Star Trek Discovery (DIS) Season 1
Season 1Season 2
The Vulcan Hello / Battle at the Binary StarsContext is for KingsThe Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's CryChoose Your PainLetheMagic to Make the Sanest Man Go MadSi Vis Pacem, Para BellumInto the Forest I GoDespite YourselfThe Wolf InsideVaulting AmbitionWhat's Past Is PrologueThe War Without, The War WithinWill You Take My Hand?
Stardate 1207.3 (May 11th, 2256): Klingon leader T'Kuvma announces that he is going to reunite the different houses of his people, against a common enemy, the Federation. Captain Philippa Georgiou and Commander Michael Burnham of the USS Shenzhou are on a mission to help the non-humanoid Crepusculans, whose planet suffers from a drought. Almost unnoticed by the natives, the Starfleet officers open a well for them. A gathering storm prevents a transporter lock, so Georgiou orders Burnham to follow her on what seems to be a circle through the desert but is actually a big Starfleet emblem as a signal for the Shenzhou to beam them up. The Shenzhou proceeds to a damaged subspace relay at the edge of Federation space, near a binary star with intense radiation. The damage may have been caused on purpose by an object hidden inside a scattering field. Burnham takes an environmental suit to investigate the alien artifact. She is welcomed by what turns out to be a Klingon warrior that attacks her with a bat'leth. Burnham fires her thrusters and rams the bat'leth into the body of the Klingon. The dead warrior, the so-called Torchbearer, is recovered by his comrades, led by T'Kuvma. On the Shenzhou, Burnham wakes up in a medical pod but interrupts the procedure to heal her radiation burns, in order to warn Captain Georgiou of the arrival of the Klingons. Although there is no evidence, Georgiou trusts Burnham's words and calls for reinforcements. Meanwhile on the alien ship, an albino Klingon named Voq volunteers to become the new Torchbearer and to "light the beacon". T'Kuvma, who was once an outcast himself, accepts. On the Shenzhou, Burnham calls her foster father Sarek to seek his advice how to deal with the Klingons. Sarek adopted her after her parents had been killed in a Klingon raid on the research outpost Doctari Alpha. She comes back to the bridge with a quite unusual proposal: to fire first, in order to earn the respect of the enemy. Georgiou declines. In the captain's ready room, Burnham disables Georgiou with a Vulcan neck pinch and orders the bridge crew to prepare the attack. As Georgiou returns with a phaser, many Klingon vessels drop out of warp. -- Seven years ago, Captain Georgiou welcomed Michael Burnham, the only human to attend the Vulcan Learning Center and the Vulcan Science Academy, aboard her ship. She became Burnham's mentor. Now it is her sad duty to confine Burnham to the brig. As several more Starfleet ships appear in the area, Georgiou calls the Klingon leader and tells him that Starfleet comes in peace. T'Kuvma calls this a lie. He convinces the other house leaders that the Federation wants to assimilate the Klingons. The Klingons open fire. During the battle, the wounded and confused Ensign Connor comes to the brig to seek Burnham's advice, but he gets blown out into space when the hull breaches. Sarek appears in Burnham's mind, telling her that she carries part of his katra. Sarek actually saved Burnham with a mind meld when she was a child. The USS Europa with Admiral Anderson appears on the scene and tractors away the Shenzhou that is adrift in space. Anderson proposes a cease-fire to T'Kuvma. The Klingon leader agrees, but then rams the Federation ship with the cloaked vessel, upon which Anderson activates the self-destruct. The other Klingon ships warp away after their victory, leaving only T'Kuvma's vessel. While Burnham prepares her escape from the heavily damaged brig, Georgiou and Saru wonder how they can attack T'Kuvma's ship although the Shenzhou's weapons are down. They devise a plan to steer a work pod with a photon torpedo into the enemy vessel, a suicide mission for which Georgiou volunteers. Burnham appears and advises against killing T'Kuvma because this would make him a martyr in the eyes of his people. When the crew witnesses how the Klingons tractor in the bodies of dead warriors, they plant an antimatter charge into a body and detonate it inside the enemy ship. Georgiou and Burnham beam over to apprehend T'Kuvma. But T'Kuvma kills Georgiou, whereupon Burnham kills T'Kuvma. On the court martial, Burnham pleads guilty. She is stripped of rank and sentenced to imprisonment for life.
Star Trek finally returns to the small screen, twelve years after the last Enterprise episode and almost two years after the first announcement of the then unnamed new series. Star Trek Discovery starts with a two-part episode that can be described as a prologue, rather than a pilot. "The Vulcan Hello" and "Battle at the Binary Stars" explore Michael Burnham's past on Vulcan, her relationship to Captain Philippa Georgiou and the disastrous encounter with the Klingons. Neither the eponymous starship Discovery nor some of the later regular crew members appear in this prologue. I was a bit surprised when the second part ended somewhat abruptly with Burnham's conviction for mutiny, but perhaps I just have to get used to serialized television.
Michael Burnham (Sonequa Martin-Green) is not only the lead character of the series. The whole narrative of "The Vulcan Hello" and "Battle at the Binary Stars" is built around her. We learn many things about Burnham's childhood and youth, how Sarek took care of her, how Captain Georgiou became her mentor and how she and Saru use to disagree on many things. All pilot episodes since TNG explored the past histories of one or two of their principal characters to some extent, but never in such a depth. It was worth the effort. Burnham's unique two perspectives (the human heart and the Vulcan mind) are worked out very well, as well as her struggle to find the right answers and make the right decision. And although her logic and her instinct prove her right in retrospect, what she does is a huge stupid mistake. In many ways, Burnham's character is in the tradition of Spock and of Seven of Nine, and has a lot of potential. Sonequa Martin-Green's play is captivating, and is among the main reasons for me to tune in again.
I like Philippa Georgiou (Michelle Yeoh) very much. She represents firm principles, wise leadership and unassuming kindness, key qualities that were sadly suppressed in the Abrams movies. Her occasional sarcasm is refreshing. Also, it is beneficial for the diversity of the series that Michelle Yeoh keeps her accent and doesn't try to come across as yet another American. In the dispute with Burnham, I am all with Georgiou. Even with the experience that the Klingons might attack or would usually attack, it still is wrong to fire first. It was obvious that Georgiou would not survive the episode. Only the way she would die was still open. I was sort of relieved when Georgiou's plan to go on the suicide mission with a photon torpedo was discarded. It was more appropriate for her to be killed trying to apprehend T'Kuvma, which also gave Burnham the opportunity to redeem herself in Georgiou's eyes. Overall, Captain Georgiou was a well-conceived and well-played character that I will miss.
T'Kuvma's (Chris Obi) demise, on the other hand, comes as a surprise. He was the arguably most advertised character besides Burnham in the promotion campaign for Discovery. The impression was created that T'Kuvma would be the Klingon leader in the war against the Federation, rather than some fanatic agitator who dies in the very first battle. T'Kuvma is not so great a character anyway, so it is not a big loss in my view. T'Kuvma is excellent in giving speeches, but that is about all he does in the two episodes. He has practically no interaction with Starfleet. In the promotion campaign it was made a big deal that the Klingons would not simply be enemies but would have a good cause to fight for, to preserve their way of life. However, there is nothing like a good cause in T'Kuvma's agenda. He laments that the Federation would come and destroy the "purity" of the Klingon race - although he has no reason to assume that, since his whole species has not really been in contact with the Federation for a hundred years, much less his secluded sect. T'Kuvma is a racist by all means, more like a Klingon Hitler than a reincarnation of Kahless. This is very unfortunate as it sort of annihilates the intent to depict T'Kuvma's house as an ancient and solemn sect and the preservers of the Klingon heritage. There is only one sign that T'Kuvma is more than an evil fascist leader. He accepts Voq, an albino, as the new Torchbearer, thereby overcoming the conventions and prejudices of his people. We don't know what role Voq will play in future episodes, but it may be something of further significance for the Klingons as a whole.
I watched "The Vulcan Hello" and "Battle at the Binary Stars" with the intention to give the series a chance, although I loathe the extreme changes to the Klingon species, to their starships and to their styling. Discovery looks, sounds and feels decent as long as we move through the USS Shenzhou and follow the Starfleet crew. But as soon as the Klingons (or their ships) come into sight, it is outrageously hard to even accept them as Klingon, much less to like them. The elongated heads of the redesigned species are more visible in the episodes than in the trailers. No one can possibly claim they are the still same race as the familiar Klingons, only without hair. But it is not just the look. These Klingons are not capable of clear articulation, and I wonder whether it is a result of the heavy make-up and false teeth or of additional electronic distortion. It is very sad that the makers of Discovery have learned nothing from the mistake of the mumbling villain Krall in "Star Trek Beyond". Furthermore, TOS as well as TMP Klingons used to be agile. The new ones are cumbersome and sluggish under their thick armor and prosthetics. With the way they speak and move, not to mention their overblown attire, the Klingons and especially T'Kuvma appear as pompous and not as people we may be able to relate to, although exactly that was the clear intention of the producers. Overall, the alterations to the Klingons are still a bit worse than I anticipated, utterly disrespectful of the alien race that millions of fans love and arguably the biggest mistake ever made in Star Trek.
The Klingons are not the only continuity buster of Discovery. They are just the most obvious and most annoying one. Considering how the producers still insist on Discovery being set in the Prime Universe (the same as TOS) and adhering to canon, the logical conclusion is that canon, in their view, only consists of facts in the form of screenplay contents but not of visual facts, or only facultatively of visuals. This is not only an inappropriate principle in a visual medium by its very nature, it is also short-sighted. In traditional Star Trek the looks of characters, props and sets had a meaning not only in the very episode but also on a larger comparative scale. Such as the Klingons, whose different make-ups were an issue in DS9: "Trials and Tribble-ations" and ENT: "Divergence". Such as Starfleet's ship design lineage that shows an evolution from the simple shapes of the original Enterprise to the streamlined and more edgy designs of the 24th century. The lineage was retroactively extended to the NX-01, albeit not completely satisfactorily. The USS Shenzhou is a still bigger offender than the NX-01. The idea is absurd to place the 24th century design of the Shenzhou next to the original Enterprise and claim that the former is a couple of years older. Or to maintain the assertion that the Shenzhou is 140+ years older than the similar looking Akira class. Even compared to the lead ship of the series, the Discovery, the "old" Shenzhou looks like a much more advanced design. And as already mentioned, this is one of the smaller problems compared to the Klingon dilemma.
Anyway, from now, we are supposed to ignore visual discontinuities, because the producers and designers decide arbitrarily what they are going to preserve, what should be reimagined and what can be recycled from the pool of Star Trek's many other eras and timelines, as an anachronism. Nitpicking is not endorsed any longer as the looks are concerned, and attempts to explain visual discrepancies are futile because we are silently expected to exercise doublethink. This is why I will treat Discovery as a reboot, a series set in a new continuity that generally does not have to comply with the previous Star Trek. Either that, or my brain will explode.
One further consequence of the lacking visual continuity is that Discovery so far looks and feels rather generic. We are on a Starfleet vessel. The time is ten years before TOS. But the only indicators of a time are the date mentioned by Burnham and Sarek's appearance. Otherwise, the series doesn't give me the impression that it is specifically set in this era. The Shenzhou is a starship that looks "as usual" from the outside, and is full of all the usual futuristic technology. The crew wears previously unseen uniforms that could belong in any era. The ship then runs into some monstrous alien vessel. The enemies are identified as Klingons. They speak Klingon. They have Klingon symbols. They have heavily decorated swords resembling bat'leths. But despite these very few things that were preserved they overall feel like a generic alien race, just with a bad taste of clothing and architecture. They could have been any other race, and it would have made a lot more sense. The series could have been set in the far future, and all it would have required was to abandon the character of Sarek. This is the fundamental problem with Discovery. It tries to shoehorn its story and its reimagined appearances into the existing Star Trek. The producers perceive Star Trek as a mere platform for "timeless" stories and designs, not as a timeline.
The story of the first two Discovery episodes is easily one of the darkest of Star Trek so far. It shows a mutiny on a Starfleet ship, a crusade with a racist motivation and the beginning of a war. This doesn't bode well for the episodes to come, at least not in the sense of relaying the message of a better future. The script tries to compensate for the sordid elements of the story with affirmations, especially by Captain Georgiou ("We come in peace.", "Starfleet doesn't fire first.") and Admiral Anderson, that almost break the fourth wall. I hope that the peaceful, benevolent and optimistic side of Star Trek will resurface in future episodes, but it is reduced to mere phrases in "The Vulcan Hello" and "Battle at the Binary Stars".
Although the two episodes focus very much on the characters and particularly on Burnham, everything appears quite plot-driven in hindsight. T'Kuvma was going to war anyway, so the Shenzhou became the first victim of his crusade only by chance. At no point of the two episodes he is open to listening to anything else but his own sermons. Michael Burnham attempts a mutiny and will face reproaches of having started a war, but she doesn't actually shoot first as she wanted. And even if she had fired first, what would she have accomplished? I doubt T'Kuvma would have understood a "Vulcan hello". Ultimately neither the characters nor their interactions (as far as these take place at all) can change anything about what comes to pass. There are also several plot holes and unlikely twists, mostly on the Klingon side, to pave a way that inevitably leads into the war with the Federation.
Overall, the flow of the story is good in both episodes despite these problems. Still, in "The Vulcan Hello" I had the impression that the suspenseful scenes on the bridge of the Shenzhou could have been somewhat more dynamic. It may be curious that such a criticism comes from me, considering that the fast pace of the Abrams movies almost made me nauseous. Anyway, what I would have liked to see is fewer camera pans, moves and tilts but more cuts, to indicate that a situation is exciting. In "Battle at the Binary Stars", on the other hand, the problem with the pace was that suspenseful moments were too often interrupted. They suffered a bit from too frequent cuts to a slow scene or to a flashback. Furthermore I find it bothersome that both episodes have placeholders for commercial breaks. It is clear that the episodes will be shown on free TV channels at a later date, but on a paid streaming service I just don't want to have such disruptive cuts.
Star Trek Discovery borrows visual effects such as the phaser pulses and the star streaks from the Abrams movies, rather than from previous TV series. It strives to be "cinematic", which apparently matters more than visual continuity. I am positively surprised, however, that the space scenes and the battle in "The Vulcan Hello" and "Battle at the Binary Stars" were not the visual overkill that I expected from the trailers and from my Abramsverse experiences. "The Vulcan Hello" features a space ride similar to the ones in the two first Abrams movies but this one doesn't feel over the top, and it underlines that Burnham is only human and not a superhero. Overall, everything CGI was rather pleasant watching. Curiously, it is the rather calm scenes such as on the bridge of the Shenzhou that are annoying and almost cause nausea because of the tilted camera, apparently in an attempt to create "interesting" visuals to compensate for a lack of action. At times I felt reminded of the awful movie "Battlefield Earth" (don't worry, I endured only a small portion of it). The Discovery prologue episodes also have almost as many lens flares as an average Abrams movie. On a final note about the "cinematic" visuals of Discovery, the series is filmed in 2:1 aspect ratio, leaving black bars on the top and bottom of a usual 16:9 screen. While I still don't see the reason not to use the whole screen, at least it didn't feel uncomfortable.
One more thing on the visual side that I dislike about Discovery (or at least about the two first episodes) is the dim lighting. It may be appropriate in some situations, but the whole two episodes were overall too dark. And I'm not even talking about the courtroom scene in which the faces of the judges were not recognizable. Yes, this may have some symbolic meaning, but I just want to see more for my money.
Discovery comes with an unusual title sequence. For the first time in Star Trek the focus is not on space and starships, but on props and symbols. I like the visuals of the title, although the color choice of beige and red is still something I have to get used to. The title theme is traditional and unobtrusive but overall unremarkable. I may have to listen to it more often, but it's not something I'm likely to whistle in the shower.
I am fond of the sounds on the bridge of the Shenzhou, which are a mix of familiar TOS beeps and occasional more elaborate sounds from the 24th century. And contrary to common belief, I won't make it a continuity issue that sounds appear before their time.
Overall, Discovery has a promising start. The two first episodes give us a good blend of exciting and thoughtful moments, although they are a bit uneven as the directing is concerned. I don't know whether I can ever put up with the new Klingons. I don't know whether Discovery can prove to me that it is more than a generic Star Trek series with loose continuity. I don't know whether the series can still manage to show a positive vision of the future. In any case I look forward to finally seeing the USS Discovery (not at all my favorite design but still better than the anachronistic Shenzhou). And I look forward to the further adventures of Michael Burnham, who may become one of my favorite Star Trek characters.
- None of the Klingons in this episode looks like the ones of TOS or TMP, although we see members of several houses. Very few of the Klingon ships of the 24 houses look remotely like familiar Klingon types. Regarding the Klingons, Discovery is a total visual reboot.
- The Starfleet ships don't fit into the established design lineage. Unfortunately the most prominent vessel, the Shenzhou, is also the biggest disappointment. The Shenzhou has tapered angular nacelles, additional spikes, odd-angled hull plates and an overall streamlined shape, totally like other official and non-official 24th century designs by John Eaves. The Shenzhou is explicitly said to be an old ship but it is among the sleekest designs of the series. The USS Europa is similarly unfitting for the era. Some other Starfleet ships are more simplistic in shape, including extremely boxy nacelles, which *could* insinuate that they are not the most recent designs if it were not for the Shenzhou.
- Several visual styles and several design features are taken from the Abramsverse and shouldn't exist in the Prime Universe in this form or at this time: bridge windows, 23rd century ships capable of landing, ship and handheld phasers firing pulses instead of continuous beams, ships popping out of warp in an instant, the warp flight effect with "turbulences".
- The Klingons have cloaking technology in 2256, although cloaking is a previously unknown and probably new feature on their ships in "Star Trek III". Perhaps we have to apply the same (lame) explanation that, just as the Romulan cloaking in ENT: "Minefield", a "scattering field" is something less advanced?
- The Klingons appear to have purple blood, apparently in an attempt to find a compromise between red and pink.
- The storm was still 1h 17min away according to Michael Burnham, but wouldn't it have engulfed most of the Starfleet emblem made of footsteps in a dust cloud, by the time Georgiou and Burnham arrive at their starting point again? Wouldn't the wind that was already strong while they were walking have blown it away altogether?
- Real-time communication with Starfleet is possible from the edge of Federation space? Well, maybe with one relay destroyed the Shenzhou is close enough to other relays.
- Does it make sense that T'Kuvma is so worried about the purity of the Klingons when his people has been in a 100-year-long isolation anyway?
- It takes barely ten minutes from the sending of the pulse to the simultaneous arrival of all 24 ships of the Klingon house leaders. This is only possible if all ships were expecting T'Kuvma's call, in some place near the binary stars (no matter if the leaders were personally aboard their ships or not). But there is no indication that they had received an advance notice. On the contrary, when T'Kuvma first contacts the other leaders after the arrival of the ships, they are surprised to see T'Kuvma and more than skeptical about his plan.
- It is rather ridiculous anyway that in an empire that is more like a loose alliance of 24 warlords who also fight each other, a 25th one, an outsider, needs nothing more than a fabricated incident and a few phrases to convince all 24 colleagues (perhaps except for Kol) to join his crusade on the spot.
- For Michael Burnham it is a big deal that exactly 24 ships arrive. But how logical is it to expect that all of the 24 leaders arrive, and each with exactly one ship?
- Does it make sense that Georgiou and Burnham beam over all alone to apprehend T'Kuvma? There may have been few or faint lifesigns at the time, but shouldn't they expect that the damaged section could be swarming with Klingons again very soon?
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "Ensign Connor, agreement between my senior officers. Note the date and time." - "Noted, captain." (Captain Georgiou and Ensign Connor)
- "They [the Vulcans] said hello in a language the Klingons understood. Violence brought respect. Respect brought peace. Captain. We have to give the Klingons a Vulcan hello." - "If their intention is to attack, balling up our fists won't dissuade them." (Commander Burnham and Captain Georgiou)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Your human tongue is not the problem. It is your human heart." (Sarek, to young Michael)
- "Starfleet doesn't fire first." (Captain Georgiou)
- Remarkable scenes:
- In the opening sequence, a starscape morphs into T'Kuvma's eye.
- Georgiou, Burnham and Saru investigate the object inside the scattering field with an optical telescope because the optical processors don't manage to provide a clear picture.
- Burnham discusses with the brig computer to enable the ethical protocol that would release the prisoner in case of an emergency. Her logic prevails.
- Remarkable facts:
- Saru is a Kelpien. On his homeworld, there is not food chain but only predators and prey. His species is the latter.
- Michael Burnham was the the only human to attend the Vulcan Learning Center and the Vulcan Science Academy. Her original intention was to join the Vulcan Expeditionary Group but she ended up in Starfleet.
- The Shenzhou uses a "lateral vector transporter" that is considered outdated by the Vulcans and also by Starfleet. This is apparently supposed to explain the "steampunk" look of the transporter, unlike the ones seen on any earlier or later Starfleet ships.
- Eagle 12 is 3 light years away from the binary system. The Andorian Gamma Hydra colony is 6 light years away.
- 240 years ago, near H'atoria, a Vulcan vessel was destroyed by the Klingons. From then, the Vulcans fired first and earned the respect of the Klingons. Hence the episode title.
- The Prime Directive is referred to as "General Order 1".
6 months later: Michael Burnham is on a prisoner transport when spacebourne creatures drain the shuttle of its energy. The shuttle is rescued by the USS Discovery where the prisoners are given a cold welcome. Saru is also aboard the Discovery, as the ship's first officer. Burnham is called to the ready room where Captain Lorca enlists her help for his ship's mysterious mission, at least until the transport can continue its journey. She shares quarters with young Cadet Sylvia Tilly and witnesses strange occurrences during a so-called "black alert" that Tilly is not authorized to talk about. In engineering, Burnham gets tasked by Lieutenant Stamets with some number crunching, still without learning anything about the project. She decides to break into Stamets's top secret lab where she discovers a huge room full of plants and spores. Captain Lorca informs the engineering team that the whole crew of the Discovery's sister ship, the Glenn, including Stamets's colleague Straal, were lost. Burnham is ordered to join the team to explore the Glenn, which is now adrift in space. They discover that not only the crew but also a Klingon boarding party has been killed in a gruesome fashion by some creature. Thanks to Burnham distracting the creature, the survivors of the Discovery boarding party can escape. Captain Lorca wants Burnham to stay aboard. He tells her that the experiment with the spores is not about the development of a weapon but of a new propulsion system. Burnham eventually agrees, and the prisoner transport leaves without her. Lorca, however, still hides something - dead and living creatures in a room like a cabinet of horrors.
The first regular episode of Discovery after the prologue doesn't feel like a pilot although it is effectively one. As we see everything through Michael Burnham's eyes, there is nothing such as "unnatural" exposition. On the downside, the unique perspective of the prisoner on the ship and its crew only adds to the overall cold, even depressive atmosphere of this episode. "Context is for Kings" also leaves more mysteries and open issues than any Star Trek pilot episode so far. Of course, this is mainly due to the fact that this pilot is only 48 minutes long and that Discovery is serialized. But that doesn't mean I have to like it.
