![]() | ![]() |
Star Trek Voyager (VOY) Season 2
Season 1 - Season 2 - Season 3 - Season 4 - Season 5 - Season 6 - Season 7
The episode descriptions are given in normal text, my comments in small text. Rating: 0=worst, 10=best (rating system)
The 37's Stardate 48975.1: Voyager discovers an
ancient automobile from Earth adrift in space and an old SOS
signal coming from a nearby planet. Janeway decides to land the
ship, since it is not possible to beam down. The crew discovers
several stasis chambers with humans and releases them, among them flight pioneer
Amelia Earhart, who mysteriously
vanished in 1937. Briefly later a number of human settlers appear, who
live on the planet. Their ancestors have been abducted by the Briori
centuries ago just like Earhart, but have eventually expelled them in a rebellion. Janeway
leaves it to the crew to join the human civilization on the
planet or return to the ship, but eventually all crew members
decide to continue the journey home.

The episode begins with several flaws. First of all, what
should be so strange about iron oxide (=rust) in space? There
could be all kinds of compounds besides pure iron. Moreover, the
truck wasn't really that rusty and was only one year old when
abducted from Earth. Secondly, due to inevitable internal leakage
currents it is impossible that there is enough charge left in a
battery after 400 years. Thirdly, how can a 20th century receiver
pick up a signal sent with a 20th century transmitter over a
distance of many million kilometers? Only the power source of the
aircraft radio was replaced with modern technology.
Fortunately
these inconsistencies are not very important for the story which
is great. Actually, as a two-part episode it would have been a
fantastic season finale and premiere. I would have liked to see
something of the human cities anyway. I would have liked to see
Amelia Earhart fly the ship. I would have liked to see some sort
of love affair, maybe Paris falling in love with a resident
beauty. There was so much potential for more. Anyway, the
episodes is only 45 minutes of which not a single moment is
wasted. It is surprising that Star Trek shows the otherwise
popular "alien abduction" plot for the very first time,
and that it is not mystified like in other sci-fi and mystery
series. The most important outcome of the episode, however, is
that Voyager has been to a hospitable place for the first time
since their arrival in the Delta Quadrant. This is supposed to
boost morale a lot.
Remarkable quote: "The remarkable thing about the humans
on this planet is that they evolved very much like the people on
Earth. Tens of thousands of light-years apart both civilizations
managed to create a world they could be proud of, one where war
and poverty simply don't exist." (Janeway)
Remarkable scene: Tuvok takes cover and pulls his phaser when
the exhaust bangs upon starting the ancient motor.
Remarkable facts: There are currently 152 crew members. -- The
ship goes to blue alert when entering the atmosphere. -- The Briori
planet is Class L - oxygen-argon atmosphere.
Ship landing: #1
Current crew count: 152
Rating: 8
Initiations Stardate 49005.3: Chakotay is alone in a shuttle when he has to destroy an attacking Kazon-Ogla vessel, but he
rescues the pilot, Kar, a teenage Kazon. The two are captured by
the Kazon. As Chakotay is facing his execution and Kar is being despised
for his failure to earn his name in a battle, they escape to a lonely planet. Although Voyager
is ready to beam him up, Chakotay gives the boy the chance to
gain respect by shooting at him. Kar, however, chooses to kill his maje instead,
thereby earning his Ogla name.

The episode is not very exciting, but interesting in that it
gives some insight into the Kazon culture. It is often
superficially described as Klingon-like, but has a distinct and
obviously not very sophisticated view of "honor". Kar
has to kill an enemy to earn his name. Bad enough, but the enemy
may be even his own maje, or is it only the gratitude of the new
maje why it is accepted? Anyway, the Kazon leave anything but a
distinguished impression. I don't know if one should be sorry for
Kar who fits into his role only reluctantly, or if one should
congratulate that he has finally made it. The episode has a
satisfactory end, but not a happy one, at least not from a
human(ist) point of view.
Remarkable fact: Kar is played by Aron Eisenberg aka Nog.
Shuttles lost: 1
Rating: 4
Projections Stardate 48892.1: When the Doctor is
activated during a Kazon attack, he discovers that he can bleed
and experience pain, as if he were a real human being, whereas the
other crew members seem to be projections. Lt. Barclay from the
Jupiter Station tells the Doctor he is actually Lewis Zimmerman,
a human trapped in his holodeck creation of a starship named
Voyager. On the real starship Voyager, the crew succeed in
retrieving the Doctor, who was trapped on the holodeck and
suffering hallucinations after a computer malfunction.

