: "First Contact"

    14 Apr 2014

    Our next article: Observations in TNG: "First Contact". See what happens to Riker in an alien hospital in the HD screen cap gallery at TrekCore.
  • TNG Reviews: "Attached" and "Force of Nature"

    13 Apr 2014

    Two more TNG season 7 reviews: "Attached" and "Force of Nature".
  • Observations in TNG: "Clues"

    09 Apr 2014

    Here are our Observations in TNG: "Clues". See the story of Data's big secret in an extensive screen cap gallery at TrekCore.
  • Observations in TNG: "Devil's Due"

    06 Apr 2014

    Presenting our next article: Observations in TNG: "Devil's Due". Our friends at TrekCore have created a gallery with 449 HD screen caps from the episode.
  • Observations in TNG: "The Wounded"

    04 Apr 2014

    Here is our next article: Observations in TNG: "The Wounded". See how Captain Picard deals with Captain Maxwell and the Cardassians on 373 HD screen caps, including the new ships of the Nebula class and the Galor class, at TrekCore.
  • Contents of the TNG Season 6 Blu-rays and of the "Chain of Command" Blu-ray

    03 Apr 2014

    CBS Home has published the contents of the upcoming TNG season 6 Blu-ray disc set and of the special "Chain of Command" Blu-ray (release date June 3, 2014).
  • TNG Reviews: "Phantasms" and "Dark Page"

    02 Apr 2014

    Here are the next two TNG season 7 reviews: "Phantasms" and "Dark Page".
EAS Favourites @deviantART
EAS Timeline @ Facebook

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 


EAS Today Archive

  Share 
  Home   Top    View as gallery 
Last modified: 03.04.14  
http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/eastoday.htm