In "Context is for Kings", Michael Burnham is given the chance to leave her callous prison, only to end up on the most callous Starfleet ship ever. While we wouldn't expect the captain and crew of any Starfleet ship to welcome the mutineer with open arms and with a wide smile, the way it actually happens is still more unwilling and unfriendly than I had imagined. The writer's intent may have been to show the Discovery with its strange occurrences and secretiveness as mysterious above all. But the sentiment of it being a very cold place is the stronger one in this first episode taking place aboard the ship. Everyone only gives Burnham the impression that her presence is unwanted. This initially even includes Captain Lorca, who wanted her for his crew and arranged her "accidental" arrival on board.
Well, not quite everyone. Cadet Tilly is open-minded about her new roommate. She talks a lot; it seems she needs to talk in order to overcome her uncertainty, and she is glad to eventually have someone to listen. But even Tilly is not ready to accept Burnham at first. She tells Burnham to stay away from the neighboring console in engineering and wait until she is assigned one, although there is nothing like fix console assignments. She just doesn't want to be seen together with the mutineer, in order to make a good impression. Tilly later apologizes for her conduct, which is actually the first kind thing that anyone of the crew says to Michael Burnham. As much as Sylvia Tilly may be a pain as a roommate, she has the potential to become an interesting character - if she is given the chance to be more than what she is now, the only nice person on the ship.
The grumpy Lieutenant Stamets is quite the opposite of Cadet Tilly. It seems that he lives only for his research. He doesn't seem to be interested in people, much less in deviant people like Michael Burnham. He doesn't talk a lot, much less to subordinates whose task is to just perform calculations. A genuine asshole. This changes all of sudden when the team is on the shuttle and Burnham challenges Stamets's professional expertise. Now Stamets shows a different side of his character. In the absence of the captain, he complains about how his work is taken away from him and from his deceased colleague Straal, and is used for military purposes. The unexpected outburst of passion makes Stamets a bit likable again, but the blatant criticism of his captain (a "warmonger" in Stamets's words) sheds an even worse light on the team spirit and discipline on the Discovery.
Captain Lorca overall comes across as more agreeable than I expected. Well, he is only slightly more kind to Michael Burnham than most of his subordinates. But he remains fair. He gives Michael Burnham orders, but it becomes clear very soon that behind these orders there are options for Burnham. Lorca tries to gain Burnham's trust when he demonstrates his research, and perhaps even more so with the flattery that he needs an unconventional person like her. He still remains a mystery in her eyes though - sometimes too ostentatiously mysterious though, which is due to the camera showing him as an intangible figure, rather than being Jason Isaacs's fault. Anyway, in my view she agrees to his offer because it is the best option for her, not because she trusts or even likes the captain. I think Lorca still holds many secrets that Burnham will not like (and that I may not like either). The menagerie of strange creatures shown at the end of the episode that only his very unlikable watchdog Landry knows about doesn't bode well at all...
It is clear that Saru still resents Burnham's mutiny, which in his case is a personal issue. You don't forget when a crewmate suddenly points a phaser at you. And he never seemed to like her very much anyway. So Saru doesn't do anything either to make Burnham feel welcome on the Discovery. He hits the mark with his vitriolic statement, "I intend to do a better job protecting my Captain than you did yours." Still, although he thinks of her as unstable, Saru openly speaks in favor of Burnham when Lorca asks him. I wouldn't be surprised if he was also involved in getting Burnham aboard in the first place. Overall, Saru tries hard to keep apart his long-time professional (and personal) assessment of Burnham and his grudge against her because of the Klingon incident. He may be willing to give her a chance because of the former, although he conveniently hides behind the captain's orders in this regard. At least this is my impression. Saru belongs to a fearful species, and that may additionally obstruct his ability to trust her again. I don't know if Saru sits well with me. The character still seems to be somewhat indefinite.
Michael Burnham herself makes it clear at various points of the episode, practically until the end, that she wants nothing else but climb on that prisoner transport again. She has left her life in Starfleet behind. She thinks she can get atonement only without the privilege of being in something like active service again. Moreover, being around Starfleet people would only sadly remind her of what she has lost, and of the big mistake she made. Even more so as everyone seems to hate her. For her, life in a prison may be the easy way. But I think at this point of her life she doesn't even know what she wants, so Lorca has to push her. Sonequa Martin-Green is convincing as the prisoner whose mood is always between lethargic and defiant. But looking into her grim face becomes tiresome after a while. On another note about Burnham, as much as we may still sympathize with her, rather than with the cranky crew of the Discovery, we have to keep in mind that Burnham gets a chance she realistically wouldn't deserve. Yet, one thing that bothers me about the prisoners' as well as the officers' reactions on Michael Burnham is that they repeatedly (at least half a dozen times in the episode) blame her for the war with the Klingons, although it was the Klingons who fired first. I wonder whether the people, the media or even Starfleet use her as a scapegoat for their own failure to anticipate the large-scale Klingon aggression.
After watching the prologue, I was hoping for more Star Trek spirit in the next episodes. But "Context is for Kings" gives us still less. We have got prisoners who voice racial slurs against Andorians, Starfleet officers that refer to prisoners as "animals" and "waste", and a science officer who calls his captain a "warmonger". With its current atmosphere and wording, Discovery is far away from the optimistic, benevolent and cooperative Star Trek I know. I think I can put up with it for now but it has to change. This Discovery episode is also very graphic in the depiction of the disfigured bodies on the USS Glenn. And the horrible alien monster is a plot device I simply don't care for. Even rather than the monster itself, I find it annoying that no one seems to be bothered by it any longer, once the survivors of the boarding party have escaped from the Glenn, as if monsters are a common sight on Starfleet ships.
A part of the mystery about the USS Discovery and the research of Lt. Stamets is solved in "Context is for Kings". According to Captain Lorca it is all about a new propulsion system that is somehow based on fungal spores. This does not sound as if it could make any sense, neither in real physics nor within the established continuity, as I explain in my annotations. And considering how the producers of Discovery pride themselves to abstain from technobabble, this episode is as tech-heavy as nothing in Star Trek since the days of Voyager's various drives-of-the-week. As soon as in the pilot episode something goes awry that the makers of Discovery so desperately wanted to get right in the new series.
Discovery is conscious of its being different than previous Star Trek iterations in many regards, as the continuity and the style are concerned. It is noticeable how the script of "Context is for Kings" tries to ease some of the problems of the series preemptively by explicitly hinting at them, in an ironical fashion. And so Cadet Tilly says she never heard of a female named Michael, making the eccentric name choice a part of the story (because Tilly, who was not told who would join her room, then remembers Michael was the first name of that mutineer Burnham). In a similar way, Captain Lorca apologizes to Burnham for the lack of light that his injured eyes can't cope with, which may be aimed at criticism that the lighting of the sets is too dark.
Just like the Abramsverse films, Discovery just loves to create pseudo-continuity by the inclusion of all kinds of characters, species and other references that are believed to be fan favorites, no matter how unsuited they are in the context. Tribbles were a largely unknown species in 2266, but they appear frequently before their time, in all three Star Trek prequels/reboots so far. While not a hard continuity error, this kind of pointless "fan service" or "tradition" just doesn't sit well with me.
The visual effects of "Context is for Kings" are good, as already in the prologue. But I have a couple of points of criticism. Space is overall too colorful in Discovery, even though we may always excuse the colors with the vicinity of a nebula or of a star with a non-white spectrum. In the prologue, everything was yellow because of the light of the binary stars. I would have expected the colors to be more subdued this week. But the USS Discovery doesn't look very realistic. This may be due to the colorful lighting but also because of the skin of the CG model. The hull plates appear unnecessarily fractured for the sake of more detail. In my impression the prototype model of the ship, still without the gaps in the saucer, was better. Also, the shuttles of the Discovery with their red "racing stripes" look a bit too toy-like.
Overall, "Context is for Kings" is decent at most. It leaves me considerably less impressed than the prologue. The story overall makes sense. It is very efficient to tell it from Burnham's perspective so it doesn't come across as heavy on exposition. I dig the mystery factor about the secret research, but that aspect could have been worked out still better. There is some action in the form of a "monster hunt" that I don't care for. On the downside, there are the cold characters that I can't relate to (yet), the many animosities that should not exist in this form in Star Trek and the technology concepts that make no sense.
- The USS Discovery NCC-1031 with its extremely angular shapes may not be the greatest ship design but at least it looks fitting for the era, quite unlike the anachronistic Shenzhou. I also like the interior sets for the most part. However, my apprehension is that, as already with the Abrams Enterprise, the VFX people and the art department didn't get the scales right and designed much too spacious sets for the ship. The way it looks to me, the Discovery has to be well over 600 meters long. The missing sense of scale further shatters the credibility of the series but seems of no interest at all to its makers that apparently just don't want their artistic freedom (to create arbitrarily large sets, in this case) to be limited.
- Discovery already has a replicator ("matter synthesizer") that can produce not just food but also other materials such as for uniforms. As usual with such anachronisms, we are expected to assume the device is less advanced than it will be at the time of TNG.
- What will happen to the revolutionary propulsion system, considering that Discovery is still meant to be canon? Can a drive system that is close to being fully functional (the Glenn traveled to the Beta Quadrant) still become such a total failure that it would never even be mentioned again? Star Trek Voyager was met with scathing criticism for introducing all kinds of technology that future series could not work with any longer. What Discovery does is much worse because it additionally disrupts the established continuity, unless the series still gives us a plausible explanation what will become of the "spore drive".
- Burnham, who was sentenced to life, is free to walk around on the ship. While this is probably a part of Lorca's plan, wouldn't it make her suspicious?
- A breath scan (probably based on DNA match) is hardly a sufficient security measure for Stamets's top secret lab. Just when I wondered how soon Burnham would trick the breath scan, she was already at it, collecting saliva from the snoring Cadet Tilly. We later learn that Lorca knew she broke in and quite possibly intended to make it easy for her. Still, it doesn't make sense for a security system to let anyone enter, who is just holding someone else's DNA into the scanner.
- Wouldn't it have been advised for the small team to leave the Glenn immediately upon discovering that not only the crew but a complete Klingon boarding party was killed by the creature?
- Lorca answers a few questions to Burnham in the end, but not the most pressing one, what the heck the creature aboard the Glenn was about. Burnham ran for her life on the Glenn, and it would definitely be the first thing she'd realistically ask him or anyone else. Actually, no one talks about that creature in any way.
- According to Captain Lorca the new propulsion system is somehow based on fungal spores. However, biological propulsion systems in Star Trek have never been plausible. And it doesn't make more sense that, in the universe, spores form an "intergalactic ecosystem" that would allow to go from anywhere to anywhere else. This is total nonsense, considering that any heavy elements and any form of life could not exist until a few billion years after the Big Bang, when galaxies already existed and were millions of light-years apart.
- Remarkable dialogue: "I was raised on Vulcan and I attended the Vulcan science academy." - "My uncle Everett plays in a Beatles cover band. That hardly makes him John Lennon." - "I'm not sure I'm following." (Burnham and Stamets)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Vulcans should stick to logic." (Landry, after the demonstration of Burnham's Vulcan martial arts)
- "We are not creating a new way to kill. We are creating a new way to fly." (Captain Lorca)
- "Universal law is for lackeys. Context is for kings." (Captain Lorca)
- Remarkable scenes:
- Michael Burnham crawls through the Jefferies tubes of the Glenn, citing from Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. She later gives the book to Tilly.
- Captain Lorca's family used to bake fortune cookies. He offers Burnham a cookie, as a symbol for her future that still offers multiple possibilities.
- Remarkable fun scene: the shushing Klingon
- Remarkable facts:
- 8186 Starfleet personnel died since the Battle at the Binary Stars.
- In the Tellun colony, 50 cons working as miners were killed when they hit a dilithium pocket.
- Species GS54 is a spacebourne species that drains the power systems of passing ships.
- Just like Saru, Burnham's former crewmate Kayla is also aboard the Discovery. She now has an implant on the side of her head.
- The Discovery is a science vessel that can host as many as 300 scientific missions, a record in Starfleet.
- "Black alert" on the Discovery means that the spore drive is being tested, which comes with side effects such as the formation of drops of a liquid.
- Biological weapons are banned according to the Geneva Protocols of 1928 and 2155.
- Captain Lorca demonstrates to Burnham the effect of mycelium spores of the fungus prototaxites stellaviatori.
- The places that Michael Burnham sees under the effect of the spores, or that Lorca mentions, are: Ilari (which I hope isn't meant to be the Delta Quadrant planet), the moons of Andoria (with a Preservers' obelisk?), Romulus, the Starbase 11 planet, the Janus VI mining colony (heavily reworked but recognizable).
November 2256: Michael Burnham joins the crew of the Discovery, with no rank. Captain Lorca lets her in on the secret of the creature captured aboard the sister ship USS Glenn, apparently a macroscopic form of a tardigrade. He plans to investigate what makes the tardigrade that Landry names "Ripper" powerful, and how to turn this into a weapon against the Klingons. Landry, however, is killed when she attempts to sedate the creature. The Discovery receives a distress call from Corvan II, a dilithium mining facility that is attacked by the Klingons. The Discovery is the only ship that could reach the colony in time, using the spore drive. Against Stamets's objections, Lorca decides to use the drive, but the ship does not end up near Corvan II. Burnham observes that "Ripper" is attracted to the spores, which may have been the reason why the creature was on the Glenn with its mushroom storage in the first place. As she thinks the tardigrade only attacks when in danger, she approaches the creature with a container of spores. Stamets is impressed and works with Burnham on a way to use the tardigrade as the ship's "navigator". The Discovery arrives at Corvan II and destroys the attacking Klingon Birds-of-Prey. Despite the success, Burnham feels remorse about the mistreatment of the imprisoned creature. In the meantime, in the debris field at the binary stars, the Klingon survivors Voq and L'Rell plan to relaunch the damaged ship of T'Kuvma, with the help of the dilithium processing unit of the abandoned Shenzhou. Kol appears to help but actually bribes Voq's starving crew with food to pledge allegiance with him. L'Rell hands over the dilithium processor to Kol, who then exiles Voq to the Shenzhou and warps away. L'Rell, however, secretly beams over to Voq, apparently with a plan to regain control of the empire.
The fourth episode of Discovery is the first one that doesn't have to establish a new setting and to introduce several new characters. The story is told in a more traditional fashion, from different perspectives than only Burnham's, which helps to warm up a bit with the other characters, at least with those on the Discovery.
Lorca loses his aura of being mysterious to some extent, as he is willing to share his secret about the weapon developments with Burnham and as we understand his plans better. Lorca has a passion for the war, as indicated by his "weapon museum". We don't know yet whether his main motivation is to be the best soldier with the best weapons, or to be just good enough in his field and only long enough to bring the war to an end. When he plays the recordings of the Klingon attack on Corvan II over the ship's comm system, he clearly tries to evoke an emotional reaction in his crew to work harder to help these people. But I'm not sure if the cries for help would motivate himself just as much.
Stamets is still cold as ice for much of the time. But I like his astonishment and his curiosity when Burnham presents her theory about how the tardigrade may be the key to mastering spore propulsion. Landry, on the other hand, remains as one-dimensional as she was in the pilot. She gets killed simply because she is reckless and imprudent. Overall, she was a very inefficient character, other than in the function of showing how different the crew of the Discovery is compared to traditional Starfleet ships. Tilly is a bit like Burnham's sidekick in this story, while Saru remains her nemesis. I don't understand Saru when he says to her, "I was wrong. You will fit in just fine here.", referring to Burnham's lack of loyalty and morality that he obviously attributes to his own captain and crew as well but that does not seem to be a problem for him. Medical officer Hugh Culber (Wilson Cruz) appears for the first time, albeit only briefly.
Michael Burnham has rediscovered her spirit that made her pursue a career in science and that made her want to explore the unknown. When Lorca presents the unknown creature in his menagerie, Burnham is rather fascinated than appalled. Overall, she remains comparably impassionate for much of the episode, but that may be attributed to her Vulcan education as well as to her being on probation. In any case I'm glad that she eventually comes across as someone with a conscience (regarding the captured creature) and with remorse (regarding the testament of the mentor whom she failed). Michael Burnham represents the type of Starfleet characters that were prevalent in the five old series. The principal characters of TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT were all driven by the motivation to make the galaxy a better place. They occasionally made mistakes, but these mistakes were usually neither glossed over nor excused with something like "extreme measures in extreme situations". Whenever someone in traditional Star Trek used such a reasoning, it was the explicit exception to the rule, and it soon became obvious that the person was a jerk. Just like Admiral Dougherty in "Star Trek Insurrection".
On the Discovery, however, Burnham is so far the only Starfleet character that acts and reflects on actions the way we should expect from Starfleet. We could argue that we simply haven't seen how benevolent, how thoughtful Lorca or Stamets are in peacetime. But does the war with its missing story opportunity to show a peaceful spirit and a positive vision of the future exonerate Discovery? Is it sufficient for the producers to evoke the legacy of Star Trek in interviews, without actually continuing it in the series? Is it so important for Discovery to be "modern" and to comment on the sad state of our present world that it doesn't show a bright future any longer? We have not seen very much of the series at this point, so I just ask these questions and I will reserve my judgment whether Discovery has the spirit of Star Trek until the end of the season. And yes, I am aware that DS9 had a much longer war and more dark stories in terms of episode runtime. But DS9 was firmly embedded into the overall optimistic world of the 24th century, whereas Discovery currently rewrites the 23rd century to a dark era.
The Klingons are just as little interesting as they were in the prologue, cumbersome in the way they move, talk and maybe even think. Voq is a prisoner of his own fanaticism and lacks practically everything that a leader needs. It remains a mystery why L'Rell remains loyal to him, although that may be the interesting part of the story. Kol is smarter and a bit more like the Klingons we know but still not a formidable enemy by a long shot.
"The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry" comes with just as much technobabble as last week's episode. The spore drive is a bit less enigmatic now, so some of the concepts seem to make more sense simply because they have been mentioned before. The episode is also rather heavy on funny or sarcastic quotes. As much as I appreciate occasional comic relief, I think there is too much of it in the episode.
I was glad that I would never have to see the anachronistic Shenzhou again. But due the inexplicable failure of the self destruct the ship still exists. On the other hand, I don't know if I really like the Discovery much better. Detractors of Starfleet ships love to refer to the design as "pizza cutters". Someone in the art department must hate Starfleet designs so much that he turned the saucer in something that doesn't only look but even works like a pizza cutter (cutting through an interstellar pizza funghi I suppose).
In a series that so far only cited from Star Trek without internalizing its principles, "The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry" is a spark of hope. The story brings to mind TOS: "The Devil in the Dark" as far as Burnham's interaction with "Ripper" is concerned. On the downside, the use of captured alien creatures for the purpose of propulsion is rather reminiscent of VOY: "Equinox". I like the action sequences of the Discovery saving the colony. It is a pity that the story about this rescue mission and the tardigrade was sidetracked in many ways, because I would have liked to see more of it. I still don't care at all for the Klingons.
- Continuity: The Discovery Klingons, or at least the religious fanatics around Voq, speak to the dead, they invoke blasphemy and cherish humility. And most disgustingly, they eat their enemies. This seems to be a quite normal ritual but is further evidence that these aliens are not at all like any Klingons we know. Much less would it help to make them likable in any fashion.
- Corvan II produces 40% of the Federation's dilithium, but no starships are available to protect this mining colony of major strategic importance?
- What happened to self destruct to avoid ships from falling into the hands of the enemy?
- Most Starfleet ships have round saucer hulls at latest since the launch of the NX class in 2151, a design feature that is largely unrelated to the ship's engines. The spore drive, on the other hand, seems to require usually inhabited parts of the saucer to spin to absorb excess energy, for which the traditional saucer hull is conveniently and quite coincidentally the perfect basic design.
- Why is it that the whole ship spins in longitudinal direction for a spore drive jump, perpendicular and hence unrelated to the saucer spin, except for a spectacular effect?
- After the destruction of the Glenn, the Discovery is the only ship of the Crossfield class left. What happened to the USS Crossfield? Considering that the Discovery and the Glenn were built with the specific purpose of being testbeds for the spore drive, we wouldn't expect the Crossfield, if the ship still exists, to be any different. Unless, of course, in the Discovery universe, the class name does not refer to the lead ship. Considering that John Eaves names all ship classes after US test pilots independently of the stories, that seems to be an option.
- Lorca destroys the remaining Klingon ships, and just the Klingon ships, with mines or torpedoes. This happens so close to the unshielded colony that debris rains on the planet. So why does the colony remain unscathed? On a side note, it would have been more elegant and much cooler to destroy the Klingon ships using the spore drive. At least, that's what I expected to see.
- Why would the Discovery leave Corvan II immediately anyway? Just for a demonstration of power that no Klingon may survive to report of it? Wouldn't it have been a better idea and even the duty of the Discovery to stay and tend to the wounded on the planet?
- The telescope is obviously meant to be the very same that Georgiou kept aboard the Shenzhou, judging from the battle damage. There may have been enough time for someone to grab it during to the evacuation of the ship. Still, it seems unlikely that Georgiou ordered someone to save the telescope in case she is dead and the ship is going down.
- Remarkable dialogues:
- "A valuable asset. That's what you called me." - "I was speaking hypothetically. Politely. And as someone who was certain I would never see you again." (Burnham and Saru)
- "The phaser will only piss him off." - "Think of it as a placebo for my skepticism." (Burnham and Stamets)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Yes, less. Less extraneous words." (Tilly)
- "The frontal lobe is overrated. It only contains memory and emotional expression. It's completely unnecessary." (Stamets)
- "That hardly seems fair. I always wanted to converse with my mushrooms." (Stamets)
- "My mother never really said anything to me, unless she was criticizing my hair." (Tilly)
- "Take good care but, more importantly, take good care of those in your care." (Captain Georgiou)
- Remarkable scene: After her initial hesitation, Michael Burnham activates the box with Captain Georgiou's last will and testament. She finds the recording from Georgiou and a telescope.
- Remarkable facts:
- Saru's threat ganglia behind his ears do not extend in the presence of "Ripper", which Burnham interprets as "Ripper" not being a predator.
- The displacement-activated spore hub drive is probabilistic. The longer the jump, the more possible outcomes. Sounds like infinite improbability drive.