Unusual situations, sudden twists, unexpected revelations.
That is what I always like to see and what this episode has plenty
of. The ingenious story entirely focuses on the Doctor. Other
crew members have only a few lines, if any. It is not a
deficiency, though The beginning points to a rather conventional
plot. There must have been a sort of attack, and the Doctor
doesn't manage to contact the other crew members. Fortunately
this is not the case, but it takes a while before this first turning point is reached. The first hint
that something is not right comes when there is
suddenly a projection system in other rooms besides sickbay. The
second one is the Kazon who intruded the mess hall. How
could he enter the ship, and if he managed to do so, why are
there no other Kazons? The third hint is the most definite one:
The Doctor starts bleeding and feeling pain, although it is not
part of his program. Actually, the Doctor is supposed to be a
real human, Lewis Zimmerman, and Lt. Barclay (Dwight Schultz)
tries hard to convince him. It was worth while to get him for a
guest appearance, and even a bit ironic, since Barclay was the
one who had severe problems with illusion and reality in TNG:
"Hollow Pursuits". I loved the flashback to "Caretaker" that was skillfully inserted into the
episode, without requiring a time travel or another strange
phenomenon.
Another nice idea was to make Kes his wife, possibly
reflecting the Doctor's wishes at that time. What if all the
formerly real persons are actually holograms and vice versa? For
some time, one could really believe that the whole Voyager story
is only a holodeck program, similar as it would be done again in DS9: "Far Beyond
the Stars". The episode also reminded me of Riker's weird
experience in TNG: "Frame of Mind". In a manner of
speaking, the resolution is similar, since the difference between
the manipulation of a human mind and of a computer program is not
that big. Chakotay's appearance marks the second turning point.
Just when the Doctor is almost convinced that he is Lewis
Zimmerman, he suddenly faces another, equally probable
explanation.
Remarkable scenes: The Doctor orders the computer to
"shut down all holographic systems" and all the
previously real persons disappear. -- In the closing scene, the
Doctor stretches his arm out of sickbay. It disappears and
thereby proves that he is a hologram.
Rating: 8
Elogium Stardate 48921.3: The presence of
space-dwelling life forms causes Kes to enter a premature
elogium, the Ocampa maturation process. It is the only phase in her short
lifespan to conceive a child, and Neelix is accordingly under pressure too. But
her elogium turns out to be a false alarm. In the meantime, Voyager
has to deal with the creatures that obviously mistake the ship
for a mating partner, and the situation is resolved by mimicking
a gesture of humility.

I just don't like this episode, and it has been my least
favorite for some time. Agreed, we learn a great deal about Kes
and about the Ocampa life. Yet, at some point it's not
interesting any more to see Kes' continuous suffering of stomach
ache and various other side effects of her elogium. It is not
credible anyway that such a hurry is necessary. I wonder how the
Ocampa civilization can survive if their women live only 9 years,
have only one phase of fertility and one pregnancy, if any.
All Ocampa should be twins - at the very least. Considering that
it would be more complicated in Kes' case anyway, since her
mating partner would be a Talaxian, why doesn't the Doctor just
combine their DNA in vitro? After all we're in the 24th century.
Moreover, it is quite obvious that the act of begetting wouldn't
have been pleasant, let alone romantic anyway. The only good
point is that the general question of children on board is
discussed, and - what a coincidence - at the end of the episode
Ensign Wildman tells Janeway of her pregnancy. The secondary plot
with the space whales - it reminded me too much of TNG:
"Galaxy's Child" and there was nothing new about it.
Remarkable scene: Kes eats beetles. Eek!
Remarkable fact: "Elogium" was originally scheduled
for the first season.
Rating: 1
Non Sequitur Stardate 49011.0: After a shuttle accident Harry finds himself in
San Francisco, in bed with his fiancée Libby. He is in a parallel
reality where Voyager has disappeared without him, and he has developed a new
type of runabout. Although his
situation is rather pleasant, he decides to correct history.
Harry finds support in an alien being responsible for the temporal accident and in Tom, who missed the ship in this reality.
In their effort to revert history to the one that Kim remembers, they steal a runabout prototype and head for
the anomaly that caused the timeline change. They succeed when Tom beams out
Harry just as the runabout is breaking apart. Harry is in the Delta Quadrant
again and rescued by Voyager.

What would you do if you suddenly got the life you have always
dreamt of, but on the cost of other people's well-being? Harry is
very concerned about it, and he doesn't choose the easy way to
live on his new pleasant life. By the way, would it really have
been that easy, taking into account that he has hardly an idea of
what he's supposed to do in this reality, namely designing starship engines? Aside from these fascinating thoughts the episode is rather average, it seems to
be written and directed with the idea in mind that Harry's odd
situation alone should make a good plot. The alien disguised as
coffee-house waiter Cosimo is a nice guy, however, is he
necessary for the story? He doesn't really help Kim, nor could he
have expected to be useful. The whole alien influence could have
been easily left out.
There are also some logical deficiencies.
First of all, how can Harry become a warp nacelle expert and earn
the Cochrane Medal only eight months after leaving the Academy?
Secondly, what is so exciting about the new runabout albeit being
virtually identical to the Danube class? The dialogues state that
it's much more than only the nacelles. Thirdly, how can there be
already a prototype in such a short time and why didn't they just
present the prototype itself to the admirals, rather than only
blueprints? It wouldn't have mattered, the two could have taken any
other shuttle, so why do they bother to steal the Yellowstone class?
Still, seeing Harry with his girl-friend in San Francisco and
getting some rare insight into the life in the Federation
compensates a lot for the lack of plot quality.
Remarkable dialogue: "Where are you going?" - "Marseille, France."
- "What for?" - "I've got to see Paris." - "But you just said you were going to Marseille."
(Libby and Harry)
Remarkable scene: The runabout prototype leaves the spacedock
door, which can be easily recognized as the Dyson Sphere door
from TNG: "Relics". :-o
Missed opportunity to get home: #4, although only for Harry
Rating: 7
Twisted Stardate not given: The crew think they are
getting mad when corridors on the ship disappear or change their
direction, because an anomaly causes the ship to twist and bend.
The distortion ring is getting closer and closer, until only the
holodeck on deck 6 is unaffected. Having tried all conceivable
counteractions, the only remaining possibility is to do nothing
about it - the ship and crew remain unharmed by the anomaly that was caused by
an unknown intelligent entity that attempted to scan the ship.

I'm still undecided if this episode is mainly about the
strange (and unexplained) effect that distorts the ship or about
character development. Actually, the former plot is amusing for
about 25 minutes, but after the first confusion there isn't much
interesting about it left. This is why the rest of the episode
seems to focus on character interaction. Virtually every crew
member gets a few good scenes or lines, save Janeway who is
knocked out by the strange (and unexplained) plasma wave. We never know who or
what exactly caused the whole fuss. Maybe
the crew would find out after analyzing the massive (and
unexplained) computer upload. But irrespective of the way I look at
it, this episode is well below average.
Remarkable error: The sign on the bar says "Chez Sandrine's à
Marseilles", which is an awkward amalgam of English and French. The correct
French name should have been "Chez Sandrine à Marseille".
Remarkable fact: The unknown entity uploads 20 million
gigaquads of new information.
Rating: 3
Parturition Stardate not given: The two rivals Paris
and Neelix, both in love with Kes, are stranded on a hostile planet after a
shuttle crash. They seek shelter in a cave where they discover a nest of eggs.
One of them breaks up apparently prematurely, revealing a reptohumanoid
creature. Paris and Neelix learn to know each other better helping the newborn alien to survive until their mother arrives.

The rivalry between Paris and Neelix is very childish,
and I
wonder how adult men can possibly behave like this. At some point
I would have expected more of a plot than "Neelix's and
Paris's pasta battle for Kes' love", but there is none.
Both the shuttle crash and the new-born turtle serve the sole
purpose of forcing the two opponents to work together and, more importantly, to engage in long and fatigue dialogues. Fortunately
they are successful and a more serious discussion is enabled;
they even build some kind of friendship. Actually, the only thing
I liked about the episode is that it will have a lasting effect.
Remarkable quote: "You don't need to impress me with
your...technobabble." (Neelix)
Remarkable scene: Paris and Neelix are summoned to the ready
room, and they appear garnished all over with pasta and tomato sauce after
their skirmish in the mess hall.
Shuttles lost: 1
Rating: 2
Persistence of
Vision Stardate not given:
The whole crew except for the Doctor suffer from
hallucinations induced by the Bothans in order to take over the ship. B'Elanna
attempts to create a symmetric warp field to block out the psionic field that creates the
illusions. Eventually Kes, who manages to defy the Bothan manipulation with her own
mental powers, finishes the works and saves the ship, and the Bothans retreat.

Hallucination is a recurring theme in Star Trek and it is
mostly not very original, neither is the idea of an alien takeover.
What remains interesting is some insight into the crew's fears and wishes.
Janeway is chased by the characters from the Victorian holonovel
- which I don't like at all - and meets boy-friend Mark. Paris
sees his father, Kim his fiancée, Tuvok his wife. What I really like is that it
is up to Kes to save the ship, with a little
help from the Doctor. She has the potential to evolve from the little girl to a
valuable crew member, and for once her superior abilities are to
Voyager's advantage. Although it is obvious they wanted to take
the ship, the Bothans remain somewhat mysterious. Maybe not a bad
idea, since I'm tired of the type of villains whose motivation is
either obvious or needs to be exhaustively explained by themselves.
Remarkable dialogue: "Why did you do this?" -
"Because I can." (Janeway and a Bothan)
Rating: 4
Tattoo Stardate not given: Investigating the occurrence of familiar symbols of American Indian origin on a
planet in the Delta Quadrant, Chakotay is separated from the rest
of the away team. Janeway takes the ship into the atmosphere to rescue Chakotay,
but the ship gets caught in a storm. Chakotay encounters aliens, the "Sky
Spirits" who once visited and
taught his people, the "Rubber Tree People", but believed they had been extinguished by the
white man by now. Chakotay tells them that Voyager means no harm to his culture,
and the aliens release the ship.

I like Indian culture in general and I'm also very glad every
time I see a human crew member who is not of British or Irish
origin. However, I have a couple of issues with the way
Chakotay's cultural heritage is depicted. First of all, we have seen
aliens preserve an Indian culture before in TOS: "The
Paradise Syndrome".
The revelation that still other aliens did care about Chakotay's
people is neither original nor credible. Moreover, as the ancestors of
present-day Indians started spreading throughout the American
continent, they formed different tribes with considerably
different cultures. How is it possible or how could the aliens
expect that they would still form a monolithic culture after so
many millennia, or that at least one among the thousands of
tribes, namely the Rubber Tree People, would preserve exactly
this culture?
Yet, Chakotay obviously belongs to this
"rightful tribe". I also wonder if Chakotay is supposed
to belong to a real tribe at all. Star Trek has never tried to
make up something in Earth's history or geography. Agreed, the
Eugenic Wars didn't take place, but it is not like in other
American TV series that frequently feature fake countries and
peoples as playgrounds for their heroes. In some way, the
definite alien influence and the indefinite cultural background
make Chakotay an alien too. Finally, considering that Chakotay's
Rubber Tree People must be insignificant among native American
cultures, it is obvious that the alien heritage was virtually
lost even before the white man destroyed the other Indian
cultures. Therefore the accusation that "those who had no
respect for life or land" are responsible is not really
correct. Notwithstanding the above remarks it's a fine Chakotay
episode, and it is revealing that he was not that fond of his
culture at first, but tried to catch up with it as late as an
adult.
Remarkable fact: A Capt. Sulu supported Chakotay's entry into
Starfleet.
Rating: 4
Cold Fire Stardate not given: When the remains of the
Caretaker suddenly begin to resonate, the crew begins to search
for what is apparently the other Caretaker. They find a smaller
version of the Array populated by over 2000 Ocampa. When
Suspiria, the other Caretaker, arrives, she blames the crew for
killing her companion. Janeway can prevent her from destroying
the ship, but there is obviously no chance to get home with Suspiria's help.