December 2256: Captain Lorca is called to a starbase where Admiral Cornwell orders him to limit the use of the spore drive of the Discovery, in order not to risk losing the only prototype. On the way back to his ship, Lorca's shuttle is boarded by the Klingons, and his pilot is killed. Lorca is taken to a prison cell with the criminal Harry Mudd and Starfleet Lieutenant Ash Tyler. On the Discovery, Michael Burnham is concerned that the condition of the tardigrade deteriorates with each jump. Acting Captain Saru, however, orders her to carry on regardless, in order to find the missing captain. Burnham convinces Stamets to work out an alternative solution, incorporating DNA of the tardigrade to another living organism, such as a human. When Saru notices that the spore drive is down, he confines Burnham to her quarters and tells Stamets to activate the drive again. After jumping to the position of the Klingon prisoner transport, deep in Klingon space, the tardigrade's condition is so bad that the creature goes into stasis. Meanwhile, on the Klingon vessel, Lorca finds out that Mudd has been spying on the Starfleet officers for the Klingons. When the guards appear again, to take one prisoner to be tortured, Lorca and Tyler attack them. They manage to escape from the Klingon vessel in a raider. Saru recognizes that one of the raiders approaching the Discovery is being pursued by the other Klingon ships, and he arranges for Lorca and Tyler to be beamed out. He then orders the jump back into Federation territory. Since the tardigrade is disabled, Stamets gave himself an injection of its DNA and performed the jump in its place. Saru orders Burnham to help the supposedly sentient tardigrade, whereupon Burnham decides to release the creature into freedom.
We may almost call this a "reconciliation story". At least, "Choose Your Pain" is the first Star Trek Discovery episode that resolves or eases more conflicts than it creates. Also, it evokes the qualities of the old Star Trek on more occasions than previously in the series, in particular forgiveness, compassion and confidence. It is the first time in the series that the spirit of collaboration prevails on the Discovery in the end. On the downside, the story is once again a dark one, both in its action and in the references.
Michael Burnham is not so much in the focus as she used to be in the first four episodes. But she wins several small victories, just by sticking to her judgment and to her ethical principles. She can convince Stamets that the ship needs a backup or a replacement for "Ripper", which appeals to his scientific curiosity and ambition. Dr. Hugh Culber, who initially saw "Ripper" as an inferior creature that can't experience pain, accepts her objections and comes to the conclusion that the tardigrade may be sentient. And even Saru, who only seemed to be afraid that Burnham could fail him again (his threat ganglia extend at one point when she enters the bridge), confesses that he is angry and jealous of her having been Captain Georgiou's first officer. Burnham decides to give him the telescope that she inherited. I only wonder how Saru will react on Burnham's release of the tardigrade...
Stamets is the perhaps most interesting character of this episode because we can see how excited and passionate he is about his work, and how much he cares for at least some of the people around him. We already know from the last episode that he would listen to Michael Burnham, just because he has filed her under "very intelligent and resourceful". And so he agrees to working out an alternative solution for the ship's navigator when she tells him that "Ripper" will deteriorate. He concurs with Tilly that the idea to incorporate tardigrade DNA into another lifeform is "fucking cool". Yet, Stamets remains silent when Saru comes to engineering and confines Michael Burnham to her quarters for deactivating the spore drive. Stamets should speak out in this situation for two important reasons. Firstly, he is in charge of engineering, and if the drive is taken down, he is the one to be held responsible for it. Secondly, even though it may be convenient that Saru only blames Burnham, they both agreed it would be useful to do it. I would have expected more of a spine from Stamets. But he makes up for his mistake when he further works on what Burnham suggested and eventually saves the ship, almost in self-sacrifice. Stamets may still not be a likable character and not the best team worker or superior officer, but he is invaluable. And there is at least one crew member who more than only likes Stamets. It is great how casually the episode introduces the relationship of Stamets and Culber.
Saru is rather disappointing as the acting captain in this episode. This is exemplified best when he consults the computer what a good captain would need. He thinks he has to be a captain by the book. He tries to align himself with the best captains of the fleet. He would have wanted to be Philippa Georgiou's first officer more than anything else, to learn what it takes to be a captain. But how could this help in the current crisis? Why doesn't Saru rather listen to the capable people around him, to Stamets, to Culber, maybe even to Burnham?
We learn that Captain Lorca has a big stain on his record because he did not go down with his ship, and even seems to have killed his crew in order not to let them fall into Klingon hands. This may be shocking news, but it remains only a side note in a story that shows Lorca as a steadfast Starfleet officer, who does everything to save himself and his people, even under the most adverse conditions. It is wonderful how he and Ash Tyler (Shazad Latif) work together to escape from their Klingon prison. Well, it all seems too easy. Although it will be explained later, it lets the Klingons appear as weak enemies. And the decision to leave Mudd behind remains controversial, considering that it may have more to do with him being an unlikable fellow than with him being a Klingon spy.
I am relieved that the new Harry Mudd (Rainn Wilson) is more like the TOS character than I would have expected. His mannerisms occasionally remind me of Roger C. Carmel's character. And I am glad that the new Mudd turns out to be the swindler and con man that we know, and not some mad movie villain. While it may be true that he would betray anyone for his own profit or welfare, he has a clear attitude when he refers to the "little guys below", who have to bear the consequences of Starfleet's actions. Whether this is true or not, Mudd challenges Starfleet in a similar way as it happened especially on DS9.
We see a ship that is identified as a Klingon "D7-class battlecruiser" but that has absolutely nothing in common with the iconic ship design by Matt Jefferies. This is not only a total disregard of the existing continuity but also blatant disrespect of the man who shaped much of the look of the old Star Trek. The "dragonfly" raiders are just as unconvincing and un-Klingon. Other than the ships, the Klingon design of this episode in terms of uniforms and interiors is a little bit more reminiscent of what we know and what we should expect. But although L'Rell temporarily gains the upper hand and still pursues a plan, the Klingons appear as one-dimensional and dumb. I only like the concept of the catchphrase "Choose your pain." that the producers were obviously fond of too and that they made into the episode title.
Something that bothers me in all Discovery episodes so far is that space in general, and particularly ships in space, are always colorfully illuminated is some fashion. This may be realistic in the vicinity of a star with an according spectrum (we already saw "red" and "yellow" ships with that rationale). But in Discovery there is always a colorful nebula or something like that, or the ships illuminate themselves in color (which in the case of the tractor beam of the "D7" makes sense but fits the cliché). Self-lighting is a concept that Andrew Probert devised for TMP, but it should remain "neutral" so the ships feel real, and not like some sort of color change lamps in space.
The story of "Choose Your Pain" is well-written and well-paced. There is an excellent balance between the parts on the Discovery and on the Klingon prison ship. Also, I can see some of the old Star Trek spirit and atmosphere in this Discovery episode. At this point, the series seems to gear towards a crew that works together instead of fighting out all kinds of conflicts. On the other hand, with the explicit violence (cracking Klingon necks), the mention of sexual mistreatment of prisoners and Lorca's disreputable past the series further proceeds into a dark territory that I am afraid of. Harry Mudd is a positive surprise, whereas the Klingons remain stupid and their ship designs horrible.
- Continuity: The ship identified as "D7 battlecruiser" has nothing in common with the famous Klingon ship design and its known variations. Ash Tyler estimates a crew complement of 30 to 40 but he may be mistaken, considering that he thinks it's a "prisoner transport". According to TOS: "Day of the Dove", the crew complement of a D7 matches that of a Constitution class. At one point, the battlecruiser is even called a "Bird-of-Prey", as if everything were the same. So far for the claim that Discovery writers look up even nonessential facts at Memory Alpha...
- Lorca is mistrustful about Ash Tyler at first, saying that no one survives seven months in a Klingon prison. Tyler then mentions that the captain of the ship (obviously L'Rell) has a special interest in him. But L'Rell has been on the wreck of T'Kuvma's ship all along, and arranged for her rescue no more than three weeks ago, at the end of "The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry". Even though the truth about Ash's captivity may be revealed later, it still leaves the time of only three weeks as a problem. It also raises the question why L'Rell had to stay and starve in the wreckage of the binary stars ship when loyal Klingon ships were available to rescue or resupply her on short notice.
- The Klingons need Harry Mudd and a listening device affixed to his bug named Stuart to know what their prisoners are talking of. Discovery continues the strange tradition that prison cells in Star Trek never have built-in audio or video surveillance.
- Remarkable dialogue: "Ouch!" - "Who are you?" - "The name is Mudd. Harcourt Fenton Mudd, Harry for short. I reiterate: ouch." (Harry Mudd and Gabriel Lorca)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "They may look stupid, our Klingon hosts. They're anything but. They regularly give us th choice to choose our pain. We can accept the beating ourselves, or pass it on to our cellmates. It's our captors' way of keeping us from bonding." (Harry Mudd)
- "Dr. Culber believes the tardigrade is sentient. It remains in a state of cryptobiosis. We have no claim on its soul. Go save its life, Burnham. That's an order." (Saru)
- Remarkable scene: Saru calls engineering to thank Stamets for the successful jump but then learns that he is in a bad condition. He rushes down, only to find him unconscious in the glass compartment. This is all very reminiscent of "Star Trek II", and fortunately not so blatantly a rip-off as in "Star Trek Into Darkness". Instead of a touching death scene, Stamets only laughs.
- Remarkable facts:
- Captain Lorca is the only one who escaped from the USS Buran when the Klingons boarded the ship. He decided to blow the Buran, in order to save his crew the pain of being prisoners of the Klingons.
- After saving the mining colony on Corvan II, the Discovery broke through the Klingon lines near Benzar and routed an attack of the Ophiucus system.
- The list of the most decorated captains, alive or deceased: Robert April, Jonathan Archer, Matthew Decker, Philippa Georgiou, Christoper Pike
- Saru says he has 134 souls to take care of. This implies that the crew complement of the Discovery is only 137 (counting in Lorca and Ash Tyler).
- Remarkable ending: Paul Stamets leaves the bathroom, but his mirror image stays a bit longer...
One week later: Sarek and his aide V'latak depart from Vulcan for a secret meeting with two independent Klingon houses on the neutral planet Cancri IV, in order to forge an alliance with them and end the war. But V'latak is a Vulcan extremist, opposed to Sarek's policy of dealing with other species. He uses himself as a bomb, leaving the shuttle with the heavily injured ambassador adrift in a nebula near Yridia. Michael Burnham, who shares part of Sarek's katra, senses that he is in danger. Upon her request, Lorca sets a course for the nebula. Burnham and Stamets devise a neural enhancer that may allow Burnham to intensify her connection to Sarek and find the ambassador. Designated Chief of Security Ash Tyler, Cadet Tilly and Michael Burnham take a shuttle into the nebula. But Sarek's mind actively fights the link. Ash Tyler insinuates that the ambassador is trying to hide something shameful from her. Burnham finds out that Sarek once had to make a choice whether to send her to the Vulcan Expeditionary Group, or rather his son Spock. He chose Spock and never told her this was the actual reason for her rejection. Sarek activates the emergency transmitter that allows to beam him out. In the meantime, Admiral Cornwell has arrived on the Discovery. The admiral has doubts about Lorca's ability to command. When the two are in bed and Lorca suddenly points a phaser at her, she decides that he has to take a break. Cornwell sets course for Cancri IV to attend the meeting in place of the injured Sarek. But after her arrival the Klingons kill her two officers and capture her. Kol promised the two other houses the secret of cloaking in exchange for their loyalty. Lorca learns of Cornwell's capture but decides to wait for Starfleet's orders.
At first, "Lethe" seems to be an episode about Burnham trying to find the badly injured Sarek. But in the following, everything about them boils down to one specific event in their past and to something that Sarek conceals from her while the two are linked. I think the story overextends the idea of Burnham's visit to Sarek's katra. The scenes on Vulcan are so long and so numerous that they disrupt the flow of the rest of the story, of what's going on in the present, of what arguably matters more. Also, the katra is some kind of soul, of mental essence. It is not the same as a conscious mind, and perhaps not even an unconscious mind. In this regard, the depicted degree of interaction in the mind meld is too high, everything is too definite, as already in "Battle at the Binary Stars". And the whole concept ultimately appears as absurd when Sarek and Burnham begin to fight against each other inside the katra. Bust most importantly, it is anticlimactic for the story that the outcome of the whole mumbo-jumbo is nothing more than that Sarek tried to conceal the truth about Burnham's declined admission to the Expeditionary Group.
Stamets appears in just one scene but in a quite memorable one. After his exposure to the "spore highway", Stamets is more than only lightened up. We could already notice the change last week, when he agreed with Tilly that they were working on something "fucking cool", and that was even before he hooked himself up to the ship's spore drive. Stamets now speaks in youth slang (of the late 20th century!?) all the time, he uses "colorful metaphors" and echoism. It's like he is on drugs (magic mushrooms?). I don't know how long his trip will go on, and if it's a great idea for him to serve as comic relief. But on a serious note about Stamets's behavior change, it somehow appears like a relapse to the teenage nerd days he definitely had. I can imagine he really was like this in his younger days, until a big disappointment led him on the path to callousness.
It doesn't come as a big surprise that Cornwell is more than only a superior officer to Lorca. Cornwell speaks out what has been obvious since the first time Lorca appeared. He is pathologically relentless towards others and most of all towards himself. He may have passed the psychological tests after the loss of the Buran. Perhaps he knew how to trick the people examining him, but he is not fit for command. Lorca probably knows that. He always pushed the boundaries, he could rely on Cornwell backing him to some extent. But he knew he couldn't carry on like this forever. When Lorca pulls the phaser and Cornwell announces to relieve him of duty, Lorca is unprepared though - helpless like a little boy who begs his mother not to take away his favorite toy from him. This moment of truth may have been a chance in the story to let Lorca recognize that he suffers from PTSD and needs help. But his lamentation only reinforces the impression of him being obsessed with being a captain and a warrior. What's worse, Lorca does nothing to save the admiral who wants him off the captain's chair. It almost looks like he speculates that she may not survive without his help. And even if he just has learned a lesson not to overstep his authority and to consult Starfleet before mounting a rescue mission single-handedly, his timing leaves a bad taste (and leaves Saru accordingly baffled).
Discovery is a series of red herrings and other forms of deception and obfuscation that are kept up for longer than only one episode. Regarding the true identity of Ash Tyler, we may be mistaken if we think he really is the capable and empathic Starfleet officer that he appears to be in this episode. But then again, maybe the doubts about him (Ash is not from Seattle as he says, but 24 kilometers away, as Lorca notes) are the red herring, and he is just the man he pretends to be. The writing of Discovery is very skilled in this regard, but it may overextend its own credibility if it plays around with the characters like "He may be a spy or not. Who knows. We may not even know ourselves." There has to be a bigger picture of the series and its characters and some degree of reliability about what is true and what isn't. So far Burnham is still the only one in whom we can trust in this regard.
Speaking of deception and obfuscation, I always took it for granted that the Klingon raid on the research outpost Doctari Alpha, in which Michael Burnham's parents were killed (mentioned in "The Vulcan Hello"), and the attack on the Vulcan Learning Center, in which Sarek had to save her life through the katra transfer (shown in "Battle at the Binary Stars"), were the same event. It just didn't make sense that Michael Burnham would be the victim of attacks twice in her early childhood. I think there is no evidence that Doctari Alpha is not identical to the Vulcan Learning Center, other than that the latter is more likely located on Vulcan. It is a deception that the attacks are indeed meant to be two separate events at two different places. Either that, or bad writing that overburdens a character with two childhood traumas and even introduces them in the same double episode so they just beg to be mixed up. When I watched "Lethe", I was annoyed that suddenly Vulcan extremists are responsible for an attack previously ascribed to the Klingons. Only after the episode I was notified that I got it all wrong and that I should have looked it up at startrek.com or Memory Alpha, rather than just watching the series.
I was hoping that Star Trek, after the last season of DS9, after Enterprise and after the first Abrams film, finally had its share of "evil Vulcans". But Discovery is another disappointment in this regard, although for once the series can claim to respect the established continuity. It introduces a xenophobic movement that is responsible for the bombing of the Vulcan Learning Center, as well as for the attempted assassination of Ambassador Sarek. In "Star Trek (2009)", which undeniably inspired this episode, the Vulcan xenophobia was limited to fellow pupils taunting young Spock for being half-human, and the High Council being skeptical about him. In Discovery, this becomes a fully-fledged terrorist movement that attacks aliens, just as well as Vulcan proponents of interplanetary collaboration. I had hoped for Discovery to be the notable exception in recent Star Trek series, and to depict a Vulcan society that is appropriately alien but as peaceful as it was in a time before writers had the idea how cool frequent appearances of abnormal Vulcans could be.
The visualization of space in Discovery continues to be disappointing. The flight through the nebula with its red, green and blue neon lights looks like from a video game of the early 90s. (Another reviewer aptly named them "Disco lights".) After a continuous improvement of the visual effects in the first 40 years of Star Trek it is a throwback (rather than a homage to TOS) that space consists of colorful lights in Discovery. The very irregular, flashy warp streak effect is another nuisance. It must make warp travelers dizzy or even drive them insane, looking through the windows at warp, especially on a shuttle.
"Lethe" has its merits, especially in the apt characterizations of Cornwell, Lorca and Burnham. Still, it is my least favorite Discovery episode so far because of several annoyances, most of which have little to do with the lack of continuity that I generally criticize. It doesn't feel realistic and becomes boring how Michael and Sarek interact in his katra. Stamets on drugs becomes a nuisance after a while. And I hate that Discovery writers couldn't abstain from the "evil Vulcan" theme, and even further expanded the idea. The rest of the story isn't interesting enough to make up for these weaknesses, especially since the bigger picture (Lorca is about to lose his command, Cornwell is captured, the Klingons may be stronger than ever) appears only in a side plot.
- The Discovery has a holographic simulator with apparently the complete functionality of the Enterprise-D holodeck that will be deemed a major breakthrough over a century later, in the year 2364. It may not yet be possible to touch objects in the Discovery version but from the look of it there isn't anything less advanced about it.
- Sarek's ship with its U-shaped engines looks at least roughly like the Vulcans ships that we could see on Enterprise and the T'Pau from TNG: "Unification".
- There are several "black" and "Asian" Vulcans, insinuating a diversity among this species, the way we could see it at latest since Tuvok. Vulcan blood is still green.
- The color of the sky on Vulcan is undecided, with red and blue portions.
- Burnham mentions "Constitution-class ships like the Enterprise". There is nothing wrong with it, but a twofold irony in the reference to the "Constitution class". In TOS, this designation was never used, and the ship's dedication plaque read "Starship Class". In the Discovery universe, on the other hand, there may not be a tradition to name classes for the first launched ship but rather for US test pilots. At this point of the series, I was still convinced that the producers would have enough respect not to "reimagine" the original Enterprise, but the season final will prove me wrong.
- Admiral Cornwell's shuttle is called a "cruiser" by Saru for no obvious reason: "Her cruiser just dropped out of warp, and she is requesting permission to land". There is one precedent in TOS: "The Way to Eden" where a small civilian ship was referred to as a "cruiser". But other than that, a cruiser in Star Trek is always a capital ship, especially in Starfleet service. In order for the "cruiser" to make more sense, we could speculate that she came in a big ship indeed, climbed on the shuttle and then called the Discovery. But that would mean that Saru hesitated to tell Lorca that Cornwell's ship arrived and that it is a well-known fact that she wouldn't use the transporter. Addendum: "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" will reveal that she left for Cancri with a Discovery shuttle. It seems possible that she also came with a Discovery shuttle, but that still leaves the question why she should bother taking a shuttle for the final few meters at all.
- Vulcan's central star is 40 Eridani A, part of the trinary system 40 Eridani A through C. Amanda tells Burnham of the journey to a moon of "Eridani D". So the "D" likely refers to a planet, rather than to a possible fourth star of 40 Eridani that is still unknown in the 21st century. Yet, this nomenclature makes no sense for two reasons. The first is that Star Trek always uses numerals for planets, such as Cancri IV. The second is that it would lead to confusion with the star systems A through C of the 40 Eridani trinary system. There is still the option that "Eridani D" is a planet or even a star in another star system of the constellation Eridanus, such as Alpha Eridani. But then Amanda would not have to referred to it as simply "Eridani". (In real life, extrasolar planets are named using small letters, starting with "b" for the first one discovered in a star system.)
- The planet name Cancri IV makes no sense either, for a similar reason. Cancer is a real constellation. "Cancri" is the correct genitive case but lacks the identification of a particular star of the constellation (such as in Beta Cancri).
- Dr. Culber thought the Vulcan katra was more like a myth. Stamets, however, seems to have a precise idea about how to build a device specifically to enhance such a "mythical" neural connection.
- Remarkable dialogue: "Computer. Green juice, extra green." - "Computer. Cancel that order. That's hardly the correct ratio of protein, carbohydrates and fat. Computer. Three-egg-white breakfast burrito with black beans." - "Computer..." - "Make it two." - "[whispering] Computer. Add salsa." - "Computer. Add roasted tomato salsa. Cooked tomatoes are a great source of lycopene. Remember that." - "Two appetizing and nutrient filled burritos." (Tilly, Burnham and the computer)
- Remarkable T-shirt: Burnham and Tilly wear "DISCO" T-shirts for their running training. It looks like the merchandising asked for some cheap to produce yet authentic Discovery item to appear on screen.
- Remarkable facts:
- The bombing at the Vulcan Learning Center was executed by Vulcan extremists, who were opposed to aliens on their homeworld. Michael Burnham died in the attack, and was revived by the katra transfer.
- On Burnham's tenth birthday, the family took a shuttle and went to the seventh moon of Eridani D. This is where Burnham received her copy of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland.
- The Vulcan Expeditionary Group would not accept two non-Vulcans, so Sarek was forced to choose between Michael and Spock (who, at this time, had not yet begun his training). Ironically, Spock later decided to join Starfleet, rather than the Expeditionary Group.
- Ash Tyler's mother was a teacher at Issaquah Elementary, 24 kilometers outside Seattle.
- Remarkable episode title: Lethe is the Greek spirit of forgetfulness and the river in the Hades, the underworld, that induces forgetfulness. The title seems to refer to Sarek's memory about not admitting Michael to the Expeditionary Group, although we may argue he just remained silent about it instead of suppressing this memory.
Stardate 2136.8: Burnham is at a party and feels uncomfortable there. On Tilly's suggestion, she is just trying to have a conversation with Tyler, when the two are called to the bridge. Sensors have discovered a gormagander, an endangered space-dwelling species, and regulations require to beam it aboard for the transfer to a sanctuary. When the creature is in the shuttlebay, a man emerges - Harry Mudd. He shoots several crew members but is eventually confined. However, that doesn't seem to bother him. An explosive device destroys the Discovery. Time is reset. Burnham is at the party again, but when she and Tyler leave for the bridge, Stamets already knows that something will happen because of the gormagander. Owing to the tardigrade DNA injected into his body, he exists out of normal space-time. In this loop, Mudd beams out of the creature. He confines himself in engineering to find out the secret about the ship's drive but is shot by Stamets just before time is reset again. This time, Stamets rushes to the party to warn Burnham and Tyler in time, but they are already gone. He finds Burnham and asks her to tell him a secret to make it easier for him in the next loop. Mudd manages to take Captain Lorca hostage. He says he has already killed Lorca 53 times and does it again. Time is reset yet again. Stamets tells Burnham of the secret she revealed to him, that she has never been in love. Instead of trying to stop Mudd, he asks her to dance with him. In the following loop, Burnham is at the party again, and Stamets arranges for her to dance with Tyler. Burnham and Tyler talk about Mudd and find out what kind technology he is using. They rush to the bridge, where Mudd has already taken over the ship and only waits for someone to reveal the secret about its drive. He kills Tyler with a capsule of weaponized dark matter. Stamets finally tells Mudd that he himself is the secret component of the spore drive. Mudd now has everything he wanted. He contacts the Klingons to hand over the ship. But Burnham has an even more tempting offer for him - herself. She tells him the Klingons would pay an even higher reward for her than for the ship because she shot T'Kuvma, upon which she kills herself with a dark matter bullet. Mudd resets time and is surprised that the crew hands over the ship to him without resistance. He contacts the Klingons and proceeds to the transporter room to welcome them. But he was tricked. Tyler managed to lock him out from the ship's systems, and Mudd actually called his father-in-law, the father of his "beloved" Stella, that he was hiding from.