First of all, I wonder why it was necessary to refer to the
events in "Caretaker" in the teaser. There is no concept of
isolated stories anyway, and some of the Seska/Kazon episodes
would have rather required a special intro for less
frequent viewers. Another issue is that Kes seems to
have supernatural abilities only on certain selected occasions. Furthermore the question arises why she can feel the presence of
the other Caretaker, but not of the Ocampa on the nearby space
station.
Anyway, it is about time that Kes is given a really
important role apart from saying something like "I sense
fear/anger" like Deanna in the first seasons of TNG and the
involvement in humorous B-plots. "Elogium" has been
merely an interlude without consequences for the rest of the
crew, so "Cold Fire" is her chance. Kes has to decide whether to follow
Tuvok's or Tanis' way of using her newly discovered power, and
this is not only a question of leaving the ship or not - which is
already hard enough. Unfortunately, the decision is made for her
when Tanis' and Suspiria's real intentions are revealed - they
are hardly interested in Kes but mostly in the ship. Poor Kes, it
will take even more time to become more than just the cute little
girl.
Remarkable quotes: "Without the darkness, how would you
recognize the light? Do not fear your negative thoughts, they are
part of you, they are part of every living being, even
Vulcans." (Tuvok to Kes), "Vulcans make the worst
patients." (Doctor)
Remarkable scene: When Kes doesn't manage to harness her
forces, Tuvok's eyes protrude and green blood runs from his head.
An unusually horrible scene.
Remarkable fact: The Caretaker's race is called
"Nacene".
Missed opportunity to get home: #5, even though Suspiria
didn't want to help, Janeway could have tried harder
Current crew count: 150, according
to Kes
Rating: 5
Maneuvers Stardate: 49208.5: The Kazon-Nistrim launch
an attack on Voyager and, breaking through the hull with an armored shuttle, they succeed in stealing a transporter module. Chakotay,
who feels guilty about Seska's treason, attempts to retrieve the
technology on his own, but is captured. When the Kazon attack
again and it is not possible to beam Chakotay out, Janeway has
the Kazon leaders beamed aboard and Chakotay and his shuttle are
returned in exchange for their freedom.

As another thriller in the Kazon storyline,
the episode features several
unusual "Maneuvers" indeed. It is an excellent story of
deception, betrayal and cunning. The episode focuses on Chakotay
and Seska, who both prevail over their respective superiors.
Nevertheless, while it is adequate that Culluh is determined but
incompetent, I wouldn't expect the same of Janeway.
Anyway,
unlike the former Maquis, the Starfleet crew leaves a rather bad
impression. Why does no one suspect the defector Seska of sending
the Federation signal and anticipate that it is almost certainly
a trap? Why does Janeway order to return fire so late after
Culluh's sneak attack? Why is security ordered to the hull breach
as late as the Kazon have already boarded the ship? I also wonder
why the Starfleet crew supposes the Nistrim have less than six
ships. An inconsistency is that the Mostral Maje Jal
Surat knows of the fate of the Relora maje and his adjutant, who
had been beamed into space. How is this possible, since Voyager
picked up the corpses just after it had happened and didn't
broadcast it, of course? Well, maybe Culluh broadcast it to all Kazon factions
as a warning?
Remarkable quote: "Hello, Chakotay. Congratulations on your victory. I look forward to our next meeting. Oh, and there's something you should know. While you were unconscious, I took the liberty of extracting a sample of your DNA. I impregnated myself with it. So, I guess more congratulations are in order. You're going to be a father."
(Seska's transmission to Chakotay)
Remarkable absences: The Doctor and Kes are both missing in
this episode.
Remarkable maneuvers: the Kazon torpedo breaking through
Voyager's hull, Chakotay's shuttle approaching the Kazon ship
with all systems disengaged, Janeway's trick to beam the Kazon
leaders aboard
Rating: 8
Resistance Stardate not given: Attempting to purchase tellerium on a
planet, Tuvok and Torres are
captured by the oppressive Mokran police, while Janeway is rescued
by an older man named Caylem of the resident resistance movement. Caylem insists on
Janeway being his daughter, who has in fact been abducted by the police
years ago. With the help of Caylem's resistance group, a Voyager
away team manages to free the imprisoned officers. Caylem avenges his daughter
by killing the Mokran officer Augris and dies when he jumps into the way of a
phaser aimed at Janeway.

"Resistance is futile". Sorry for this awkward pun,
but it summarizes what I think about this uninspiring and
predictable episode. After Janeway has been separated from the rest of the crew,
it all boils down to her hanging around with Caylem as some kind of father
figure. His character reminds me of Mullibok in the
equally boring episode DS9: "Progress". The circumstances are
different here and at least there is a reason for Janeway's prolonged stay on
the planet, but just like Kira in the DS9 episode she develops an unlikely
emotional attachment to the old man (of the kind that would never be written for
a male main character). I also don't like the portrayal of Caylem's senility
that can be
regarded as an offense to older people.
The rest of the story is just too simple to be interesting. The crew
members are captured, and it is obvious they have to be freed
again after 45 minutes. It is not the slightest surprise that Caylem gets the
chance to exert revenge and dies at the end of the episode to find deliverance. The two points are only
for a certain quality of writing and acting in the scenes of
Janeway and Caylem, but this can't really compensate for the meager plot.
Rating: 2
Prototype Stardate not given: Voyager picks up the
damaged Pralor android 3947 that is afloat in space, and B'Elanna manages to
repair its defunct power module. When Janeway refuses to provide
more power modules for the other androids, 3947 kidnaps B'Elanna
and forces her to build a prototype. While the android ship is being attacked by a similar
vessel of the Cravic, another android
civilization, B'Elanna can be rescued. It turns out that the Pralor
and Cravic civilizations had built the androids to fight each other, but the androids
wound up killing their creators and continued the
war on their own.