It is clear that this episode was made in the spirit of TNG: "Cause and Effect". The theme is much the same. The principal difference between the plots is that in the TNG episode each loop repeated with the exact same pattern, whereas in DIS Mudd works against the crew and their efforts to prevent the disaster. He is always one step ahead of them, even though Stamets does his best to keep up. Using a time loop for a perfect crime is an interesting new twist, at least in Star Trek, and the story works well for me. I enjoy seeing the many opposing efforts of Mudd and the crew, in their many iterations and variations. In this regard, "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad" is the so far most successful episode to bring back memories of the good old Star Trek.
Something of note, however, is that the way the characters deal with the temporal loop dilemma is very different than it would have been shown in a TNG episode, for instance. The crew members of the Discovery obviously have not yet developed the same level of mutual trust. On the Enterprise-D, the whole crew would work together and did work together in "Cause and Effect", as soon as someone suspected something was wrong. On the Discovery, Lorca simply brushes aside Burnham's and Tyler's objections to beaming aboard the creature. They may have tried again in later loops, and Stamets too may have attempted to prevent Lorca from enabling Mudd to board the ship, but they were obviously unsuccessful. So it takes quite a while on the Discovery until the single crew members' actions finally lead to a coordinated effort to defeat Mudd. Well, TNG: "Cause and Effect" may not be a fair yardstick, considering that the whole crew had premonitions, rather than just one person. Still, on the Enterprise-D the crew very often worked together with one mind, for example when Picard signaled to Riker to confine the aliens in TNG: "Allegiance", without saying a word. The Discovery crew is still a far cry from such a spirit of collaboration. That's not meant as criticism of the series but as an appraisal of the state of the crew.
In the mindset of Lt. Stamets, love seems to be the key to the mutual trust that is needed to master a critical situation. At least, that is what I read into his efforts to pair off Burnham with Tyler, after learning that Burnham has never been in love with someone. It is curious because Stamets just asks for a secret that would make it easier for him to convince Burnham of his findings in the next loop, more like a password. But then he more or less understands it as an obligation to change something about this deficiency, perhaps also because she reminds him of how he was like when he first met Hugh Culber. Stamets wants to accomplish too much as a character, and the whole story eventually overextends the idea of bringing Burnham and Tyler together. Instead of his playing Chinese whispers (he talks to Burnham so she can talk with Tyler), why doesn't Stamets simply approach the two, saying "I need to talk with you. It's urgent." In order to make sure they would listen, he should have asked both of them for a secret to share. Why the connotation that Burnham's appreciation for Tyler or vice versa must have any relevance for the effort to defeat Mudd? I really like the idea of Burnham and Tyler's romance, and it is a cute detail that it only comes to fruition in a timeline that doesn't exist any longer and that only Stamets knows about. This may be another nod to TNG, thinking about Troi and Worf. Still, it feels out of place in the story context.
I like both Burnham and Tyler very much in this episode. Their chemistry works well. In many ways the stubborn Burnham and the charming Tyler mirror the other odd couple on the ship, Stamets and Culber. The depiction of Stamets in the episode, on the other hand, suffers a bit from the character's double trouble. In addition to the trip that he is on since his connection to the spores, he also experiences the many time loops. It must drive him additionally crazy. We never really know what Stamets' behavior is about in this episode, especially since he is not so much in the focus as a character as he should perhaps be, considering he is the only one who always knows what is going on.
I enjoyed the appearance of Harry Mudd in "Choose Your Pain", where he was a sneaky con man, close to the original portrayal of the character in the two TOS episodes. Mudd was a highlight of the episode. There is, however, not much left of this character in "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad". The piece of dialogue "You're mad." - "No, I'm Mudd." that was already known from the series trailers is telling in this regard. The new Mudd is corrupted by his absolute power, he has become a merciless serial killer who just can't stop. Mudd remains playful and comical the whole time, but that hardly exonerates him. On the contrary, these traits left over from the old Mudd let his crimes appear even more frightening, and reminiscent of other psychopathic killers on TV and in movies.
It was foreseeable that the crew would eventually con the con man. But after the numerous temporal loops (at least 56), the crew finally defeats the intruder with a swift idea and a huge deal of luck, rather than in a common effort that profits from the accumulated knowledge of all loops. Stamets unwisely reveals the secret of the spore drive to Mudd, although Tyler has just been killed, and the chance to win in the next loop may be better than ever. But Stamets is excused because he is the one among the crew who went through all those loops and who may have thought that now would be as good as any time to end it. With Mudd being in control of all systems, there are no options left for the crew to avert the capture of the ship by the Klingons, except to offer him something even better. It is not a well-considered plan but a very desperate last resort that Burnham reveals who she is and that the Klingons would pay a fortune for her, only to commit suicide in the next moment. She speculates on Mudd's greed, and that he would sacrifice what he has gained for the chance to get an even higher reward. I don't know whether Mudd knows about the bird in the hand that is worth two in the bush. In any case, he is extremely stupid when he rewinds time yet again.
The clear intention of the writer was to lighten up the story again in the final loop, after all the killing that has been going on in the previous ones. This is also necessary to exonerate the "con man", who will not be known as a murderer by the time of TOS. And it was probably also deemed a good opportunity to show Stella, for the sake of additional comic relief, and to pull off a similar ending as in TOS: "I, Mudd". So the final loop is very plot- and continuity-driven, but it utterly fails in being light-hearted, much less realistic. The narrative makes a big deal of Mudd's claim that he lost Stella because of the war, although in fact he ran away with her dowry. Well, the crew confronts Mudd with his lie to distract him and take his phaser. Still, since they bothered to look it up in his record and even called his father-in-law to that end, does this very minor offense have any relevance to his repeated takeover of the ship in coincidence with mass murder? It is so incredibly stupid that Mudd is released into the custody of his "beloved" Stella and her father that it hurts.
I just love temporal anomaly episodes, and this is a really intelligent one. I enjoy how everything in "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad" unfolds, although I don't mind Lt. Stamets's matchmaking efforts and Mudd as a maniacal mass murderer doesn't work for me. The story is great, the best of the series so far, until the point towards the end when it sacrifices its credibility. The producers of the series should have been aware that the huge damage to the continuity was already done, and that keeping minor facts in line, like Mudd's criminal record, is no reason to write such an outrageously dumb ending for the episode. For all the above reasons and the ones in the annotations below, Mudd wasn't the right choice for the villain of this episode anyway.
- The gormagander, a "space whale", is already the third space-dwelling creature in Discovery. In TOS and TNG, such species were always deemed something exciting and new, but the new series creates the impression they are almost daily routine.
- In TOS, Mudd had a long record of crimes, including theft, smuggling and fraud - but definitely not murder or attempted murder. The release of Mudd into the custody of Baron Grimes is obviously supposed to keep his record clean in this regard, and in line with TOS.
- It remains a mystery how Mudd could convince the Klingons to release him, how he could retrieve the time crystal, how he could find the Discovery (the Klingons evidently can't) and how he could capture the gormagander.
- Mudd wants to figure out the missing component to make the spore drive work, which would be Stamets. He doesn't find it out until Stamets himself tells him. Mudd had access to all of the ship's systems. Didn't he check the engineering logs at any time? It would have made a lot more sense for him than just pushing buttons in engineering to see what happens.
- Stamets asks Burnham for a secret in her life that he could use in the next time loop to earn her trust. She whispers in his ear that she has never been in love. I think that's rather unsuited because it's indefinite evidence. It would have been better and more logical for her to mention a fact or a person from her childhood that is not on record.
- On the Enterprise-D, Geordi would have called Picard: "Captain, don't beam aboard that creature, and raise shields. Trust me. I'll explain later." That doesn't seem to be an option for Stamets, or he tried it and Lorca just didn't listen. This is not really inconsistent but rather sad.
- At some point, Mudd should have noticed that someone else is aware of the time resets. He should have recognized that some of the crew react differently each time. But he seems unsuspecting until Stamets tells him that he too is out of space-time.
- Since when is calling the culprit's father-in-law to apprehend him the punishment for hijacking a Starfleet ship in coincidence with (attempted) mass murder (in multiple cases)? And aside from what he did on the Discovery, Mudd has conspired with the enemy and has crucial strategic knowledge that would absolutely require to lock him up. (It would have been very understandable if Stamets had simply shot him.)
- Why would the crew bother to look up details about Mudd's wife Stella, and even call Baron Grimes? Time is pressing in the effort to defeat Mudd. It would have been totally sufficient to beam Mudd into the brig once the normal course of time was restored.
- Baron Grimes arrives within a few minutes after being called. Why does it need the spore drive if all ships in this universe are ultrafast?
- Remarkable dialogue: "You're mad." - "No, I'm Mudd." (Burnham and Mudd)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "I am among the others... but also apart. I wish sorely to step out of my comfort zone, yet don't know how. But tonight, I will face one of my greatest challenges so far. Tonight we are having... a party." (Burnham's log entry)
- "I'm just sad we missed our first kiss." (Tyler to Burnham, after Stamets has told him of what happened in one loop)
- Remarkable music:
- Wyclef Jean's "Staying Alive" (with samples from the famous Bee Gees song) is played at the party. I can't believe people will still or again love this song after 250 years. The Bee Gees? Perhaps. But Wyclef Jean? Come on!
- In one time loop we can hear "Love and Happiness" by Al Green, obviously arranged by Stamets so Burnham and Tyler can dance.
- Remarkable starship: Baron Grimes arrives with a rather cartoonish ship that looks like it comes from "The Fifth Element". This would have been the chance to show a TOS-like civilian ship.
- Remarkable costumes: The clothes of Stella and her dad are very TOS-like, a homage to the style of Bill Theiss.
- Remarkable homage: When Tyler gives his speech, the camera shows a crew member in a wheelchair, obviously wounded in action.
- Remarkable facts:
- Gormaganders feed on alpha particles in solar winds. This task is so consuming that they often ignore all other instincts, including mating. (Is this an allusion to a certain Discovery crew member?)
- According to Ash Tyler, about 10,000 Starfleet lives were lost since the beginning of the war.
- Tyler says that Mudd bragged about robbing a Betazoid bank, using a "nonequilibrial matter state", which Burnham knows as a time crystal.
- Paul Stamets met Hugh Culber in a café on Alpha Centauri. Culber was humming a Kasseelian opera. The annoyed Stamets told Culber to get lost, but Culber took the seat next to him and kept it ever since.
- Mudd says he lost Stella because of the war, but actually he took her dowry and is running from her father, Baron Grimes.
Stardate 1308.9: The Discovery arrives to aid the USS Gagarin in a battle against Klingon ships that are equipped with the new invisibility screens based on the "Ship of the Dead". The Gagarin, however, is destroyed, just like the Hoover and the Muroc briefly before. Saru, Tyler and Burnham explore the planet Pahvo with its unique natural communication network that extends into space. They hope that the planetary transmitter can be tuned in a way to render cloaked Klingon ships visible. On the "Ship of the Dead", L'Rell vows allegiance to Kol, the new leader of the Klingons. She proposes to help interrogate an obstinate prisoner, Admiral Cornwell. L'Rell, however, reveals to Cornwell that she is going to defect. The two proceed towards the shuttlebay but run into Kol. L'Rell claims that Cornwell took her weapon and tried to escape. She fights with Cornwell and wins, telling Kol she would dispose of the dead body. L'Rell, however, discovers the desecrated bodies of warriors she knew, and swears revenge to Kol. On Pahvo, Saru contacts the planets' non-corporeal inhabitants, and learns that the whole planet is one lifeform. Under the influence of the Pahvans, Saru destroys Tyler's and Burnham's communicators and tells them that he has found his peace on the planet and wishes to stay. Tyler distracts Saru so Burnham can proceed to the natural transmitter in order to contact Discovery. Saru catches up with her and attempts to destroy the Starfleet transmitter that Burnham has connected to the structure. The Pahvans interfere, sending Ash Tyler to stop the violent Saru. The three officers are beamed up to the Discovery. On the Klingon ship, Kol pretends to accept L'Rell's pledge for allegiance but then his people come and drag her away for her attempt to deceive Kol. Although Burnham was under the impression that the transmitter on Pahvo was set to disrupt the Klingon invisibility screens, the Pahvans send out a massive signal to the Federation and the Klingons. Under the assumption that the Klingons see this as an invitation to attack the defenseless planet, the Discovery prepares for a fight.
Welcome to Pahvo, the planet that breathes as one! I suspected there was an analogy to Pandora the moment that the landing party spoke of the unique natural communication network on Pahvo. So it didn't come as a surprise at all when it turned out that the whole planet is a single organism. It was also clear that one of the three Discovery crew members would somehow be transformed or otherwise manipulated by the planet, and that this person would be Saru, the one who suffered the most from the noise level on Pahvo. Discovery finally explores a strange new world in "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum". Yet, this world is neither very original nor very credible. I care more for various other aspects of the story, such as the exciting space battle and some of the character interaction of the landing party on Pahvo.
In one possible interpretation, Saru remains much the same person even under the influence of the planet Pahvo. He is not simply mind-controlled but essentially loses an aspect of his personality or of his Kelpien nature that he always considered a burden. As Saru says himself, he was born afraid, and for the first time in his life he is without fear, thanks to his being connected to the planet. But Saru also loses his ability to judge and his skepticism, which apparently are firmly linked to his species' role as prey on their home planet. In a way, he is like a human being on LSD, or like Stamets on spores. Only Saru's readiness to resort to violence to defend his paradise does not fit with the image. It does not seem to find the approval of the Pahvans either. If the writer's intention was to show what a Kelpien without fear would be like, rather than a mind-controlled instrument of the planet Pahvo, it would have been more favorable not to let Saru become violent. On the other hand, this may be just what Saru is without his caution, a bit like the "bad Kirk" in "The Enemy Within".
In a side plot, Cadet Tilly notices that Lt. Stamets is confused after his latest jump, addressing her as "captain". When she notifies him of his disorientation, Stamets is the old petulant person all over again and reprimands her. Tilly later takes the courage to speak to Stamets again. Stamets now admits that at times he is not sure of where he is and who everyone else is. But he wouldn't let Dr. Culber examine him because the doctor would have to send him to a medical facility of Starfleet, and if he didn't and his superiors found out, it would ruin Culber's career. While the reasoning that Stamets makes up regarding his friend Hugh Culber seems a bit melodramatic, it makes sense for Stamets to remain silent about his occasional confusion, as long as it doesn't jeopardize the ship's mission. On the other hand, maybe it is time to think of someone else as a backup for him? When I try to summarize my impression of the "old" grumpy man, the temporary Stamets "on drugs" and the rather objective one that Tilly talks to, I never really know which one is the true person and whether there is something like a "true Stamets" at all. His character is written as very uneven and remains accordingly hard to grasp. Well, unless we are dealing with genuinely different versions of Stamets.
Speaking of uneven characters, if there is one figure in Discovery that is even less comprehensible, it is L'Rell. Well, her basic behavioral pattern seems to be very simple. She is quick to pledge allegiance with any new leader that seems apt, first with T'Kuvma, then with Voq, then briefly with Kol, then once more with Voq and now with Kol again. Her story so far is cheesy like a Klingon soap opera. But she is just as quick to renounce her loyalty for no apparent reason, and much of her previous servility may have been only pretense anyway. The dilemma is we can't tell what is genuine about her statements and actions, if anything. This was a problem in her mysterious conspiracy with Voq in "The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry", and once again in "Choose Your Pain". What L'Rell is doing can be only partially explained with the fan theory about Voq's whereabouts that exists at this point of the series. L'Rell's behavior in "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" once again raises the question whether her initial pledge for allegiance to Kol was genuine, or rather her attempt to defect with the help of Admiral Cornwell. Both interpretations are equally valid. Only when she is horrified about the desecrated dead warriors and swears revenge to Kol, we can see the real L'Rell, quite possibly for the first time in the whole series. For all I can remember, it is the first time she is alone and hence does not have to pretend anything. It remains to be seen how her latest intrigue will be resolved, and I hope there will soon be more clarity about and more depth to L'Rell (well, and Voq anyway), assuming that she survives. Is she a cunning person who has a big plan, is she an awkward intriguer who always needs to switch to a new plan, or is she just a minion who only knows to jump on the bandwagon?
This takes me to Ash Tyler. The more I get to know him, the more I like him, and the more I want him to remain just the person he appears to be. At this point of the series, I have a soft spot for him and for his relationship with Burnham, perhaps because nothing else in this universe is harmonious. However, we also learn that the apparently so confident and composed lieutenant holds a deep-seated grudge against the Klingons. It makes me wonder what his next confrontation with them will be like, or if we are up for a somehow expected surprise. Anyway, the series currently portrays Tyler to be both as human as possible and as likable as possible. And if there is something wrong with him, it becomes harder every week to make this potential revelation plausible.
This is the first episode of the series with a real cliffhanger, considering that the two parts making up the prologue were released on the same day. "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" leaves a lot of unanswered questions. What are the Pahvans up to? Are they trying to forge a peace treaty, in a similar fashion as the Organians in TOS? What happens to L'Rell? It seems unlikely that she will simply be killed, although Kol appears to have no reason to spare her life. Is Admiral Cornwell really dead? This is unlikely because otherwise it wouldn't have been shown how L'Rell takes the effort of dragging her away, with an eventual close-up on Cornwell. So although "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" is a substandard episode by itself, I find it quite appetizing.
- The Klingon starships in this episode are referred to as "battlecruisers" and "destroyers". The latter is a first time for smaller Klingon ships in Star Trek but makes sense. None of the vessels is in any way familiar (except, of course, from previous DIS episodes).
- This episode establishes that the cloak (or invisibility screen) is not an isolated technology on the Sarcophagus Ship but finds widespread use on Klingon ships during the war. It is hard to reconcile this with later mentions of the technology in which it appears to be brand new (although a possible excuse in this regard is that Star Trek Enterprise set an unfortunate precedent).
- So the planet Pahvo can emit subspace signals. To communicate with other planets? Or with the spore network? Discovery establishes far-reaching interstellar biological phenomena and technology whose complete disappearance will be very hard to justify.
- Why does Kol apply the "war paint" to L'Rell's face as a sign that he accepts her to his house, only to accuse her of treason the very next moment? Does he want to have a traitor in his house so badly? Well, he insinuates that his house has special ways to deal with liars, but wouldn't this apply to non-members likewise?
- Burnham is in an extreme hurry to connect her transmitter to the "antenna" on Pahvo because Saru is on her heels. It doesn't look like she has any time for the modifications to use the antenna as a detector for cloaked ships. All she apparently tries to do is contacting Discovery. Burnham, Tyler and Saru are beamed up immediately after Discovery's arrival, and it doesn't seem that anyone beams down again to modify the transmitter. So why does Burnham assume the transmitter would send a signal to jam the Klingon cloak? Perhaps the transmitter was pre-configured to do that, but this is a stretch, since the technology of Pahvo was completely unknown.
- Remarkable dialogue: "The needs of the many..." - "...are worth fighting for. Are worth dying for. But so are the needs of the few." (Burnham and Tyler, rephrasing a famous Vulcan proverb)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "There will be time to grieve. This is not that time." (Lorca, after the destruction of the Gagarin)
- "And we particularly enjoy being discussed in the third person while present." (Saru, when Burnham tells Tyler about Saru's capabilities)
- Remarkable scene: L'Rell wants Cornwell to scream when she approaches her, but she doesn't do it. L'Rell then screams at her, and the admiral screams back. L'Rell says "Good. You were convincing." (because this was meant to distract the guards).
- Remarkable title: The episode title is Latin for "If you want peace, prepare for war". It sounds much like a prologue to DS9: "Inter Arma Enim Silent Leges".
- Remarkable facts:
- The Klingons destroyed the starships Hoover, Muroc and Gagarin, taking 462 lives.
- Kelpiens like Saru may run faster than 80km/h when pursued by a predator.
- Ash Tyler says that, after the war, he will return to Lake Shasta, to sail and to fish trout.
Admiral Terral orders Captain Lorca to withdraw from Pahvo. Lorca, however, does not want to leave the planet with its peaceful civilization unprotected. He orders a course to Starbase 46 at Warp 5, rather than using the spore drive, to give his crew the opportunity to devise a method to detect the cloaked Klingon "Ship of the Dead". Saru, Burnham and Tyler propose to beam aboard the Klingon ship to install transmitters. When the ship is cloaked, the transmitters would send the position to the Discovery, allowing to relate these data to imperfections of the cloak. In order to get the Klingons to drop their cloak, the Discovery would act as a bait. Lorca asks Stamets to perform as many as 133 microjumps around the Klingon ship, in order to get the required 3D data. Stamets is reluctant but eventually agrees when Lorca demonstrates that he is interested in more than only the military side of Stamets's research, and that it could be used to explore parallel universes. Lorca does not want Burnham to beam over to the Klingon ship with Tyler, but Burnham reminds him of his own words that she is only aboard Discovery to help end the war. The Discovery jumps to Pahvo, right as the Klingon "Ship of the Dead" has arrived. Kol orders to decloak in order to be able to attack, whereupon Tyler and Burnham beam aboard, masked by pattern simulators that let them appear as Klingons. They place one transmitter near the ship's stern but then discover a human lifesign in the burial chamber. It is Admiral Cornwell. While Burnham tends to the admiral, Tyler discovers someone he knows: It is L'Rell, who was dumped here by Kol. Memories of his torture resurface in his mind, and he is unable to act. Burnham stuns L'Rell and proceeds to the bridge alone to place the second transmitter. Once she has activated the device, the Discovery jumps away. The Klingon vessel goes to cloak again, giving the Discovery crew the opportunity to perform the microjumps and to gather the data necessary to detect the cloaked vessel. Kol's people, however, discover the sabotage to the ship. In order to gain time, Burnham gives up her cover, reveals her identity as the one who killed T'Kuvma and challenges Kol to a fight. After the completion of the scan, the three Starfleet officers are beamed out of the Klingon vessel, but also a Klingon prisoner, L'Rell. The algorithm to detect the cloaked vessel is put together, and Lorca orders to fire photon torpedoes, destroying the defenseless "Ship of the Dead". Apparently plagued by his PTSD, Tyler goes to the brig to see L'Rell, who insinuates that the two have a common plan. Lorca promises that Stamets would have to perform just one last jump, to get the Discovery out of the range of the Klingons. But this jump goes awry. Stamets collapses, and the ship ends up in unknown territory, surrounded by Klingon wreckage.
I would have expected this episode to resolve the mystery about the Pahvans, who sent out a signal in "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum", with the possible intention to get the Federation and the Klingons to talk. The resolution in "Into the Forest I Go" is more conventional, however. The Pahvans don't even show up again. Still, "Into the Forest I Go" is the most intense Discovery episode so far. The story thrives on the carefully executed plan to expose the cloaked enemy vessel, the spirit of collaboration among the Starfleet crew, the excitement about the space battle but also on the human drama of Ash Tyler's PTSD. However, the story consists of many more elements, not all of which sit so well with me. Some of them come with a bad aftertaste and even cast doubt on the things I like about the episode.
Captain Lorca is my favorite character in "Into the Forest I Go". Well, his shipwide announcement that the crew of the Discovery used to consist of scientists who have become warriors doesn't resonate with me. But it is the kind of statement that the crew may have expected from him in this situation. Other than that, Lorca has become a commendable captain who is well aware of his duties. He disobeys his orders in much the same fashion as Picard would have done under the same circumstances, in order to save the peaceful Pahvans. This is remarkable because so far we knew Lorca as a warrior who would only protect the Federation and its citizens. He has just learned of the peaceful civilization on Pahvo and never met anyone of them in person, and still he is ready to fight for them. It almost seems to be a bit out of character that Lorca would want to defend the Pahvans without the need to persuade him, but then again it is the first time in the series that he is in such a situation. His stance that officers shouldn't advertise the fact that they disobey orders is wise, and is a nice contrast to other Starfleet commanders who used to make their moral or tactical superiority a big deal.
Lorca motivates the crew, and especially Stamets, who is reluctant to perform so many jumps in rapid succession. We could argue that Lorca only exploits Stamets' driving force of being a scientist, that he entices Stamets to risk his life with the prospect of making a revolutionary discovery. But realistically, what could Stamets achieve if the ship has to stay in a safe harbor, or if the Klingons win the war? I think Lorca does the right thing when he assures Stamets of his support for the scientific mission ("Captain, I didn't know you cared"), after the war, for which a further sacrifice may be necessary. Regarding Burnham, on the other hand, the captain is very cautious, if not to say overprotective. He does not want her to go on the dangerous mission aboard the Klingon ship. He thinks of her as a very valuable crew member, so in his view it would be better to send Ensign Expendable. Burnham reminds him that he released her from prison to help end the war in the first place, that she has no other purpose on the Discovery and that she would be the most qualified person because she has been on that ship before. Lorca listens to her, unlike he did on previous occasions, and ultimately has to agree with her logic.
Dr. Culber and Cadet Tilly have no obvious purpose in this episode. We can see Culber as he examines Stamets on Lorca's orders, to find some reason why he shouldn't perform further spore drive jumps. But the thorough examination is pointless because it takes just as long as Burnham and Saru need to devise the plan to detect the cloaked Klingon ship. It would have made a lot more sense for Stamets to help them. Culber later accompanies Stamets to the chamber to monitor his lifesigns during the jumps (which he should have done on previous occasions too). Tilly, who obviously doesn't know that Culber has examined him, thinks that Stamets told his friend about the side effects of the jumps (which he could and should have done at latest during the medical test). She embarrasses Stamets with her knowledge of something that the lieutenant didn't reveal to his friend. But that's all what the involvement of Tilly and Culber is about.
Michael Burnham and Ash Tyler are the heart of this story. It first seems they would subordinate their mutual feelings to their mission, but at latest when Tyler opens himself to Burnham it becomes clear that the two are willing to share more than only the bright moments of their lives. It almost brought a tear to my eyes when Ash spoke of how being on the Discovery with Michael was worth all the months of torture.
We always have to keep in mind that the sword of Damocles is hanging above Tyler's character. L'Rell's remark that she has plans with him is telling and is a further hint that Tyler is actually Voq in human disguise. If this is true, it will entail several huge problems. The more we see of Tyler and of his very human behavior and emotional life, the less plausible it is that he may be a surgically altered Klingon, or a human with an implanted parasitic Klingon personality. Even if a fake person of the latter type may still have genuine loyalty for the Federation and affection for Burnham, the visualization of his being tortured and raped would have to be rated as an illicit deception of the viewers. Furthermore, exposing Tyler as a Klingon spy would not only destroy one of the most popular characters of Discovery, which is something we may be expected to put up with in modern-day serial television. It would also show someone as a liar, who so far exemplifies PTSD in an unprecedented fashion in Star Trek. A series that otherwise prides itself in being diverse and inclusive would disparage war veterans, victims of torture and sexual abuse, and other people with traumatic experiences. I hate to think about the consequences.
L'Rell's statements and actions make less sense in every episode she appears in. So far she has done everything to weaken her own position and that of her people. She has lost everything, and survived the last episode only with a big deal of luck. Kol might just as well have killed her on the spot instead of leaving her in the burial chamber. It is totally incredible that she could have a bigger plan, one that takes into account that the Klingons don't get hold of the spore drive, lose the advantage of cloaking and eventually lose the war, not to mention her own degradation to an outcast who is captured by the enemy. This all makes absolutely no sense. If she really has an agenda, it relies on so many coincidences that is makes Kirk's unlikely maneuvers to snatch the Romulan cloaking device in "The Enterprise Incident" appear like a well-considered plan.
As a sort of summary of the first chapter with Discovery's all-new Klingons, they never appeared to me like the endangered civilization that T'Kuvma spoke of, or like the alien race that has good reasons to go to war against the Federation as insinuated in the promotion campaign. The Discovery Klingons have just one principal enemy: themselves. They are hampered by their their own immobility, figuratively and literally. They like to hear themselves talk, but hesitate when it comes to acting. They may be great in scheming and possibly in gathering intelligence but don't manage to use it. They are never consequential in what they are doing. Overall, the Klingons are disappointing as the antagonists of the series. And the mere intention that they should become very alien and accordingly incomprehensible does not justify the total alteration of every aspect of their culture, not only the visual ones. I can only speak for myself, but I sorely miss the look and feel of the old Klingons. In this regard, I like how Kol accepts Burnham's challenge to a duel, although he would have no reason to even listen to her. Their fight evokes the old, more vivid Klingon spirit that is otherwise missing from the series.
We don't know at this time what happens to the Discovery when Stamets's last jump goes awry. But there are a few cues in the episode. The first is when Stamets mentions the possibility to enter parallel universes. The second is that the Discovery isn't seen jumping in just one direction as usual, but also in the opposite one. This is reminiscent of the visualization of the Mirror Universe in TOS: "Mirror, Mirror". On another note, we can see in the jump log that jump #133 was overridden by Lorca, leading to a jump to an "unknown" position. Lorca says, "Let's go home", which seems to support another popular fan theory, that he is from a parallel universe. Jump #133, however, is not the upcoming one but was the last of the 133 jumps that Stamets performed to locate the cloaked ship and that already appeared as successful on Tilly's display earlier in the episode. Would Lorca have any reason to sabotage the very jump that would lead to the destruction of the "Ship of the Dead"? Was the enemy ship destroyed in a parallel universe (in his one?), and Lorca now wants to take the ship "home" to "our" universe? It is a total conundrum what he is up to.
"Into the Forest I Go" is the so far most exciting and most revealing installment of the series, and a worthy mid-season finale in almost every respect. It evokes the spirit of the old Star Trek, with a crew that is of one mind and works towards a common goal. There are some characters that don't work so well and we don't learn why the Pahvans sent out the signal, but that doesn't detract from the story. However, I have misgivings about the continued secret-mongering about L'Rell and Tyler, especially as the story gives rise to new mysteries about Lorca and Stamets. I just hate that every second character is under suspicion to have a hidden agenda or even to be a completely different person. It may be a stylistic device of modern serialized television and it may be deemed useful to keep the fans talking (and possibly to distract from other issues of Discovery). But I think that the mystery factor about characters is neither realistic nor desirable, considering that the viewer needs to be able to relate to their motivations, thoughts and actions to some extent. Discovery carelessly plays around with its assets. The series will have a very hard time to resolve the mess it creates, regarding Star Trek's continuity but also regarding its very own storylines and characters.
- After the Discovery is gone, Pahvo is defenseless again. What makes Lorca assume that other Klingon vessels wouldn't follow the signal?
- So L'Rell has a plan? One that involves that the Klingons don't get hold of the spore drive, lose the advantage of cloaking and eventually lose the war? One that takes into account that she survives only by chance and becomes an outcast who is captured by the enemy?
- Remarkable dialogue: "I need some reasonable explanation as to why we're currently not using the spore drive. I understand you had some trouble with your interface upgrades." - "Now that you mention it, uhm, has been a little itchy." (Lorca and Stamets)
- Remarkable quotes:
- I have no intention of reaching our destination. But if you're planning on disobeying a direct order, it's best not to advertise the fact." (Captain Lorca)
- "Do not worry. I will never let them hurt you... Soon." (L'Rell, to Tyler(?))
- Remarkable scenes:
- Kol notices that Burnham sees a value in the Starfleet badge in his hand that belonged to Captain Georgiou. He taunts her, saying "It makes for a useful object to pick my teeth." and demonstrates it. Briefly before she gets beamed out, Burnham grabs the badge.
- We see the first romantic kiss of two men in the history of Star Trek.
- And for what it's worth, in the second (sexual) part of Tyler's flashbacks we can see exposed Klingon breasts for the first time.
- Remarkable ship: The size of the Sarcophagus Ship has been the subject of a lot of speculation. We now know that the first sensor needs to be set up 600 meters away from the place where Burnham and Tyler beamed aboard, so a length of at least 1000 meters seems plausible. We also get a size comparison with the Discovery. The Sarcophagus Ship is more than twice as long. Since the Discovery measures as much as 800m (600m without the nacelles), the Klingon vessel must be at least one mile long.
- Remarkable title: The title is a quote by naturalist John Muir, "And into the forest I go, to lose my mind and find my soul."
- Remarkable facts:
- The Klingon cloak is based on a gravitational field that bends light and other radiation around the ship.
- Burnham and Tyler place two transmitters on the Klingon ship. Although not explicitly mentioned, the placement of two transmitters at a relatively great distance would allow triangulation of the signals and would reduce the amount of data points (and hence of jumps) required to gather the 3D information for the algorithm. This is an example of good science in the series. If the second transmitter were just for the sake of redundancy, it would make no sense to put them so far apart from the first one.
- Lorca and Stamets theorize that the pockets of negative mass in the map obtained from Stamets's jumps indicate that the mycelial network is connected to parallel universes.
- Lorca is about to receive the Legion of Honor award, but wants to pass it on to Stamets.
After the last spore drive jump that Stamets performed, the Discovery is trapped in a parallel universe where Vulcans, Andorians and Klingons are allies in the fight against the xenophobic Terran Empire. Stamets alternatingly enters a catatonic and a frantic state. As Lorca doubts that Dr. Culber keeps a sufficient professional distance, he decides to assign another doctor to the patient. When Tyler is sent to retrieve a computer core from the remains of a Klingon ship, his PTSD resurfaces, and he barely manages to perform the task. He visits L'Rell in the brig, who insinuates that he is not the person he believes to be. Tyler seeks Dr. Culber's help, who agrees to perform further tests on him. After the investigation of the computer data, it turns out that the ship has switched places with the Discovery from the parallel universe, here commanded by Captain Tilly. The Lorca of the parallel universe attempted to overthrow the emperor, who sent Captain Burnham of the ISS Shenzhou to apprehend the traitor. But she was killed by his followers. The emperor had Captain Lorca's ship, the ISS Buran, destroyed, while Lorca himself managed to escape. Our Lorca finds out that the USS Defiant crossed over to the Mirror Universe without the use of the spore drive, but information on the classified incident would only be accessible to active captains. He and Burnham come up with the plan to pretend that she is still alive in the parallel universe, and to return to the ISS Shenzhou with Lorca as her bounty. "Captain" Tilly calls the Shenzhou, now commanded by Connor. He reluctantly agrees to let Burnham return to her rightful place on the ship, with her valuable prisoner. While they prepare to beam over, Dr. Culber finds out that Tyler was surgically and mentally altered by the Klingons. Tyler kills him. He then rushes to the transporter platform and beams over to the Shenzhou with Burnham and Lorca. Aboard the Shenzhou, Connor tries to assassinate Burnham, but she defeats and kills him, which earns her the appreciation of "her" crew. Tyler is already waiting in her ready room, apparently ready to retrieve the information on the Defiant, while Lorca suffers in a agony booth.
The series had to resolve a number of mysteries in this episode, and is successful on at least a few accounts. "Despite Yourself" provides a satisfying answer to the question why Stamets showed a multiple personality disorder after a number of jumps. It is because at times he really was a different person, after switching places with his own Mirror Universe counterpart, who would recognize Tilly as his "captain". So it was obvious that the episode would take Discovery to some parallel universe, and I would have been disappointed if after all the foreshadowing there had been a different explanation for the strange occurrences in the past few episodes. And considering Jonathan Frakes's big spoiler, it was no surprise either that his episode would be set in the already familiar Mirror Universe established in TOS: "Mirror, Mirror".
Considering that the Mirror Universe incidents of all Star Trek series were always strangely entangled, not to mention the characters, it was clear that Discovery would be no exception in this regard. The appearance of the USS Defiant from TOS: "The Tholian Web" and ENT: "In a Mirror, Darkly" in the dialogue and on a screen is the continuation of a tradition in Star Trek, and as such rather a sign of laziness than one of genuine continuity. The whole idea to show a Mirror Universe variant of Discovery so early in the series, with the fun of creating still different uniform styles, badges and agony booths, seems to cater to the nostalgic feelings of the makers of the series in the first place.
As I already anticipated when Jonathan Frakes first announced the Mirror Universe episode of Discovery, it is a combination that puts me off, and "Despite Yourself" can't change my mind. In many ways, Discovery itself is a parallel universe, as much as the people in charge may reject this notion. In fact, the Klingons of the traditional Prime Universe of Star Trek have everything in common with those of the traditional Mirror Universe, and nothing with the reimagined Discovery Klingons, to mention just the most obvious obstacle.
Even many of the "loyal" fans, who (incomprehensibly) dismiss the extreme Klingon transformation as a mere stylistic change, feel that Discovery lacks the old Star Trek spirit of peace, solidarity and compassion. It almost seems like "Despite Yourself" attempts to whitewash the Discovery Prime Universe in this regard, not only in the visualization of the "savage" Mirror Universe and its cruelties, but especially in its verbal description. Burnham reiterates no less than three times in one minute how evil the humans of the newly discovered parallel universe are, and a few more times throughout the rest of the episode. They are "a fascistic empire" and "an oppressive racist xenophobic culture", ruled by "a faceless emperor", and so on. It is understandable that after studying historical records of the Empire's genocides Burnham would choose such harsh words. But the repeated finger-wagging gets annoying because at some point it breaks the fourth wall. Also, I wonder what quality and quantity of facts, collected only by the Empire's enemies as it appears, Burnham can base her judgment on, after reading in them for perhaps an hour or two and before meeting any human of this universe face to face. In Star Trek, alien civilizations are usually not rated as cruel or even fascistic from the outset, not even Discovery's version of the Klingons. Humans, on the other hand, are apparently not conceded this benefit of the doubt.
Regardless of the lacking credibility of the premise on Discovery's thin ice, the Mirror Universe with its stereotypes and its limited storytelling potential just isn't interesting any longer to a long-time Star Trek fan, who sees more in the franchise than nostalgia. It may have been decent as a one-episode excursion, but with the prospect of another full Mirror episode next week I'm not really excited to see the conclusion. I only hope that it will be over soon. There are a few nice new twists in "Despite Yourself", such as the efforts to modify the whole ship and crew to pass as the Mirror version. But ultimately this narrative too boils down to the cliché that the counterparts of the crew are all ruthless or otherwise contrary to what they are in our universe. All of them seem to have overblown and cheesy back stories. The Mirror characters may be killed or may survive just as the story requires it, which is made possible by the nature of this place as a throwaway version of the Prime Universe. The only noteworthy aspect is how bad Burnham feels after killing Connor, the kind young ensign who was afraid of the war and died before Burnham's eyes in "Battle at the Binary Stars". He is a merciless killer in the Mirror Universe, who doesn't hesitate to get away with Burnham to save his position as the ship's captain. Still, he is someone who Burnham cares for. It is the only emotional moment in an overall cold episode, and it gave me goosebumps.
Speaking of emotions, the revelation that Tyler is indeed Voq was probably supposed to be a highlight of the episode. But Voq-Tyler is not interesting as a character any longer, and this isn't even primarily because he commits a murder. He would be interesting if he could remain Tyler, a vet who can't cope with his PTSD and who may find comfort and perhaps help in Michael Burnham. It would be equally good to see the old Voq again, a Klingon who always was an outsider, and whose fanaticism unexpectedly earned him respect and brought him to power. But Voq-Tyler is a strange hybrid, whose very nature is unrealistic and whose behavior will change arbitrarily, just as the plot requires it. It is pathetic enough that L'Rell's alleged plan brought her aboard the Discovery only because of a series of unlikely mishaps. It makes things worse that a totally unstable person like Voq-Tyler is a crucial part of this plan. Moreover, the Voq-Tyler side plot with the killing of Dr. Culber distracts from the mission on the Mirror Shenzhou, as if the writers had a feeling the Mirror Universe premise alone was not exciting enough.
Another big disappointment is how Hugh Culber is killed without having accomplished anything of note in the series. He did not appear until episode 4 and used to be discreetly absent at times when medical advice would have been useful. He was not heavily involved in his friend Stamets's experiments and self-experiments, even after Lorca had made them official. In light of this low profile of the character, it is ironic that Culber loses Stamets as a patient just when it would matter the most for him, and even more ironic that he meets his fate just when a conflict with the captain arises, the very first time the otherwise restrained Culber might play up. In brief, he was just not supposed to become important.
Overall, things fall apart in this episode, as several characters drop out. Tyler is a murderous Klingon spy, Stamets is unresponsive, Culber is dead, Saru is clueless, Lorca is a shady person with an uncertain agenda. Tilly at least provides comic relief. Burnham remains as the only crew member we can still count on. She is also the only character I still perceive as authentic and that I feel emotionally attached to, similar as already in her first two episodes on this ship. I only don't get it why she has to get intimate with Tyler on the ISS Shenzhou. There couldn't be a worse universe and time for it.
Something I notice in the performances of a couple of characters in this episode is that they remain unnaturally soft-spoken. Jason Isaacs (Lorca), Shazad Latif (Tyler) and Wilson Cruz (Culber) seem to restrain themselves not to speak from the depths of their throats. I recall this phenomenon from several previous Discovery episodes, but it is particularly noticeable in "Despite Yourself". Perhaps their unusual constraint and contemplation is a further attempt to emphasize the difference to the rampant Mirror Universe. Overall, Jonathan Frakes successfully stages the weird situation the crew is in, but in a way that it is constantly strained, without leading to a particular climax. In a way, watching this episode was straining for me too, rather than entertaining.
Regarding the series continuity, "Despite Yourself" leaves two mysteries that will probably not be explained and will persist as inconsistencies. The first is the time of at most three weeks that were available for L'Rell and Voq to transfer to the Klingon ship (an idea that they suddenly got after months of obviously unnecessary starving at the binary stars), to transform Voq and to let Tyler spend time with Mudd in the prison cell. This is more than a simple oversight, it is sloppy writing. The second is that according to Lorca's display, jump #133 was manipulated by him in the last episode, not the last one, #134. I don't expect this ever to become plausible.
In a way, Discovery falls straight into the hole the writers have dug for the series. Some of the many issues are resolved in "Despite Yourself", but not in a particularly intelligent or surprising way. Some other problems are aggravated. Most of the characters don't work for me, which has definitely to do with them being dead, disabled or otherwise discredited. Although I'm not fond of Mirror episodes anyway, I would have preferred the story without the distraction from the Voq-Tyler plot. And I would have preferred the detour to the Mirror Universe to last just one episode. Overall, "Despite Yourself" may not be quite the worst episode of the series so far, but it is the most disappointing one.
- It is obvious why the Constitution-class Defiant was only shown as a very coarse wireframe. The producers don't dare yet to out Discovery as a visual reboot, which is why the appearance of this ship class in the reboot universe remains "classified". It is a similar obfuscation tactic as not mentioning the "Ferengi" in ENT: "Acquisition" and the "Borg" in ENT: "Regeneration".
- It is no big deal that the Constitution-class USS Defiant NCC-1764 looks somewhat different by now (with indentations in the saucer and a kink in the nacelle struts). We have to keep in mind that the ship arrived in the Mirror Universe as long as a hundred years ago. It could have seen quite a number of refits. The only slight oddity is that the monitor shows the original prefix "USS", although we may assume it was changed to "ISS".
- The "scientific" explanation for the differences between our universe and the Mirror Universe is that the quantum signatures are different. While this was neither confirmed nor denied in previous Mirror Universe episodes, the concept of quantum signatures rather belongs to the quantum universes of TNG: "Parallels".
- It would have been a good idea to transmit the procedure to detect cloaked vessels to Starfleet right away, before engaging the spore drive.
- Where is that other doctor that Lorca mentions and who should tend to Stamets, replacing Culber? Have we ever seen anyone else identified as a doctor on the ship?
- Remarkable quote: "Is that how you treat your long-lost captain? If you greeted me that way I'd cut out your tongue and use it to lick my boots." ("Captain" Tilly, to Captain Connor)
- Remarkable scenes:
- I like how "Captain" Tilly complains to the captain of the other Terran Empire ship, the Cooper: "What the hell. Hold your horses." Her awkwardness reminds me of the Doctor as "ECH" in VOY: "Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy".
- When Tilly asks Lorca to pose as her chief engineer, he imitates a Scottish accent.
- The crew switch their Starfleet emblems with the ones of the Mirror Universe (Earth + sword + an inverted Starfleet delta in this reimagination), and they even repaint the ship prefix on the hull to read "I.S.S.".
- Remarkable appearance: Besides the Shenzhou, we also see Ensign Connor again, now as the ship's new captain.
- Remarkable facts:
- Dr. Culber mentions the "Manchurian test" to uncover hidden engrams, referring to the novel The Manchurian Candidate by Richard Condon.
- Just as in our universe, Mirror Lorca commanded the Buran, and managed to escape before the ship was destroyed.