Already the teaser, showing the events from the perspective of
3947, is very promising, and the episode keeps this promise.
There is not a single minute of boredom, not a single unnecessary filler scene. B'Elanna's dedication and excitement to get the robot 3947
running again is very personal, as is her disappointment
about being deceived by him more than once. As the plot unfolds, the suspense rises gradually up to the culmination when it is
revealed that the Pralor and Cravic robots actually killed their
creators. One of the best scenes is B'Elanna's dispute with
Janeway whether to provide the robots with new power modules or
not. It is remarkable in that it's not just arguing about the
Prime Directive, but touches very basic ethic problems. Are the
robots actually lifeforms? If yes, do they have to be preserved
from extinction, or is it right to deny them the requested
reproduction? Would it be the same as helping a biological
species that has become sterile, or is it that the robots are
just not designed to reproduce?
At first, I didn't like the idea
of having incompatible power modules which seems to be a
recurring problem in Star Trek. Is there no equivalent of a
simple transformer for generating a suited type of power? Anyway,
this time the power modules are a kind of copyright protection
which makes sense with respect to the dedicated warlike nature of
the robots.
Remarkable quote: "Prototype unit 0001 is ready to accept programming."
(0001, repeatedly)
Remarkable scene: B'Elanna tells 3947 to cross his fingers,
and he tries hard to do so. :-)
Rating: 9
Alliances Stardate 49337.4: Being under continuous
attack from the Kazons, Janeway decides that it is time to seek an
ally. Voyager encounters the Trabe, who once suppressed the
Kazon, but were expelled from their planet in the course of the
Kazon rebellion. Janeway arranges a peace conference on a planet, including all Kazon sects. However, a Trabe ship attacks the conference
room. Disgusted about this cowardly and reckless behavior,
Janeway ends the talks with the Trabe.

It's an episode with many surprising turning
points, and it's
the episode where Janeway has a personal conflict with virtually
everyone. Janeway vs. Hogan: When Hogan suggests that Voyager give away technology to the Kazon, this is actually the climax
of the Federation-Maquis conflict. Unfortunately this storyline
will not be continued and will end in "Basics". Hogan
is only a small crewman and he is "only" a Maquis
anyway, but she gets unusually upset about it, as if it were
already a mutiny. I can understand her since her leadership was
questioned in front of the whole crew and, even worse, on a
memorial service for a crew member. Nevertheless, she could have
responded to it in a rather calm and superior way. Janeway vs.
Chakotay: He suggests to seek an ally, and Janeway is irritated
about it, or doesn't she just want to admit that she would do the
same in his position? Her arguing with the Prime Directive is a
weak justification, since she has always found her own
interpretation so far. Janeway vs. Tuvok: It's a nice idea to
include the Spock reference (Khitomer Peace Treaty) and the
hybrid of two species that is stronger than either of them alone.
It's no surprise to see that rather Tuvok than Chakotay can
convince her. Janeway vs. Culluh: No one would have expected an
agreement. However, eventually it is Culluh's macho attitude of
not wanting women to make decisions that makes her break off the
negotiations. Not that I would approve of Culluh's opinion, but
this is mainly a cultural clash, which she should have left aside for
the time being. Otherwise no one in history could have ever found
an ally. Janeway vs. Trabe leader Mabus: It is obvious that he
has ruined every chance of an alliance with his cowardly plot to
kill the Kazon majes. Here I agree with her.
What I liked most about the episode was the elucidation of Kazon
history. It is only incredible that Neelix hasn't told Janeway
about the Kazon-Trabe relations in time. The way the Trabe are
portrayed is a bit insidious. They are expelled people and they
look much like humans - at least much more than the Kazons. They
even wear Bajoran earrings! Nevertheless those people turn out
little likable. The question is if they are really that bad or if
it's only their leader. Janeway should have given them another
chance, but unfortunately they never showed up again.
Photon torpedoes used: 3
Crew losses: 1 shown, 2 mentioned
Rating: 7
Threshold Stardate 49373.4: Tom pilots a new shuttle
prototype and he is the first person ever to reach Warp 10 -- infinite speed! After his flight he
undergoes a strange
metamorphosis to a new, "more evolved" lifeform. Tom kidnaps
Janeway, they go to Warp 10 again, after which they both evolve to amphibious creatures
resembling newts and have children! They are found and identified by an away
team, and the Doctor manages to restore
their human nature, while their kids are left behind.

This is "Spock's Brain, part II: Tom's Tongue".
"Trashhold" (sorry, I couldn't resist) screws
up the laws of science
like no other episode of Star Trek. Considering the manifold violations of
basic principles of Star Trek and of the real world the quality of
the rest of the plot doesn't matter that much, but even this winds up as
harebrained. Neelix
is incredibly stupid for an experienced space traveler. The
scene when Tom and Harry explain him Warp 10 is not only annoying
because the "theoretical impossibility" is disproved in
the following, but also because they explain it to Neelix in very
simple words and he nevertheless doesn't get the idea. Tom has
two good scenes when he urges Janeway to send him on the Warp 10
flight and when he tries to explain that he firmly believes he is
evolving to something better. But once again what we are being told is not what
we can see. And the very moment when he loses his tongue it become ludicrous.
Ironically, the Kazon who is contacted by traitor Jonas is the
most intelligent character in the episode: "Warp 10, that's
impossible." Correct. So why didn't Braga simply stick to this fundamental
law of Trek and real physics?
The only point is for the
unintentional entertaining potential of the episode, of the kind that already
"Spock's Brain" had.
Remarkable quotes: "Nothing in the universe can go Warp
10. It's a theoretical impossibility. In principle, if you ever
reach Warp 10, you'd be traveling at infinite velocity."
(Kim), "I have some tests I would like to run on Your
Majesty before I release you into the realm of ordinary
humans." (the Doctor)
Remarkable dialogue: "What did he ingest?" -
"Just a cup of Neelix's coffee." - "It's a miracle
he's still alive." (the Doctor and B'Elanna)
Remarkable shuttle: The Warp-10 shuttle is a more streamlined and elegant
design as the usual shuttle boxes, and it's named for Zefram Cochrane. The
spaceframe is not custom-built for the Warp-10 flight, but is a
standard shuttle as we will see later.
Missed opportunity to get home: #6, even if only a crew of
salamanders arrives
Rating: 1
Meld Stardate not given: Crewman Darwin is found dead in
engineering, and Tuvok concludes that he must have been murdered by Betazoid
Ensign Suder who was there at the time. Tuvok mind-melds with Suder to understand why he
killed the crewmate for no obvious reason. The procedure endangers Tuvok's
mind, as he develops violent tendencies himself. When he is about to
execute Suder, another mind-meld helps him to control his
emotions again. Suder is locked up in secure quarters, where he will spend the
rest of the journey.

While the episode was absolutely convincing and somewhat
thrilling, I missed the motion in it. Once there is a criminal
case aboard the ship, but the murderer is found quickly and the
only remaining problem is why this useless crime did happen. This
becomes the general question where violence comes from. To
explain this is futile, because violence is part of our nature
and is more or less well suppressed. Tuvok needs the whole
episode to find this out, and after a while it gets boring for
the viewer to see that he makes little progress. Personally, I
was hoping for some kind of revelation about Suder's true motive, but there was none. While
the whole plot was not really the thriller it could have been, I concede an extra point
for Lon Suder (Brad Dourif) as a credible psychopath, one for Tim Russ giving a Tuvok as
the "evil Vulcan" and one for the sinister atmosphere.
Remarkable fact: This is the first episode to present Tom as
unreliable and rebellious, which will be resolved in
"Investigations".
Crew losses: 1
Rating: 5
Dreadnought Stardate 49447.8: Voyager encounters an autonomous weapon
probe of Cardassian origin. Back in her Maquis days
B'Elanna reprogrammed the weapon dubbed
"Dreadnought" to attack a Cardassian fuel depot. Being
pulled into the Delta Quadrant by the Caretaker, Dreadnought now believes the navigational data is a deception and heads for the
densely populated planet Rakosa V. When all efforts to disable
Dreadnought fail, Janeway decides to destroy it using Voyager's
self-destruct. Virtually in the last moment B'Elanna manages to
disable the probe from within.

This is definitely one of the most exciting thrillers in Star Trek
history, comparable in many ways to TOS: "The Doomsday Machine". The episode features another intense plot focused on
B'Elanna after "Faces" and "Prototype".
Agreed, the "stubborn computer/bomb" plot elements are
borrowed from "2001: A Space Odyssey", "Dark
Star" and TOS: "The Ultimate Computer". Anyway, the computer's behavior,
unlike that of a hologram, is awfully logical and inflexible
while it sometimes seems that Dreadnought desperately protects
and justifies its mission much like a human being would do:
"The probability of being in the Delta Quadrant, 70,000ly
from the last confirmed position, is negligible."
Dreadnought seems to make up its own interpretation of what is
negligible, and this is most unsettling. Moreover, the computer
is speaking with B'Elanna's voice so as to emphasize the odd
situation. In some way she is threatened by herself. The
dialogues between Dreadnought and B'Elanna are a clear homage to
HAL-9000, most obviously the irrelevant phrases like "Did
you sleep well last night." I don't think this is a
deficiency, at least I enjoyed it very much. An absolute tidbit
is the dispute between the Maquis program and the obsolete
Cardassian file that try to eliminate each other. It reminded me
a bit of the communication between Windows and a program by a
hardware manufacturer, which both simultaneously demand to get
their drivers installed, once new hardware is detected.
Remarkable dialogue: "What do you think of Cameron?"
- "I like it." - "Cameron. From the ancient Celtic term for one whose nose is bent." - "What about
Frederick?" - "Frederick. Very distinguished. However,
it bares a close resemblance to a rather impolite term on the
Bolian homeworld." - "It doesn't have to be a human
name. I like Sural. It's Vulcan." - "Yes. Unfortunately
it's also the name of a dictator on Sakura Prime, famed for beheading his enemies - and his parents." (Samantha Wildman
and the Doctor discussing possible names for her child)
Remarkable quote: "When a bomb starts talking about itself in the third
person, I get worried." (Tom)
Remarkable scene: Janeway orders all personnel to leave when
she is about to self-destruct the ship, but Tuvok insists on
joining her because it would be logical.
Remarkable facts: Dreadnought carries a warhead of 1000kg
matter and 1000kg antimatter, has quantum torpedoes and a plasma
wave weapon, is virtually invulnerable through adaptive shielding
and incredibly intelligent. It seems much too advanced and
perfect for something Cardassian. -- Janeway is obviously the only
captain allowed to activate the self-destruct single-handedly.
Torpedoes used: 6
Rating: 9
Death Wish Stardate not given: The Voyager crew
accidentally frees a dissenter of the Q Continuum who has been
imprisoned for his desire to be mortal. When Q comes aboard, it
is up to Janeway to decide whether the new Q is granted asylum,
thereby destabilizing the Q Continuum, or if he is returned to
the other Q. Despite Q's offer to take the ship home if she
favors his demand, she lets the new Q, who calls himself Quinn,
stay aboard as a human crew member. His death wish, however, is
so strong that he commits suicide briefly later.