Burnham and Tyler have to stay aboard the ISS Shenzhou in the parallel universe until they can either decipher the information on the Defiant, or transmit it to the Discovery without anyone listening. In the meantime on the Discovery, the murder of Dr. Culber has been discovered, but is ascribed to Lt. Stamets. Tilly, however, is sure that Stamets is not himself because of his exposure to the spore network. She convinces Saru to let her proceed with a treatment with spores, rather than relying on conventional medicine. "Captain" Burnham receives orders from the imperial flagship to destroy the rebel base of the "Fire Wolf", the Klingon leader of the alien rebels. She needs a pretext and tells the crew that she would rather beam down with Tyler and steal data that may help eradicate the rebellion once and for all. When she and Tyler materialize on the surface of the planet called Harlak, the two surrender to the rebels. They are taken to a camp and meet the "Fire Wolf", who turns out to be the parallel version of Voq. Burnham tries to convince Voq that she is no longer the ruthless captain he used to know. In order to verify her statement he calls the "Prophet", the parallel version of Sarek. In a mind meld with Burnham, Sarek confirms her peaceful intentions. Tyler, however, becomes increasingly agitated in the presence of Voq, his true identity in the other universe. As memories of his former Klingon life resurface, Voq-Tyler is appalled that his alter ego would ally himself with Vulcans, Andorians and Tellarites. He assaults Voq. Only Sarek's insistence that Burnham's intentions are genuine prevents that she and Tyler are killed by the rebels. Burnham warns the rebels of the impending attack and returns to the Shenzhou with Tyler. Tilly almost succeeds to revert Stamets's brain to the normal state, but then his heart activity drops rapidly, and the medical staff can't save him. Stamets comes back to life though, and in his mind he meets his parallel self. When Burnham confronts Tyler, he admits that he is Voq in human disguise, and that he infiltrated the Discovery. He attempts to kill her, but Saru, the captain's slave in this universe, saves Burnham's life. Tyler is taken to the transporter room for execution. Burnham personally beams him into space, but he then materializes on the Discovery where he is arrested. Saru also takes the storage device with the information on the Defiant that Burnham placed in Tyler's holster. On the Shenzhou, Burnham is informed that another ship begins an orbital bombardment of Harlak. It is the ship of the emperor, who turns out to be Georgiou. Emperor Georgiou is angry that Burnham disobeyed her order to eliminate the outpost immediately.
The few things I like about "The Wolf Inside" can be summed up quickly. It is only consequential that Voq-Tyler's deconstruction continues, although it distracts from the main plot just like in last week's episode. At least, the secretiveness about his character is finally over. It was getting on my nerves. Cadet Tilly gets more action in this episode. She can show that she cares for her superior officer, and she can put her knowledge about the spore drive to good use. Yet, it is a bit annoying that Stamets seems to be dead just for the sake of a little extra thrill, and is miraculously resurrected a few minutes later (like Worf in "Ethics" or Tom in "Threshold"). Saru appears as a competent temporary captain this time and unlike in "Choose Your Pain", as he relies on the expertise of Tilly and of Burnham. Well, Burnham may overact once again when she tries to save both universes. But when she spares the lives of the people on Harlak, she does the same as Kirk in "Mirror, Mirror" and proves that her assertion to come from a better universe is more than just lip service. I also like the irony that lies in Burnham's affectionate affirmation of trust in Tyler at a time it is clear that he is a Klingon spy. Unlike in the previous episodes depicting their relationship where is comes across much like a fake in hindsight, it now has a meaning that the story takes time for it.
Burnham watches helplessly how crew members are beamed into space for their "malicious thoughts". But her conscience and her Starfleet spirit eventually kick in when she is ordered to eliminate the rebel outpost on Harlak. Lorca advises against disobeying her direct orders but has to admit that everything Starfleet is founded on should not lose its validity in the Mirror Universe. Burnham's attempt to not only spare the lives of the rebels but also give them a spark of hope that their world may become a better place is noble. But she overextends the idea when she tries to find the secret of why the Klingons of this universe would ally themselves with other races, in the hope to come to terms with the Klingons of her own universe as well. It is obvious that this is fallacious from the outset, since the Mirror Klingons may have just as little in common with the Prime Universe Klingons as the humans of the two universes with each other. Burnham seems to think that in the Mirror Universe all alien species are linked in a spirit of cooperation, but she fails to recognize the simple truth, that my enemy's enemy is my ally. And so Voq does not tell her anything of further significance. Ultimately the whole fuss she makes about peace with the Klingons is nothing more in the story than the inadvertent trigger for Voq-Tyler to expose his true nature. This part of "The Wolf Inside" exemplifies how plot-driven the characters are. The writing is not primarily aimed at putting the pieces together to a bigger picture, but to provide the timing for otherwise predictable plot twists, and let them appear more dramatic.
I already mentioned in my review of last week's "Despite Yourself" that the Mirror Universe premise doesn't work for me in the series context of Discovery. It is hard enough to recognize the Discovery Prime Universe as "our" universe, to overlook the extreme visual alterations, to come to terms with the overall cold climate and to put up with the idea that at least every second character is a traitor, suffers from a disorder or has a hidden agenda. The long stay in the Mirror Universe distracts (and effectively detracts) from the introduction of the "normal" Discovery universe, which by now is still far from being a credible, much less a desirable flavor of Star Trek.
Just as last week's episode confirmed the fan theory on Tyler being Voq and showed us the USS Defiant yet again, "The Wolf Inside" fulfills everyone's expectation that the "faceless emperor" is none other than Philippa Georgiou. Her appearance makes sense by the traditionally weird logic of this pulp universe where improbable coincidences seem to be the rule, and where the further consequences don't matter. But it also fits with the general impression that the world of Discovery is a small and confined one compared to the big Star Trek Universe. Most of what happens in Discovery has been hinted at before and involves characters, ships and places we already know. And whenever something really unexpected happens, it has no further significance, such as Culber's death. In some ways, the Mirror Universe is an exaggeration of the Discovery Prime Universe, rather than an antithesis.
In a further attempt to verbally underline the differences between the Prime Universe and the Mirror Universe, Burnham asserts: "Even the light is different. The cosmos has lost its brilliance." Considering the very different visual effects and the omnipresent yellow and neon blue lighting of the series, this statement breaks the fourth wall and also describes how fans of the old Star Trek perceive Discovery. Well, while everything related to actual and computer-generated lighting continues to be disappointing, this episode stands out with the credible scenery of the surface of Harlak (although the planet too has a blue hue).
On another curious (and slightly bothersome) note about this episode, it has the probably longest teaser of Star Trek's history. The opening credits appear as late as after 15 minutes, and rather unexpectedly.
"The Wolf Inside" continues in the same vein as last week's "Despite Yourself". The episode consequentially fleshes out the Discovery-specific Mirror Universe setting and the Voq-Tyler story. But the fun aspect that so far was one of the saving graces of the Mirror Universe setting is missing this time. The characters are chased through a plot full of clichés. Everything that happens is either foreseeable (Burnham listens to her conscience, Voq-Tyler's true nature is exposed, Georgiou is the emperor), or it remains meaningless like the appearance of Mirror Voq. The perhaps worst thing about this episode is that Discovery is still not back in its own universe and that we have to endure at least one more Mirror episode with probably the same uninspired writing.
- The Andorian that can be seen in this episode looks like the variations already established but features pronounced bones where previous Andorians used to have eyebrows. Perhaps I should just be glad that the Andorians were not turned into insects (as indicated by the helmet in "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad")?
- The two reimagined Tellarites have tusks like a wild boar or a warthog, and unlike any Tellarites previously seen in Star Trek.
- It seems the dead Culber is discovered hours after Tyler's departure. No other medical personnel is present to tend to Stamets or to assist Culber. Where is that other doctor that Lorca was talking of? The power in sickbay is switched off for the repair job without anyone looking after the patient!
- Why does Saru assume that Stamets killed Culber? He appears to be a suspect only in a very superficial investigation. Are there no surveillance records of sickbay? And even if Tyler deleted them, his fingerprints and DNA must be on Culber's neck.
- Just like Culber never appeared in engineering in the beginning, there is no medical personnel overseeing Tilly's experimental therapy, until Stamets is about to die. Even if Saru and Tilly "kidnapped" Stamets, wouldn't the CMO notice that his patient is missing? Wouldn't he or she insist on being present wherever Stamets was taken and whatever Tilly is going to do with him?
- Why would the apparently dead Stamets remain in the spore chamber in main engineering, in bright light for everyone to see?
- How could the Discovery follow the Shenzhou all the time without being noticed, so the ship could be in transporter range when needed? Also, doesn't "Captain Tilly" receive any orders that would require the Discovery to show up somewhere?
- Why is Georgiou an "Emperor", not an "Empress"? I don't assume that the Terran Empire would abolish the female form of the title for the sake of gender equality. In this case, the real-world reason, to conceal identity of the "Emperor", may just as well be the in-universe rationale too. Perhaps Georgiou doesn't want to let the ordinary people know she is a woman.
- Remarkable quote: "You remind me of everything good, of what I want my world to look like." (Burnham, to Voq-Tyler, when she still thinks he is Tyler)
- Remarkable scene: Burnham lies to Saru when he asks whether there are any Kelpiens aboard the ISS Shenzhou, obviously out of respect for him, considering that Mirror Saru is a slave. When the transmission has ended, it turns out that Saru too didn't tell the truth because he didn't mention Dr. Culber's death, in order not to distract Burnham.
- Remarkable appearances:
- James Frain appears as the Mirror Sarek, with a goatee just like his son Spock would have one in "Mirror, Mirror".
- Michelle Yeoh can be seen once again in the series, as Emperor Georgiou.
- Remarkable fact: In the Mirror Universe, several alien races such as the Vulcans, Tellarites, Andorians and Klingons have allied themselves against the human-only Terran Empire. Voq, the "Fire Wolf", is their leader. Sarek is called the "Prophet".
"Captain" Burnham and her "prisoner" Lorca are summoned to the ISS Charon, the palace ship of Emperor Georgiou. In order to return home, they still need to find out the coordinates of the interphasic space that brought the USS Defiant to the parallel universe. The emperor is delighted to see Burnham alive, who is much like a daughter to her. She sentences the alleged traitor Lorca to spend the rest of his life in an agony booth. Burnham is asked to choose one Kelpien slave for an unknown reason, and she picks one. During her dinner with Burnham, Emperor Georgiou casually mentions that the meal is a Kelpien. Although Burnham tries hard to conceal her extreme disgust, the emperor suddenly questions her loyalty and sentences her to death. But as she is going to be executed in the presence of high-ranking Empire officials, Burnham reveals that she comes from another universe and gives Georgiou the Starfleet badge with its different quantum signature as proof. Georgiou spares Burnham's life but kills all officials that are present except one, who promises that he will keep the secret. On the Discovery, Stamets is still in a coma, but his mind is walking about in the spore network together with his parallel universe counterpart, who is trapped there for quite some time already. The other patient on the Discovery, Voq-Tyler, is torn between his human and his Klingon identity. Saru seeks the help of L'Rell, and she finally agrees to treat him after the suffering Voq-Tyler has been beamed into her cell for her to see. In the spore network, Stamets glimpses his deceased friend Culber and follows him, against the advice of his parallel universe counterpart. Culber tells him that the other Stamets was going to destroy the network, and that he simply has to open his eyes to wake up. The two versions of Stamets wake up on their respective ships, the Discovery and the Charon. The Stamets on the Discovery notices that the sickness of the spore network has already spread to the Discovery's spore supply. On the Charon, Burnham proposes to give Emperor Georgiou the spore drive technology, in exchange for the information that will allow the Discovery to return to its own universe. Lorca is still in the agony booth, interrogated by Captain Maddox, who blames him for killing his sister Ava. Georgiou opens Burnham's eyes regarding Lorca's true identity. The Lorca she knows is the one from the parallel universe, the one who gathered followers to overthrow Georgiou, the one who was chased by the parallel Burnham. The only way for him to get on the palace ship was as Burnham's prisoner, and so he went to the Prime Universe and took command of the USS Discovery, to enlist her for the job. As the two are talking, Lorca breaks out of his agony booth and attacks Maddox.
It seems that Discovery spreads rumors and gives rise to fan theories, only to confirm them one by one. I don't know if it is the intention of the writing staff to give us the feeling of being smart, or if they feel like including broad hints for themselves to get it right. Anyway, just like the open secret about Voq-Tyler, the idea that Lorca is from the Mirror Universe has been lingering since the early days of the series, effectively since we know that there would be a Mirror episode and since Lorca appears to be somehow different than the other people on the Discovery. So our Lorca (and perhaps the only one still alive) really is the one from the Mirror Universe. He needed Michael Burnham for the sole purpose to get his feet on Emperor Georgiou's ship, as Burnham's prisoner.
This agenda may explain why he was always very protective of Burnham, but nothing else makes sense. Lorca somehow found a way to our universe while he was on the run, which will be explained next week. He somehow had to take the place of Prime Lorca. Did he blow up the ship, or was the Buran already destroyed at the time? Will we ever know? Anyway, he also must have made up a really good story as to how he survived the Buran disaster (Well, he was successful at that in both universes after all!). Then he must have arranged his transfer to the Discovery, the only ship besides the Glenn that could bring him back into his universe. We may never learn how he accomplished that, considering that Starfleet captains are ordered to take command and can't pick a ship for themselves. He then spent a couple of months, trying to get accustomed to the Prime Universe, always in the danger that someone or something could blow the whistle. At one point he finally had the chance to get hold of Michael Burnham although she should be in prison for the rest of her life, and very luckily for him his superiors as well she herself agreed. Discovery went into several battles that he and Burnham barely survived. And speaking of barely surviving something, who says that the traitor Lorca wouldn't have been killed on sight in the Mirror Universe, or tortured to death by an overzealous agony booth operator? Which is what would definitely have happened, had Burnham not synthesized a special analgesic for him. Honestly, his chances to make his stand in any of the two universes as a free man would have been a thousand times better. At least, L'Rell and Voq are not alone any longer with their absurdly unlikely plan to infiltrate the Federation. Lorca and Voq-Tyler not only have in common that they are infiltrators with a far-fetched plan, they also share the cover-up story of suffering from PTSD, which is lazy writing and, as I already mentioned a couple of weeks ago, a disservice to real-life veterans. This makes me additionally angry.
Now that Lorca's true (and evil) nature is known, Discovery has lost another character that we could count on, or at least occasionally. Just like in Voq-Tyler's case, Lorca's past actions have to be re-evaluated, his past pledges of allegiance are nullified, his past expressions of emotion (including his PTSD and his relationship with Cornwell) come across as fake. It's up to me to recall what he did and why he actually did it. The story, in contrast, will grant him easy redemption, should he survive, like it already did with Burnham and may be about to do regarding Tyler and perhaps even Emperor Georgiou. Anyway, if destroying characters and retroactively invalidating everything they represented is what modern television is about (while still keeping the option to rebuild them with a feat like "Darth Vader saved his son in the end"), I don't want Star Trek to be modern. But Discovery is just too keen on being like other TV series, rather than like Star Trek. The writers have forgotten that the viewers need to relate to the characters and to what they stand for. Since hardly anything that Lorca or Tyler ever said or did was genuine, much of the little bit of Starfleet spirit that Discovery still seemed to have was mere lip service. I seriously consider to revise my past reviews of Discovery and my occasional praise for Lorca or for Tyler, because it was a big deception (much like in "it was only a dream" episodes as they are commonly scorned by many fans). I don't mean to say that Star Trek should show humanity as perfect. Picard's stance was wrong a couple of times, but he didn't turn out a Romulan spy. The Borg sneaked Seven of Nine aboard Voyager, still she always remained honest and authentic. Not everyone is always a role model in TOS, TNG or VOY, let alone in DS9, but a starship full of spies and traitors is something unprecedented in the franchise. Not to mention that it is anything but realistic that on the Discovery you can't rely on your comrades, and the most trustworthy person is a convicted mutineer with a tendency to be self-righteous and to overreact.
After the lackluster story of last week's "The Wolf Inside", I like the writing of "Vaulting Ambition" a bit better, even if I consider the countless already mentioned issues with Lorca. The staff's possibly lacking ability to flesh out a story and keep it coherent is not my chief problem with this and the other Mirror episodes anyway. Most errors lie in the very idea of the storyline, and ultimately in the very concept behind Discovery.
"Vaulting Ambition" is easily the darkest and most violent episode of the franchise ever made. The exploding soldier, whose blood sputters across the agony booth, is the kind of graphic violence we have to get used to. This is not a first time in Discovery. But the series crosses a new line when Burnham eats the Kelpien she has unwittingly chosen. (Like most viewers I first thought the Kelpien was Saru. He looked like him. But it would not have made sense anyway, because why would the slave be transferred to the Charon ahead of the much anticipated Burnham and Lorca?) Discovery just wants to be provocative. I wouldn't object so much to it if it didn't happen with the caveat that it's "only" the Mirror Universe. But let's face it. This new Mirror Universe is not the playful place it used to be in the series context of DS9, and to some extent still in the Enterprise double feature "In a Mirror, Darkly". Discovery's version is a lot darker than that. It is dead serious. And it has become an integral part of Discovery, rather than a throwaway version that our characters could simply leave behind with a deep sigh. Discovery finally becomes consequential in a setting where we would least expect it. It is one positive aspect of "Vaulting Ambition" (and a good deal Michelle Yeoh's merit) that despite the silliness of the pompous emperor on her overblown ship we can and have to take her seriously. But as already in the two preceding Mirror episodes, the setting is too much designed to exonerate the "normal" Discovery universe (of which less is left every week, considering what is revealed about Lorca). Every half-way decent person appears like a hero, when pitched against Adolf Hitler. The whole excursion to the Mirror Universe of at least four episodes can barely conceal everything that is rotten in the Discovery Prime Universe.
It is just too obvious how the cruel Terran Empire is designed as a mirror of T'Kuvma's Klingons, rather than of the Prime Universe Federation, and perhaps unwittingly so. Many themes are the same: the huge palace ship, the exaggerated decoration, the constant intriguing, the cannibalism. Even the strange way Emperor Georgiou deals with the traitor Burnham, first inviting her to dinner and then sentencing her to death all of sudden, rings a bell. Kol did essentially the same when he accepted L'Rell into his house, only to let his guards drag her away a few seconds later. And Burnham's survival on the Charon is just as unlikely as L'Rell's on the Sarcophagus Ship. I don't think that Kol's or Emperor Georgiou's actions were ever supposed to make sense, except to let their rule appear as particularly despotic. Just like Voq-Tyler and Mirror Lorca both turned out to be spies on the same ship, the theme of the pompous dictator was simply repeated in an apparent lack of better ideas.
The only interesting part of the episode, and the only one that still reminds me of the Star Trek I love, is the one about Stamets's fantastic voyage through the spore network - and effectively through his own mind. As unrealistic as it may seem, it is both curious and touching to witness how Stamets copes with the loss of Hugh Culber, and how Culber is the key to find a way out. I think Stamets knows himself what happened to him, to the other Stamets and to Culber. But the other Stamets distracts him. Our Stamets makes up Hugh Culber as a person he can trust, as someone who speaks out the truth and who acts as a beacon. I saw it coming that the two versions of Stamets would switch places, and I really thought that our Stamets regained consciousness on Georgiou's ship. Only in the following episode it would be confirmed, to my confusion, that each of the woke up where they belonged. Rewatching the sequence from "Vaulting Ambition", it makes sense that Mirror Stamets says, "He [Prime Stamets] did it.", a statement which I thought referred to Culber. Anyway, despite this small disappointment that arises in retrospect, Stamets's ultimate trip would have made a decent story of its own but it remains only a light-hearted side plot in an overall extremely grim episode. I am glad that Mirror Culber doesn't appear, which would have ruined it for me.
In another side plot, Saru begs L'Rell to help Voq-Tyler in some fashion, without having any control over what she is going to do with the patient. In my opinion, anything but keeping the two prisoners separated is irresponsible. I think it is safe to predict that Saru conjures up a disaster when he allows L'Rell to proceed. She could kill her patient or turn him into a zombie, she could selectively kill the Tyler in Voq-Tyler, she could kill anyone else. I bet we will see the horrific outcome of the procedure in one or two weeks. It almost definitely isn't what the Klingon mourning scream seems to indicate, that the Voq personality is dead. But whatever "unexpected" happens this time, we are supposed to believe it is still all part of L'Rell and Voq's big plan, like everything that already went awry since Voq "gave up everything".
Discovery is marked by bad production design regarding its reimagination of the starships. With the fanboyish übership ISS Charon, the series eventually hits rock bottom. The Charon makes even the USS Vengeance look like a well-considered and well-balanced design with reasonable dimensions. In addition, its boxy shapes with a cheap skin look like put together by a beginner in 3D modeling. We may argue that the design is fitting for the Mirror Universe (considering the mile-long Mirror Negh'Var of DS9), but since this universe has become an integral part of Discovery and is not silly at all, the Charon is a further disservice to the credibility of the technology of the series. The fiery ball in the middle of the ship drives me crazy, whatever its purpose is. And just like everything else in the space of Discovery, the ship appears in neon colors instead of anything we may accept as natural light, making it look even more toy-like than the design is anyway.
It seems the fans love this episode or hate it, there is nothing in between. I enjoyed only a few aspects that were enlightening (everything related to Stamets) or at least entertaining (everything related to Burnham and Georgiou). I was emotionally invested only in the former, though. The episode did cross lines that I have drawn for myself. I felt an urge to disconnect myself from everything that was going on on the ISS Charon, even though I hold Michelle Yeoh in high esteem. She portrays the emperor quite credibly, without overdoing Georgiou's being evil in gestures or grimaces. Sonequa Martin-Green, on the other hand, is not all that convincing in her role as Michael Burnham here, especially in her interaction with the emperor. Michael Burnham is a person who should at least try to remain cool, also because of her Vulcan training, but it looks like she is about to burst out in tears any time. We never see the Mirror character for comparison, still one look into our Burnham's agitated face should realistically blow her cover. I still like Michael Burnham because there has to be some character to cling to when everyone else dies, becomes insane or turns out a traitor. But her trouble touches me a bit less every week anyway, irrespective of the particular problems I have with "Vaulting Ambition".
I hate the very idea of the Mirror Universe as it is used in Discovery. DS9 too had its share of episodes in that universe. The difference is that DS9 was never defined by its own Mirror Universe the way Discovery is by now. No one ever complained that DS9 sucked because of its Mirror Universe episodes, even as they became increasingly silly. The simple reason is that they amount to merely 5 episodes out of 173. It has to end, or what's left of Discovery's assets will be lost. But it will take at least one more episode for me to endure, perhaps the whole rest of this desolate first season.
- No human being from the Mirror Universe was ever shown to be light-sensitive in previous Star Trek series.
- Emperor Georgiou is correct that besides the temporal displacement, another side effect of the Defiant crossing over was that the crew went insane and they began to kill each other.
- Even though the concept of parallel universes is well-known in the Mirror Universe, would it really take just seconds for Georgiou to confirm the quantum signature of the Starfleet badge and to believe Burnham? So much that she would immediately kill several loyal people?
- Moreover, why would Emperor Georgiou execute her Burnham, although she loves her, but spare the parallel Burnham, although she is a definite enemy? There is nothing she can gain from Burnham, until Burnham tells her about the spore drive.
- Georgiou asks Burnham: "Was your Georgiou a woman of honor? Then you have no reason to believe I am not as well." While not a definite error, everything we know about the Mirror Universe and everything that Burnham herself has learned about it is proof of the opposite.