It is amazing how the authors have managed to create funny Q
stories without getting silly for TNG, and so is Q's first
appearance on Voyager. One might criticize the idea of Voyager
hanging on a Christmas tree or being attacked by protons, which is
close to ludicrous indeed. Yet, this can be regarded as a part of
a game to impress the allegedly primitive humanoids. It is
interesting to notice that the two Q's will become more sensible
once they see that Janeway and her crew are obviously taking it
more seriously than they would like her to do. In spite of all
the distracting fanciful ideas, the episode successfully gets to
the bottom of the question if an individual may be allowed to
commit suicide. Janeway decides in Quinn's favor, despite Q's
promise not to lock up Quinn again and his offer to bring the
ship home. It's strange to see that Janeway has a talent to waste
preferably her best chances. Moreover, I have the impression that
Q's macho attitude towards her did play a role in her decision
process. Anyway, she has a good explanation for her judgment.
Her attempt to convince Quinn that human life isn't that bad is
very touching, on the other hand, no one can really expect Quinn
to go on living as a mortal being, for every aspect of it can be
supposed to be entirely included in his virtually eternal life as
a Q. The only new experience would be death, and this is what he
gets.
What I also liked about the episode is the many references and
allusions that are consistent with previous events in Star Trek.
It is stated that without Quinn there would be no Riker and the
Federation would have been assimilated by the Borg. Q's
punishment by the Continuum, as shown in TNG: "Déjà
Q", is referred to. Janeway has a very good point about
executions of Q Continuum members, as mentioned in TNG: "
True Q". A Q episode is not a good time to care about
physical oddities. I only wonder where and how the protons that
attack the ship should occur without electrons. Maybe the ship
got right into a beam weapon.
Remarkable guest appearances: Q (John de Lancie) and Riker
(Jonathan Frakes)
Remarkable dialogue: "What did you do to him?" -
"Nothing. He is still there, in the 24th century. I just
took the rest of us to an old hiding place of mine." -
"Report." - "Captain, there are no stars
outside." - "Well, that's partially accurate. Actually,
there's no universe outside." (Quinn, Janeway and Kim
experience the Big Bang)
Remarkable quotes: "I am curious. Have the Q always had
an absence of manners, or is it the result of some natural
evolutionary process that comes with omnipotence?" (Tuvok),
"And you find nothing contradictory in a society that
outlaws suicide, but practices capital punishment?" -
"No." (Janeway and Q)
Remarkable fact: Quinn started a "100 year war between
the Romulans and the Vulcans". This is not necessarily a
contradiction to the assumption that they didn't have contact
(again) until the 22nd century, but it could be the war that
already took place on Vulcan between Surak's logicians and the
dissenters who later became the Romulans.
Missed opportunity to get home: #7, with even two Qs to ask such a favor
Rating: 7
Lifesigns Stardate not given: The Doctor saves the
life of a Vidiian woman, Dr. Danara Pel, by creating a holographic
reproduction of her intact body. The Doctor feels attracted to
Danara and they spend a lot of time on the holodeck. Danara likes
her new appearance and she even tries to kill her deformed real
body, but the Doctor succeeds to convince her that it is
necessary to resume her old body. Meanwhile on the bridge, the conflict of
Chakotay and Paris escalates, and Paris ends up in the brig.

It is a very touching episode about Doctor
"Shmullus" and his emerging emotions. The episode also
manages to show the whole impact of the Vidiian phage by
concentrating on the personal tragedy of a single individual. It
is explicitly shown what an attractive and charming person Danara would be without the
terrible disease - and wants to be when she realizes it.
Fortunately there is no simple statement like "real beauty
is inside you" or "outer appearance doesn't
matter". It does matter. Yet, one can overcome one's fear
and doubts. At one point, it seems as if B'Elanna would deny
Danara her help in the same way as Worf refused to donate blood
for the injured Romulan in TNG: "The Enemy".
Fortunately she can overcome her reservations. Tom's increasingly
odd behavior is shown as a little sub-plot, however, with respect
to the plan to uncover the traitor it is just too blatant.
Wouldn't Jonas be rather alarmed than appeased if there is
someone even more interested in leaving the ship?
Remarkable scene: the gradual holographic reconstruction of
Danara Pel's healthy physiology
Remarkable dialogue: Kes advises the Doctor: "You have to
tell her how you feel." Cut. The Doctor is performing a
surgery, casually turns to Danara and says: "By the way, Danara, I feel romantically attracted to you and I wanted to know
if you feel the same." Camera turns to Kes. Note her facial
expression: shocked!
Remarkable misunderstanding: "What are you crying?"
- "I'm sorry, I..." - "I thought you'd be
pleased." - "I am. I just never expected to look
healthy again. I've been sick for so long." (Doctor and
Danara after the restoration of her body, reminds me of Data in "Star
Trek: Generations")
Remarkable mistake: The unit "terahertz" is once
mispronounced as "tetrahertz". :-o
Remarkable fact: The Doctor possesses a database with the
medical knowledge of 3000 cultures.
Rating: 7
Investigations Stardate not given: As a consequence of his
recent insubordination, Tom leaves Voyager and joins a Talaxian
convoy, but he is abducted by the Kazon. Neelix investigates the
case and he thinks that Tom might have had contact to the Kazons
before. Janeway and Tuvok, however, tell him that Tom
intentionally behaved like that to get the opportunity to unmask the real traitor. On the Kazon vessel, Tom finds out that it's
Jonas, and he escapes with a shuttle. Jonas sabotages Voyager,
but in a struggle with Neelix he plunges into a plasma stream and is killed.