- What kind of a deal does Saru have with L'Rell? Saru asks her to end Voq-Tyler's suffering. Neither of them mentions whether it is about saving Tyler, or rather Voq. Would Saru really let L'Rell proceed with whatever she can do for him?
- L'Rell couldn't have brought the surgery equipment with her when she was captured. Is it so easy to replicate?
- Who is Voq-Tyler? Voq in Tyler's body? This would have left behind Voq's body dead or as an empty shell. It could explain why Culber didn't notice anything unusual about Tyler. Or rather, Tyler in Voq's body? This is what L'Rell's statements sound like, and what will be more or less confirmed two episodes later. But it makes no sense. If a Klingon body is transformed, on a cellular level, to be indistinguishable from a human's, doesn't this mean that there is nothing Klingon left? Wouldn't it be a lot easier to just transplant the brain patterns? The narrative shies away from a definite statement as to what happened to Tyler and Voq.
- So Mirror Lorca came to our universe. He spent months preparing his return together with Michael Burnham. Only to be apprehended and to be put in an agony booth repeatedly, where he could have been killed any time?
- It appears that Emperor Georgiou has never heard of the spore drive until Michael Burnham tells her about it. Her amazement seems genuine, also considering that if she had any idea of it, she could pretend that her scientists (and especially her Stamets) were already working on it. The price for Burnham to return to her universe could be higher. Well, the ISS Charon is very big and Georgiou may not be familiar with every scientist and every project. Still, it is odd and deserves to be clarified next week.
- Remarkable dialogue: "Georgiou." - "You mean Emperor Georgiou." - "Logic tells me she's not the woman that I betrayed. But this feels like a reckoning." - "Your Georgiou is dead. She's a ghost." - "Haven't you ever been afraid of a ghost?" (Burnham and Lorca)
- Remarkable quotes:
- "You've been wrong about everything. There is a god, and she's very very mad at you right now... I totally had you for a second. You can't deny it. You should have seen your face. I mean, our face." (Mirror Stamets, to Stamets)
- "Computer. Play Kasseelian opera. The aria he loves, the one I hate." (Stamets, in the spore network)
- Remarkable facts:
- Mirror Michael Burnham lost her parents in her childhood, just like her Prime Universe counterpart.
- Mirror Stamets had an accident with the spore drive, just like the Prime Universe Stamets, or so he claims.
- Mirror Lorca was somehow responsible for the death of Captain Maddox's sister, Ava.
- Maddox presents Lorca a hypospray with DNA of a Comtaxan parasite from Tonnata VII. It doesn't mix well with human DNA, which he demonstrates on one of Lorca's soldiers, whose body explodes.
Stardate 1834.2: On the ISS Charon, Lorca frees his followers from the agony booths, among them the parallel version of Landry. A fight with the loyal troops of Emperor Georgiou for the control of the ship ensues. Lorca apprehends the parallel Stamets, who betrayed him and apparently ruined his coup. Stamets has to agree to help Lorca, for a chance to stay alive. He launches a bioweapon that kills many of Georgiou's soldiers. Lorca makes a shipwide announcement that his people are taking control of the Empire, but he advises them not to touch Michael Burnham, to whom he is still attached. Burnham escapes from the throne room and tries to find a way to contact the Discovery. On the Discovery, Stamets and Tilly are concerned about the state of the mycelium network that is dying because the Charon's engine core, the "central orb", taps it for power. Without the spore network, all life in all universes may perish. Lorca and Stamets set up a trap for Emperor Georgiou, in which all of her guards are killed and she can only escape by means of an emergency transport. In the throne room, Lorca celebrates his victory and kills Stamets, as he doesn't need him any longer. Acting Captain Saru and his crew seek a way to repair the spore network, but the only viable method would be to target the heavily shielded central orb of the Charon with a photon torpedo, boosted by the whole mycelium supplies of the Discovery. This would not only cost all the spores that Stamets would need to take back the Discovery to its universe, the ship wouldn't survive the blast in the first place. Saru is not content with this no-win scenario. He motivates the crew to come up with something better. Contacting the Discovery and learning of the plan, Burnham agrees to take down the shield around the central orb. She finds Emperor Georgiou in her hiding place and convinces her to work together to defeat Lorca, by giving him what he wants. Meanwhile on the Discovery, Stamets and Tilly come up with the idea to use the ship's warp drive as an additional protection against the explosion. They prepare to attack and wait for Burnham to disable the shield. Burnham appears in the throne room with Georgiou as her "prisoner" for Lorca. As the Discovery approaches, Burnham and Georgiou assault Lorca's people. When only Lorca is still alive, Burnham spares his life, but Georgiou does not hesitate to kill him with her sword. Burnham takes down the shield. Georgiou vows to stay behind to allow Burnham to escape, as Lorca's troops are about to storm the throne room. But Burnham arranges for Georgiou to be beamed back with her. The Discovery destroys the central orb, the mycelium network begins to regenerate but Stamets does not manage to control the spore drive. Only when he remembers Culber's words from his stay in the network, he intuitively finds a way out. The Discovery arrives in its own universe. But it is nine months too late, and the Klingons appear to have won the war.
I didn't expect much from "What's Past Is Prologue", except that, perhaps, it would end Discovery's increasingly exasperating stay in the Mirror Universe. The past three episodes were marked by a lot of action, but they got lost in absurd plot contrivances, among which the "surprising" revelations (Tyler is Voq, Georgiou is the Emperor, Lorca is Mirror Lorca) are just the tip of the iceberg. Also, as the cruelty and negativity of the story reached its peak in last week's "Vaulting Ambition", I felt emotionally detached from the characters' struggles, and ultimately from the whole series.
"What's Past Is Prologue" fares a bit better in this regard. But one of the episode's more important merits simply is that it fulfills my expectation and takes back the Discovery to our universe. This outcome reconciles me a bit with the course of the story, which once again largely lacks intelligent and plausible twists, let alone depth of the characters. It is a seesaw power struggle between two supervillains like in a pulp story, with their minions as utter cannon fodder, and with Michael Burnham caught in the middle. She survives because of her Vulcan martial arts skills, which she can prove against vastly superior forces twice in the episode. It seems nothing happens just once in the series as of late. But most notably she benefits from the fact that both supervillains are smitten with her and would not kill her (at least occasionally in Georgiou's case, depending on her mood). This constitutes another unlikely doubling of themes. We could give this episode the alternate title "Everybody Loves Michael", which perhaps is applicable to the whole series just as well. Burnham also uses the trick to present a "prisoner" for the second time, only that the roles of Georgiou and Lorca are switched now. Maybe this doubling is not as lame as the other instances, as it can pass as symbolic (as a "Mirror" of the first time). But it is anything but credible that she succeeds yet again.
I have to concede that despite the several unlikely twists that save her life, Burnham's actions and decisions make sense in her own mindset. Lorca has betrayed her, he has been lying to her all along, he has used her for his own despicable goals. Her instinct tells her that he is her enemy, although he ultimately fails to provide a proof that he is any more evil than Georgiou. Emperor Georgiou, on the other hand, is at least a bit like her Prime Universe counterpart, like the captain whom she let down. I didn't give it too much weight, but now I see that the remark about her reckoning at the beginning of "Vaulting Ambition" foreshadowed what would happen. It makes sense for Michael Burnham to seek an alliance with Georgiou, because she always wants to get everything right, even in the wrong universe. It fits the image that she does not give Lorca the well-deserved "Vulcan hello" in Georgiou's presence the end, although it may also be seen as a rather contrived ploy for her to keep a clean slate. For all she's been through in this desolate universe and the many that died at her hand in combat, it wouldn't matter if she killed him too. Regarding her beaming over with Georgiou, I saw that coming, and I think it's one of the few nice twists, although it adds another prisoner to the Discovery (besides L'Rell and Voq-Tyler) that the story may have problems to deal with. Somehow I have the impression that L'Rell and Voq-Tyler (who are discreetly absent from this episode) are up to something to happen until the season finale, but I have no idea what Emperor Georgiou may still be useful for.
The story leaves the Mirror Universe in disarray. However, I never cared for any Mirror Universe story since the early DS9 outings, and it is no different with DIS. It appears the writers didn't care either. Despite all the efforts to give it more seriousness than before in Star Trek, their new iteration of the Mirror Universe lacks depth, it lacks diversity, it lacks logic or any sort of bigger plan. So Discovery finally leaves this throwaway version of itself behind, but not without having suffered damage. There is damage to the overall coherence and credibility of the series, which had just reached a point where the setting and the characters were reasonably well introduced. Moreover, "Into the Forest I Go" was the first episode where the Starfleet spirit seemed to be present in more than just phrases. But now Lorca and Tyler, two very human characters, are gone for good, and leave many of the relationships and the trust that has been built in shatters. (At least, I firmly assume that Tyler will never come back as the one he used to be.)
Saru is more optimistic than I am about the future of Discovery. I cherish the way he motivates the crew to work harder in order to escape from the Mirror Universe, and how he, as a caring captain, invites them to make suggestions. It is the first time that Detmer, Rhys, Airiam and Owosekun say more than something like "Yes, captain." Saru doesn't believe in no-win scenarios. That sounds like a certain other Starfleet captain of his era. He thinks there are always possibilities. I hope and expect that what he says is more than another series of phrases. I take it as a promise that his crew will be less dysfunctional and more Star Trek again - at least in the second season.
It is good in this regard to see how well Stamets and Tilly work together, although it is just in a few brief scenes. Stamets connects himself to the spore network again, and he has a lot of trouble controlling it. This is no surprise at all, considering that the spore drive is activated as the ship is riding the wake of the explosion, with its warp drive activated, while the network is regenerating. Stamets accomplishes a miracle when he manages to find the right exit in spite of everything, only listening to Culber's voice in his mind. It is very satisfying how Culber is somehow still with Stamets and is useful after his death, although it doesn't feel realistic at all. Also, Stamets learned to control the spore drive by intuition, rather than by intellect, already in "Choose Your Pain". There is nothing really different about what he does in "What's Past Is Prologue".
The biggest disappointment about this episode is Lorca, and on every conceivable level. Some fans expected Mirror Lorca to be revealed as a freedom fighter, as someone who unites all races of his universe against the evil emperor. He could have been a noble exception among his kind, also considering that these exceptions will exist in the 24th century. Actually, the humans of the DS9 Mirror Universe are all chastened after their empire's downfall, quite unlike the power-hungry humans of Discovery who would never learn a lesson about humanity (pun intended). But this is not the fault of DIS because TOS and ENT already set the tone, and I certainly don't complain that the new series sticks to canon here. Anyway, it is definitely a missed chance. With Lorca as another one-dimensional evil overlord, there was no other option but to kill off his character. What's worse, Emperor Georgiou and her rule was already established as a "xenophobic", "racist", "fascistic", "oppressive" in Burnham's words, the harshest description possible. Georgiou did absolutely nothing to redeem herself, except perhaps being kind to Burnham for some time, which Lorca tried as well. So, by the logic of this story, Lorca just has to be "super-xenophobic", and so on. This implicit over-exaggeration is absurd, especially since he never gets the opportunity to put his plans into practice anyway.
Well, Lorca holds a speech to that end, in which he labels Georgiou's rule as too friendly towards other races, and he ends with a plea to "make the Empire glorious again". A certain real-world leader loves to say something similar, but what bothers me more is that it is the same theme as T'Kuvma's in "The Vulcan Hello", and another instance where themes simply repeat in the Mirror Universe, without any new spin on it. Overall, Lorca is already the fourth cruel ruler to be overthrown in the course of just 13 episodes, and the third to be killed. Good Star Trek never needed villains and their power struggles as main themes, but Discovery abounds with them.
It is also a pity for the series to lose Jason Isaacs. It currently looks like he will not reappear as the Prime Lorca, who likely died in the Mirror Universe, although we can't tell for sure. I liked Isaacs's performance, and especially his subtle swings of mood felt authentic and added to the mystery about Lorca. It is a pity that it all has no significance in retrospect, other than that Captain Lorca must have been an accomplished actor just as well.
"What's Past Is Prologue" does not turn out quite as disagreeable as last week's "Vaulting Ambition", although its story as well as several characters are just as ostensibly dark yet shallow. But the episode includes sparks of hope, coming from Tilly, Stamets and most notably Saru, who revive the Starfleet spirit on the ship. Here's to hope that Discovery will remember that it is supposed to be Star Trek in the remaining two episodes, and in the second season.
However, as the episode title already gave away, the Discovery crew first needs to repair the timeline before the series can move on - unless the makers end the season with a cliffhanger and decide that it wouldn't be so bad to keep everything about the Klingon victory as it is. There is also the unanswered question of what happened to the ISS Discovery. Captain Tilly's ship may be still in the Prime Universe, if the two Discoveries really switched places. And what is the deal with the spore that conspicuously entered Tilly's body?
- We now know what brought Lorca to our universe in the first place. It was a simple ion storm that interfered with the transporter. This is exactly what happened in TOS: "Mirror, Mirror". It is the original method to cross over, and a nice nod to the TOS episode.
- The whole crew of the Discovery have extensive first-hand experiences in the Mirror Universe. Yet, the phenomenon will be totally unknown when Kirk, McCoy, Scotty and Uhura materialize on the ISS Enterprise.
- Although we now have a plausible explanation of how and why Lorca arrived in our universe, the rest of his unlikely story that I outlined in last week's review will forever remain a mystery.
- Emperor Georgiou conveniently has a only a few guards with her when she runs into Lorca's trap. Vice versa, Lorca too has only a handful of people that protect him in and around the throne room. Neither of the two seems to have any reinforcements on other ships either.
- How can Stamets and Tilly calculate that the whole spore supply would be just enough to boost the explosion of the orb and heal the spore network, that there would be neither 50% too little of it, nor 50% left for the jump home? They can have hardly have remotely sufficient data on everything involved in this extremely complex and, well, incalculable, plan. In a similar vein, how can they predict that the ship will barely survive the explosion, even with the warp drive activated? Well, it's Star Trek and in a certain movie a certain person too made an educated guess, still it feels like a stretch that they make any predictions.
- Last week, Emperor Georgiou didn't seem to know anything about the spore drive. The reason may be that it does not exist on the ISS Discovery. But her own ship, the Charon, is powered by a very similar technology. Well, Georgiou may not be so much into technology, and perhaps she even feigned ignorance because she was interested in Michael Burnham staying in her universe in the first place.
- Emperor Georgiou agrees to Michael Burnham's plan to take down the shielding of her ship's engine core without asking any questions. Well, Lorca is taking over the ship, getting rid of him is her main concern, and she has already run out of options. And once again, besides resignation, the reason may be that she is attached to Michael Burnham and would do anything she suggests.
- Why doesn't Lorca kill the defenseless Georgiou when she is lying on the floor, in front of her throne? It is clearly visible she is not yet dead. Why does he turn his back on her so she can stab him?
- Where does the "war map" of the Klingon victory come from? There is no Federation left that could transmit such a map, and the Klingons most likely wouldn't share it. Well, it could be based on sensor data, but it's a stretch that these would span many sectors.
- Remarkable quotes:
- "I'm living proof that fate is real." (Lorca)
- "It is well-known that my species has the ability to sense the coming of death. I do not sense it today. I may not have all the answers. However, I do know that I'm surrounded by a team I trust. The finest a captain could ever hope to command. Lorca abused our idealism. Make no mistake. Discovery is no longer Lorca's. She is ours. And today will be her maiden voyage. We have a duty to perform and we will not accept a no-win scenario. You have your orders. On your way." (Saru - I wish I could share his optimism!)
- "I was just thinking about everyone who's ever said that victory felt empty when it was attained. What a bunch of idiots they were." (Lorca)
- Remarkable scene: Michelle Yeoh's fight as Emperor Georgiou against Lorca. It is her leg that kicks his head when he is standing right in front of her!
- Remarkable fact: Mirror Lorca was on Priors World to find allies in his fight when his ship, the ISS Buran, was attacked by the ISS Charon. He was beamed back, but an ion storm interfered with the transporter beam, so he ended up in the Prime Universe. It is, however, not clear what happened to Prime Universe Lorca. By the logic of the Mirror Universe, he was being beamed at the same time, and the two switched places. So did our Lorca simply die on the Mirror Buran?
Acting Captain Saru confines Emperor Georgiou to the guest quarters. He asks Michael Burnham to talk to the now restored Tyler, but she refuses. A Starfleet ship approaches the Discovery, and a boarding party materializes on the bridge. Admiral Cornwell appears with Sarek, who mind-melds with Saru to assure his identity. It turns out that the USS Discovery was believed destroyed by the Klingons, but that the ship was actually the ISS Discovery from the other universe. In the nine months that the USS Discovery was gone, the Klingons have carried out attacks on numerous and often civilian targets and have conquered 20% of the Federation's territory. But rather than following a coordinated plan, after the death of Kol the single Klingon houses compete with each other for the control of the Federation's assets. The Discovery proceeds to Starbase 1 near the Sol system. But the starbase has been occupied by the Klingons, and all Federation personnel killed. Cornwell orders a course away from the starbase. She seeks the advice of L'Rell, who tells her that the Klingons will never stop their attacks until they are conquered. Burnham asks Georgiou how she defeated the Klingons, and learns that it requires to hit them on their homeworld Qo'noS. The crew devises a plan to get the tactical information about Qo'noS by hiding the ship in the volcanic caves underneath the planet's surface. In order to obtain the spores required to jump to Qo'noS, Stamets plants the remaining crops on a so far uninhabited moon in the Veda system, and stimulates their growth electromagnetically. Sarek forges some kind of alliance with Georgiou, promising her freedom in exchange for her support against the Klingons. He says goodbye to Burnham and leaves the ship. Burnham finally comes around and talks to Tyler, but only to tell him that their relationship is over. Once the required spores are collected, the new captain of the Discovery takes her seat - Philippa Georgiou.
"The War Without, The War Within" can be considered a filler episode leading up to the hopefully more exciting season finale. This may explain but does not excuse that the story lacks cohesion and lacks a climax. In many ways, it feels like a setback to "Context is for Kings", like a second pilot episode. It certainly has the long exposition in common with a pilot, in which Cornwell seems to tell us the complete history of the war with the Klingons. Furthermore, last week Captain Saru announced that the ship would go on a second maiden voyage, and the crew worked together with one mind for the first time in the series. But after another change of command a good deal of the new spirit is lost again. Cornwell is unwelcome as the ship's new commander, and there is just too much much unfinished business everywhere.
Especially regarding its characters and their relationships, Discovery runs in circles instead of trying to move on. Only Lorca is missing, but somehow I have the impression that he too will come back, contrary to my conviction that he had been killed by the writers even before he actually died. Anyway, after the return to the "good" universe, the series apparently scrapes together everyone left in terms of likable characters. Sarek and Cornwell reappear to that end, Voq-Tyler is all Tyler again, and Emperor Georgiou even fills in for her Prime Universe counterpart! No one is gone for good in the Discovery universe, they can all be revived any time, in some universe, with some reasoning. Somehow we can pretend that everything is fine with everyone. Maybe this is not the fault of Discovery in the first place. Star Trek has many precedences of characters returning from the dead or returning to duty as normal after extreme transformations. Discovery, however, is serialized television. The makers of the series pride themselves for being consequential, for not pushing a built-in reset button. But Discovery handles this self-imposed restriction rather more than less casually than previous Star Trek incarnations.
As impressive Shazad Latif's performance as the remorse-ridden Tyler is, I don't care as much for the character as I previously did. There is no realistic way that he could find redemption among the very people that he betrayed and hurt, especially Stamets and Burnham. Tyler has lost his purpose in the series. He reminds me a bit of Ensign Suder of Star Trek Voyager, who was confined to his quarters after killing a crewmate and died fighting the Kazon when he eventually wanted to "do something for the ship". But knowing the Discovery writers, I somehow doubt that Voq is really dead, and that he and L'Rell won't stir up trouble again. Trouble that the Discovery crew invites by their fixation on these two and on Georgiou.
In many ways, Tyler is the outcast among the crew that Burnham was in "Context is for Kings", which is another clear parallel to the pilot episode. The scene when he walks through the mess hall, and everyone tries to ignore him, is very reminiscent of the according one when Burnham first came aboard. Also, in both cases it is Tilly who takes the first step and talks to the outsider. Although I am not fond of the doubling of events that has become a pattern in Discovery as of late, this works for me. It feels right. If my reservations about Tyler's true character and loyalty are unwarranted and, for once, everything really is as it seems, he deserves the chance that Tilly is willing to give him. If I were on the Discovery, and if Tyler had not hurt me personally, I might eventually come to terms with him, albeit not as quickly as Tilly.
On the other hand, I can understand Michael Burnham very well that she doesn't want to talk to Tyler, and that she has no ambition to be instrumental in his resocialization. She has been hurt just too much by him, or by the Klingon inside him. Even though she clearly recognizes the parallels between his way to find himself and her own continuing struggle with her nature, there is nothing that connects her any longer with him. They do not complement each other any more.
I can see the intention to let Admiral Cornwell appear as very determined at first, only to show her uncertainty after the starbase has been destroyed. However, her actions and statements don't always make sense. The following is a case in point. She and Sarek are aboard the Discovery for the debriefing of the ship's crew for at most 30 minutes. Probably even much less, considering that the ship is not at warp, and she urges Stamets to activate the spore drive to get to Starbase 1 as fast as possible. They have just learned of the existence of the Mirror Universe. Inflamed with rage about Lorca's betrayal, Cornwell phasers his fortune cookies. But only a few minutes later, after her recount of the events since the Discovery's disappearance, she gives the order that the crew has to remain silent about the existence of the Mirror Universe. She makes it sound as if she had pondered about it. And Sarek, who agrees with her, insinuates that the two have already discussed the issue, which can't be true.
I don't like Sarek's involvement in this episode anyway. As already mentioned, his role is gratuitous. He was included in my view because someone thought the series needed to bring back all the familiar and possibly popular faces. Yet, there is nothing that would really require his presence, except for rebutting the rather far-fetched theory that the crew of the Discovery may be impostors. Well, I admit I was never very fond of James Frain's re-interpretation of the character, but so far I envisioned that Sarek may change in the ten years before TOS, and that the story about the Discovery and Burnham may have to do with it. However, I simply can't imagine the Sarek I used to know as a military advisor, who suggests to shoot first or to attack Qo'noS without having sufficient details, or as a scheming person who makes a deal with a prisoner behind the backs of the crew. On the bright side, I like the father-daughter scenes with Michael Burnham, which make up for their stupid "katra fights" in "Lethe". It is a nice touch that Sarek of all people gives Burnham advice regarding her love for Tyler: "For what greater source of peace exists than our ability to love our enemy?" On the other hand, I don't understand the foreshadowing that it is their last goodbye. We all know that the series would not work any longer without Michael Burnham, so there is no point to it.
What bothers me most about this episode is that several character interactions don't make sense and were apparently included only to involve everyone and try to give everyone's involvement a meaning. Realistically, Burnham and Georgiou have nothing to talk about. But Burnham asks Georgiou for advice on the Klingons, although the former emperor comes from a wholly different universe and can't be trusted in any matter. Several of my predictions from last week's review were wrong, but I think I hit the nail with my assessment that the writers can't handle Mirror Georgiou. She has no place in the Prime Universe, so Burnham has to give her an unwarranted significance (that Sarek even enhances when he forges a secret deal with her). Practically the same happens at about the same time in the ship's brig, when Cornwell asks L'Rell what the Klingons are up to. She has no reason to speak to the Klingon woman (other than showing that she is still alive), but like Burnham she somehow expects to learn something from her prisoner. L'Rell has no idea what happened in the past nine months, and even if she knew something more relevant than "We will never stop fighting!", she would have no reason to tell it. The story makes it look like talking to Georgiou and to L'Rell is the big deal, the key to defeating the Klingons. The plan to grow the spores on the planet and to survey Qo'noS from underneath the surface, on the other hand, seems to come out of thin air and comes across as routine.
On a more technical note, there is something annoying about the way that other ships suddenly pop up out of nowhere in Discovery, as if there were no long-range sensors. We may make up excuses why the Discovery couldn't detect the admiral's ship in time. But it happens all the time in the series and doesn't exactly help to justify that the Discovery has any kind of tactical advantage because of the spore drive. Moreover, like already the two last times that a ship suddenly appeared, this ship isn't even shown, as if the CGI budget were not sufficient to visualize it.
"The War Without, The War Within" is an episode that just does what is necessary to wrap up the Mirror Universe excursion and to prepare the series finale. Rather than creating an arc of suspense in the episode itself, the story gets lost in gratuitous talks involving gratuitous characters. A focus on the crew of the Discovery, without Sarek, Cornwell, L'Rell and Mirror Georgiou, would have served the purpose of this penultimate episode much better. "The War Without, The War Within" has its moments, especially regarding Burnham and Tilly, Burnham and Sarek, Burnham and Tyler. But the story is uneven like in the early episodes of the series, and it ends with an absurdity that words can't describe.
- Nobody knows of the Mirror Universe because Cornwell orders the crew of the Discovery to delete all records and never to talk about it. So the Mirror Universe doesn't exist, just like Principal Skinner is his mother's son.
- Discovery tells two different stories about the Federation's war with the Klingons. The first is the dramatic one, the one needed to emphasize how desperate Starfleet is. The Klingons are close to win the war, they have destroyed much of the fleet, they have conquered 20% of the Federation's territory, they slaughter civilians wherever they meet them. The second one is the version to fend off the critics of the series, and to feed the bean counters among the fans with casualty figures that are low enough to be reconciled with canon. A few thousand dead here, another few thousand killed there. Cornwell mentions incidents with thousands of deaths, not millions. In this version, it doesn't sound like the Klingons commit more than occasional terrorist acts, if we compare her figures to the enormous casualties of WWII and several later wars. So is the Federation really on the verge of being extinguished, or is the war insignificant enough to be just a side note ten years later? The writing was always double-faced in this regard, but it never becomes as obvious as in this episode.
- Cornwell enlisted Sarek's support to find out who's aboard the Discovery. But who did they expect to find there? The Federation knows nothing about the existence of a parallel universe. Temporal phenomena, on the other hand, are not unheard of. So why the suspicion that the Discovery is a ship full of evil clones? Cornwell mentions the danger of Klingon infiltrators. But did she really expect to find a replica of a destroyed Starfleet ship, full of Klingon impostors?
- Stamets says that Starbase 1 is "100 AUs from Earth, and 1 light-year from our current position". There are two problems resulting from this statement. The first is that the Discovery, whose warp drive is still down at the time, conveniently ended up in the direct vicinity of Earth (100 AU is only a small fraction of a light-year). This is very unlikely. I don't think the last known position of the Charon was so close to Mirror Earth, and there was no way for Stamets to control the jump that precisely either. In fact, at the end of "What's Past Is Prologue", Saru was relieved to learn that the ship was in the Alpha Quadrant at all, and not somewhere else in the galaxy. Moreover, it is strange that no one bothered to mention: "By the way, we're just one light-year from Earth." The issue becomes a major error when we see that Starbase 1 is in orbit of an Earth-like planet. There is definitely no such planet 100 AU from Earth!
- The fact that the Discovery is so very close to Starbase 1 also raises the question why Cornwell wants to get there using the spore drive in the first place. A normal warp jump would be absolutely sufficient. The reason that Cornwell cites for using the spore drive is that going to warp is dangerous because the whole sector is swarming with Klingons. Yet, she waits for the end of the debriefing to give the command, as if floating in open space were safer than being at warp!
- So the best way to keep the Klingons from destroying the whole Federation and killing billions is to attack Qo'noS? While Earth and every other Federation planet is without starships to defend them? Are the people on the Discovery out of their minds? Realistically, the Klingon warriors out there that were not able to protect their homeworld would be even more determined to retaliate and destroy the Federation. They would unite in a coordinated devastating attack on Earth. The idea that the Klingons might cease their attacks and return home to mourn the dead once their homeworld has been targeted is just as flawed as that of the "Vulcan hello". Well, the attack on Qo'noS may make sense if it could be done without the need to pass many Klingon defense lines, and without leaving Federation planets unprotected for a long time. In other words, the Discovery would be alone on such a mission.
- Is there anything that Emperor Georgiou of the Mirror Universe could know better about the Klingons of the Prime Universe than anyone else aboard the ship? Is there any reason to believe that the Prime Klingons have so much in common with the ones from the Mirror Universe? Is there any reason for Burnham, and once again for Sarek, to ask her for help in the first place? Is there any reason to trust her in any way? And yes - I did consider the possible symbolic significance that Captain Georgiou did survive. Only that it wouldn't impress the Klingons at all. T'Kuvma didn't consider her a worthy enemy, so why does anyone assume that Captain Georgiou's return is any good? And why is it that the crew apparently isn't apprised of Georgiou's true identity? Several people have seen her, word must have got around.
- Remarkable scene: Admiral Cornwell vaporizes the bowl with Lorca's fortune cookies.
- Remarkably cheesy scene: Emperor Georgiou orders the "slave" Saru to get on his knees, only to learn that he is the captain. Well, at least she didn't say, "Oh, dinner is coming."
- Remarkable facts:
- Voq underwent a procedure that the Klingons refer to as "species reassignment protocol" and that Starfleet medicine does not fully understand.
- On Stardate 4789.6, the Klingons launched hyperthermic charges at Kelfour VI, burning off the atmosphere and killing 11,000 civilians instantly. On Stardate 4851.5, a cloaked raider tailed the USS Saratoga into the spacedock at Starbase 22 and ignited its antimatter supply in a suicide mission. Similar assaults were carried out at Starbases 19 and 12. One third of the fleet was lost. Research outposts at the border colonies of Nivalla, Septra and Iridin were destroyed. 20% of the Federation territory was lost to the Klingons.
- Starbase 1 was conquered by the House of D'Ghor. The Discovery scans 274 Klingon lifesigns, but no one of the 80,000 people on the station survived.
- Enterprise NX-01 under Captain Archer was the last Starfleet ship to visit Qo'noS, a century ago.
- Dr. Pollard takes over the treatment of Tyler.
The Discovery, now under the command of "Captain" Georgiou, is en route to Qo'noS, to chart the planet for a large-scale attack. Burnham is more than skeptical about the motives of her superiors but she obeys their orders. Georgiou interrogates L'Rell the Terran way. The Klingon woman, however, does not reveal anything about a possible access point to the caves on Qo'noS that would allow a drone to map the whole planet. Tyler tells Georgiou and Burnham of Molor's old temple underneath an Orion embassy and trade outpost on Qo'noS. Dressed as human traders, the three and Tilly beam down and split up to find the entrance to that temple. While Georgiou seeks pleasure in a brothel, Tyler and Burnham try to find out something from the Klingons. Burnham is appalled how much Tyler remembers and lives out his Klingon side. But he eventually manages to identify followers of Molor that may know the temple. Tilly consumes a drug that renders her unconscious. When she wakes up and checks whether the drone is still in the case she is carrying, she discovers that it is actually a hydro bomb. Georgiou takes the bomb, heads for the cave and launches it. Once she activated the detonator, the resulting volcanic activity would obliterate the planet's whole surface. Back on the Discovery, Burnham contacts Admiral Cornwell to protest, also in the name of her crew. She beams down again and convinces Georgiou not to ignite the bomb. Tyler appears with L'Rell, and the detonator is encoded to her bioprints. Tyler decides to join L'Rell. With the power to destroy Qo'noS in her hands, L'Rell gets the Klingon warlords to unite again and cease their attacks on the Federation. On Earth, Burnham is pardoned by the Federation President and reinstated to her rank as commander. The ship is going to pick up a new captain at Vulcan, when another Starfleet ship sends a distress call - the USS Enterprise NCC-1701.
I expected this season finale to be breathless, to lead all the way from a conflict with Mirror Georgiou over a fierce battle with the Klingons to some sort of stalemate that would require the Klingons to negotiate with Starfleet. Perhaps a bit like in "What You Leave Behind". The lack of action in "Will You Take My Hand?" may be disappointing. But it isn't so bad in hindsight that the writing doesn't quite follow the seemingly predetermined path. I like the surprisingly many calm moments. I especially enjoy the scenes with the landing party on Qo'noS. It may not have been the right time in the series but it is a welcome change how our crew explores a strange new world, also because it features more natural and believable Klingons than the ones we were shown so far in the series.
Overall, however, "Will You Take My Hand?" just achieves its principal goal to bring the Klingon war to an end, and to lay the ground for a new, hopefully more optimistic storyline in the second season. Just like in "The War Without, The War Within", the story suffers from incomprehensible actions and decisions of the characters, the two most obvious being to put Mirror Georgiou of all people in charge of a mission to save the Federation and to trust in L'Rell of all people to use her power to end the war. The second important purpose of this season finale is to dispose of its used up characters, or give them a new perspective.
L'Rell never received any notable character development in the whole series. She suffered one defeat after another, she was captured and beaten up several times. She spent the whole second chapter of the season in Discovery's brig. And yet, we were supposed to believe that she was up to something greater. L'Rell finally achieves what she always wanted. She becomes the leader of the Klingons and follows in T'Kuvma's footsteps. But she earns all this gratuitously, only at the mercy of her human captors and of the bomb detonator she is carrying. Her position as a leader is just as undeserved as T'Kuvma's, who united his people with hollow phrases in "The Vulcan Hello". Everything about her story is totally dissatisfying. Well, better luck next season! It seems very likely that she will return.
It was obvious to me that Tyler would not stay aboard the ship, although I would rather have expected him to betray Burnham. Actually, I was only waiting for him to become all Klingon again when he played and laughed together with members of his species, and we could see the worries grow in Burnham's face. Perhaps it was a successful red herring that he didn't fulfill my expectations and didn't switch sides yet again, or I may only have become too apprehensive about the writing of Discovery. Anyway, when Tyler tells Burnham he would leave with L'Rell, it doesn't come as a surprise. Although last week's episode initiated his resocialization, he may not want to be among humans any longer, among the people he hurt so much. And just as I thought about my expectation that "Will You Take My Hand?" could have been like "What You Leave Behind", at least here is a clear parallel, thinking of how Odo returned to his people. It has already been confirmed that Tyler will be back for season 2, most likely not on the Discovery.
Emperor Georgiou is definitely the least prolific of the three characters that just had to leave the Discovery. She never had any purpose in the Prime Universe. The way that was chosen to involve her is gratuitous. Starfleet gives her the command of the ship and pretends she is the Prime Georgiou, while still allowing her to have fun with violence and sex (so it wouldn't get too boring and because it's deemed necessary to always remind us of who she really is). It is the same doppelgänger ploy as it is customary in the Mirror Universe, only with a reversed sign. That alone is not the problem. As I already predicted last week, there is no reason to let her lead the team in the first place. It feels so wrong. But Michael Burnham is the only one who notices that and takes offense. What's worse, Georgiou's conduct serves to further whitewash the Discovery Prime Universe, considering that the involvement of Sarek and Cornwell in her evil plan is only a side note in the story and has no consequences for them in light of the happy ending that Burnham brings about against her orders. That said, I must admit that I enjoyed Michelle Yeoh's performance as Mirror Georgiou in spite of everything. Her cold-blooded attitude is refreshingly different, her lines are priceless. Still, I am not going to miss her. I would prefer not to see her again, for the sake of what's left of the series' credibility. I do miss Yeoh's Prime Georgiou, who was unwisely killed off.
I already complained about Sarek being a schemer and a warmonger on Discovery. We can now add "proponent of genocide" to the list. Discovery has ultimately ruined a once revered character.
Tilly is once again a positive surprise among the cast. And once more she provides a kind of comic relief that doesn't feel out of place. It is hilarious how she reacts on Mirror Georgiou, and her drug trip (with Clint Howard!) turns out apt, although for a moment it looks like she could make a complete idiot of herself.
It is clear that the conflict between Burnham and Emperor Georgiou in "Will You Take My Hand?" echoes the one Burnham and Captain Georgiou had in "The Vulcan Hello". Burnham has switched sides and now puts the principles of Starfleet above her fears, and ultimately above the instinct of self-preservation. I like the symbolism of this aspect, but I don't think it was worth the otherwise unwarranted participation of Mirror Georgiou. And considering that Cornwell and Sarek were close to committing a genocide, the happy ending doesn't sit well with me anyway. I am all with Burnham regarding the right course of action. I am glad that it is her who delivers the speech about the principles of the Federation, because if Sarek or Cornwell had done it, it would have been hypocrisy. Still, it comes across much like self-praise, seeing how Michael Burnham knows everything better than anyone else, and has the superior morale on top of that.
In spite of her role as Discovery's Mary Sue character, Burnham is the only one in the series I could really relate to, at least most of time. She made a stupid mistake in the prologue, but in the further course of Discovery she represented reason and decency in a universe that seemed to be full of assholes, spies, traitors and maniacs. Well, there are also Saru and Tilly, and Stamets saw an overall positive development. But they all usually shied away from sticking to principles and from making decisions for themselves or (in the case of Saru) also for others. Rather than exploring the potential of the few "good" characters, Discovery was just too fond of its shady figures and their power to dominate and manipulate, which unfortunately includes Sarek. And as much as Burnham tried to bring benevolence and justice to this universe, the one thing that also belongs to Star Trek she could never relay is optimism. As hard as the series once again tries to push it, to bring the first season to a conciliatory conclusion, Burnham is not the person who could motivate me. She neither manages to show how great the Federation is in-universe, nor does she give me hope that the second season may be any more like the good old Star Trek.
The appearance of Captain Pike's USS Enterprise was quite obviously meant as a beacon, to assure us that everything will be better and more traditional in the second season. But aside from my criticism of the overdone reimagination of the ship, I can't see anything but cheap fan service in it. In my view, it is a crossover of the kind that already ruined ENT: "These Are The Voyages" (the notorious "Valentine to the fans"). My apprehension may be premature. But I just don't want to see the original Enterprise, reimagined or not, in a series that otherwise acts like TOS had never existed. In this regard, it may be even unusually honest of Discovery that the Enterprise was redesigned from TOS- to DIS-style. But this only deepens the rift that Discovery has opened between itself and the rest of the franchise, and also between the fans. I dread the insistence of DIS fans that the "real" Enterprise in TOS should look like the DIS ship and the demands to retcon it accordingly, and I don't think my reaction will be friendly.
Although I like many aspects of "Will You Take My Hand?", the whole storyline is so messed up since Discovery's departure to the Mirror Universe that the finale could only do damage control and bring the season to a half-way conciliatory ending. It is beneficial for season 2 that Discovery can leave the Klingon war behind and has abandoned most of the characters that represented the "dark" universe. What Discovery needs in my view is a "reboot of the reboot". It is too late to correct gross mistakes like the Klingon redesign, the unfitting ships and sets or the extended trip to the Mirror Universe, but Discovery could at least begin to explore strange new worlds. Just a suggestion.
- The Orions of Discovery are not reimagined, although the color appears to be pale green now.
- The Klingons in this episode sound and feel much more like the ones from TNG and DS9. In the darkness of the trade outpost, it almost seems we are watching an authentic, non-reimagined Star Trek series. From the outside, the outpost looks a bit like Qo'noS did in Star Trek Enterprise.
- It was to be expected that, unlike Star Trek Enterprise, Discovery would not respect the look of the original USS Enterprise NCC-1701. Their Enterprise is described as an "olive branch to fans concerned about old-school canon". Well, I am such a fan, and to me it is a further slap in the face. Like everything else that the producers deemed dated, the ship was redesigned to fit with the reimagination dictate of the series. The basic proportions of the Constitution class are roughly the same as they were in "The Cage" or in TOS. The shapes of the saucer, the engineering hull and the nacelles were modified to be more streamlined. The neck was shortened. The bridge, the shuttlebay region, the impulse engines, the nacelle pylons and the details on the nacelles are totally different now. Shiny and heavily structured plating was added all over the hull. I'm not saying the ship looks bad now, but the radically different appearance is a further sign that the makers of the series don't care for the assets of Star Trek (let alone for old-school fans). And it is the final nail in the coffin, regarding a possible reconciliation of the reboot ships of Discovery with the existing Starfleet design lineage from TOS to ENT (which, unlike the Klingon redesign, was not a totally hopeless case so far). If not even the Constitution class looks the way it would have to, why should any other ship in the series? Why should I even bother to make up explanations for angular nacelles if there are much more obvious obstacles for the Discovery ships to fit in? I will take care of the Discovery ships. But TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT designs will have precedence in cases of contradiction because they came first and they respected each other. The "new" Constitution class is exemplary in this regard. As far as I am concerned, it has no right to exist outside the Discoveryverse.
- The DIS Mirror characters may not have much in common with those of DS9. But they share the sexual kinkiness that is apparently unfamiliar to Prime Universe characters of any Star Trek incarnation.
- Paris is a skyscraper desert in Discovery's 23rd century. Well, perhaps the city authorities make up their minds and tear down almost all tall buildings surrounding the Eiffel Tower within the next three decades?
- We now know why the spore drive never shows up in Star Trek again. It's because Starfleet has mothballed the technology until they can find a non-human interface. Continuity can be so easy if you simply don't care.
- The same can be said about the memory of Starfleet's desperate fight against the Klingons and the bomb under the surface of Qo'noS. Let's just not talk about it, and everything is fine.
- As I already wrote last week, it is a bad idea of Starfleet to put someone in charge whose nature is in contrast to the principles of the Federation and who can't be trusted. There is no reason why Georgiou would have to lead the vital mission to Qo'noS. All that Starfleet needed from her was the information on how she destroyed Mirror Qo'noS. Cornwell could have dropped the bomb herself, which would have made a lot more sense because the people on the Discovery trusted her. But it is so convenient to hypocritically put the blame on the villain from the Mirror Universe.
- Why would Georgiou expect L'Rell or Voq to be an expert in the geology of their homeworld?
- It is hard to believe that the now xenophobic Klingons would tolerate a so-called embassy with a multicultural trade outpost on their planet where even humans can run around freely.
- Considering that Georgiou is not trustworthy and Tilly is carrying the drone that is essential to the plan, leaving these two alone is a bad idea. I knew it the moment they mentioned to split up.
- Why should the Orion love slaves of all people know something about the Klingon shrine?
- What was the idea behind Sarek's, Cornwell's and Georgiou's original plan? That once their homeworld has been obliterated, killing billions, the Klingon armada that was almost in Earth's orbit would turn around? That the remaining Klingons would shamefully accept their fate?
- What happened to the chain of command? Why does Burnham call the admiral? Is she in command of the ship now?
- Is there a reason to assume that L'Rell would not tell the other leaders something like, "I have the key to destroying Qo'noS. You have to unite in the fight against the filthy Federation"? She may not have been the biggest fan of the war, but she is anything but a peace angel either.
- Remarkable quotes:
- "Scared Kelpien makes for tough Kelpien." (Terran saying)
- "Do not show respect by referring to that green dot as homeworld. Klingons are animals and they don't have homes. Call it Qo'noS or the enemy planet." (Georgiou, to Detmer)
- "I have little interest in what we're scanning. I care what's scanning us." (Georgiou, to Owosekun)
- Remarkable speeches:
- "On the eve of battle, on a cold and windless night, an old general turned to a young soldier. 'Tomorrow,' said the master, 'you will know fear.' The young soldier, who had not yet experienced the agony of war, looked at the general with quizzical eyes: 'How will I know fear if I don't know what it looks like?' The general replied: 'You will know fear because it speaks very fast and it speaks very loud. If that is how fear acts, recognizing it is easy.' But as the young soldier considered the general's advice, she asked the question gagging us now: 'Once I know fear, how do I defeat it?'" (episode intro by Michael Burnham)
- "We are no longer on the eve of battle. Even so I come to ask myself the same question that the young soldier asked the general all those years ago: 'How do I defeat fear?' The general's answer: 'The only way to defeat fear is to tell it no.' No, we will not take shortcuts on the path to righteousness. No, we will not break the rules that protect us from our basest instincts. No, we will not allow desperation to destroy moral authority. I am guilty of all these things. Some say that in life there are no second chances. Experience tells me that this is true, but we can only look forward. We have to be torchbearers, casting the light so we may see our path to lasting peace. We will continue exploring. Discovering new worlds and new civilizations. Yes, that is the United Federation of Planets." (Burnham's speech at the award ceremony)
- Remarkable scenes:
- When Burnham and Georgiou come to Tyler's quarters, he can be seen with a knot that "ties him to his past" when he was on Earth and had a boat. When Tyler and Burnham part ways in the end, he leaves the knot in her hand.
- When Tilly learns that "Captain" Georgiou is actually the emperor, she awkwardly attempts to give her a Terran salute.
- A peeing Klingon. People cataloging "first times" in Star Trek clearly have their fun with this series. Are those two urine streams coming from the same man? I don't want to muse what that means.
- Tilly tastes something delicious on Qo'noS, but spits it out in disgust when she learns that it's a "space whale", a gormagander.
- L'Rell declares herself the leader of the Klingons, and the Klingons laugh just like they did when T'Kuvma did the same in "The Vulcan Hello".
- Remarkable decoration: The seal of the United Federation of planets has the two inscriptions "UFP" and "FPU". The latter obviously stands for "Fédération des planètes unies".
- Remarkable facts:
- Captain Georgiou comes from Pulau Langkawi in Malaysia.
- In the Mirror Universe, Emperor Georgiou and Captain Tilly subjugated the Betazoids and wiped out Mintaka III.
- When Michael Burnham and her family were on the outpost Doctari Alpha, they planned a vacation on Mars. But Michael begged her parents to stay three more days to watch a star go supernova. When the Klingons attacked, her father tried to bar the kitched door, while her mother hid Michael in a cabinet. Her father was killed quickly. The Klingons took their time with her mom. Then they sat down at the kitchen table to have dinner and laugh.
- Centuries ago, when the caldera was active, it was used for live sacrifices to honor Molor. After Molor's defeat against Kahless, the place was built over.
- Taking an extra drink and setting it on fire is a habit of the followers of Molor.
- A Klingon game of dice is called T'Sang, which means "Obliterate them".