The episode is a spy story above average, but it reminds me a
lot of TOS:
"The Enterprise Incident" where the plan was equally stupid. Did Tom
actually expect to be kidnapped by the Kazons? How could he be
sure he would get an opportunity to find evidence about the
traitor? If so, how could he hope he could ever escape?
Nevertheless this wasn't Tom's episode, but Neelix's, and focusing on him would have been a good idea under different circumstances if the
story had taken place completely on Voyager. We already knew it
was Jonas, and it would have served the episode better if it had
been a silent duel between him and Neelix, but the minor
character obviously wasn't supposed to get more screen time.
An
irritating detail: When the warp coils were burnt out, there was
obviously a verterium cortenide source in the range of the
impulse drive. What a coincidence. A possible flaw: Why does
Neelix have access to Tom's logs through an engineering code that is even known to low-ranking crew members, and why is there
no additional voice recognition?
Remarkable fact: Neelix reads a log entry of a communication
"Voyager to Catati" (sp.?). The Caatati from "Day of
Honor"?
Unlikely.
Crew losses: 1
Rating: 6
Deadlock Stardate not given: Subspace anomalies
inside a nebula cause a quantum duplication of Voyager and crew.
One version is heavily damaged, first by proton bursts and later by the Vidiians. Ensign Wildman
loses her baby and Harry is blown off the ship through a hull breach. Yet, an undamaged version of Voyager occupies the same
space at the same time. In order to save the intact ship, Capt.
Janeway of the damaged ship decides to activate the
self-destruct. However, as the Vidiians enter the undamaged
Voyager, this ship has to be destroyed, after Kim and Naomi
Wildman have been transferred to the other ship.

Damage to the ship and losses of life have been the weekly business of Voyager,
but it has never been that grave so far. It is obvious that the
crew and the ship can't go through such a hard time and face
such hard decisions every few episodes, because then the subject would be
quickly exhausted, not to mention the trouble to explain how the crew recovers
and how the ship can be repaired each time. Anyway, it was worth the trouble this time. The chance to bring
Janeway and her crew into a truly desperate
situation was not wasted, and their distress was even emphasized by showing a
second, completely intact ship at the same time. Ironically, the
proton bursts from one Voyager are actually the cause of the damages and of Harry's and Naomi's death on the other ship. It is
equally ironic that it is eventually the previously undamaged
ship that has to be sacrificed.
Nitpicking: I must admit I didn't bother too
much about the fact that both ships were still occupying the same
point in space-time, yet they were separated. It is explained by
the usual phase variance theory. Nevertheless, why is
self-destruction an option if the two ships are that strongly
coupled that crew transfer or division of antimatter would have
been fatal? How is it possible and why is it regarded as useful
or necessary to merge the two Voyagers again? Exactly this will
lead to an ethical problem in "Tuvix". -- One more strange
thing I noticed: The Vidiians are able to extract organs without
surgery ("The Phage") and they can create two separate
copies of the same person by DNA splitting ("Faces"). They just have
to possess transporter
technology too, still they obviously don't have a transporter and
enter the ship the old-fashioned way by cutting through the hull.
Remarkable scene: The Doctor of the intact ship asks "How
is our other patient?", and the camera pans to the
unconscious second Kes from the damaged ship. I liked the way it
was referred to her in a casual remark. The crew has obviously
become very "professional" about the frequently
encountered anomalies.
Remarkable quote: "Mr. Kim, we're Starfleet officers,
weird is part of the job." (Janeway)
Rating: 7
Innocence Stardate not given: After a shuttle crash that kills the
ensign who accompanies him, Tuvok encounters a group of three children. In the meantime,
Voyager gets in touch with the purportedly xenophobic Drayans. On the planet,
Tuvok tries to comfort the children, who fear a creature, Morrok,
that is supposed to kill them. The children are actually members of the
Drayan race and were transferred there to die. Drayans are subjected to a reversed aging process, being
born as apparently old and wise people and dying as innocent
children.

The episode begins with a shuttle crash. There haven't been too many so far in the
series. But I dislike it as an uninteresting standard procedure to get
characters isolated. Moreover, another "unnecessary" ensign has to die. This one
gets at least a touching death scene. Nevertheless, it is
irresponsible to leave poor Tuvok alone with the three children.
Fortunately, just when I was about to dub the episode
"Tuvok's Kindergarten", the plot gained some
profoundness. Tuvok, the most emotionally challenged of all
Vulcans, gets a couple of very nice scenes. He shows a strong
fondness for his little friends without losing his impeccable
logic. Two points for him, one for the fact that these children
are not as annoying as kids have been elsewhere in Star Trek. The
rest of the episode is crap. As a matter of fact, the children
are old people, while they behave much like real children. There
is no way to explain this biological nonsense. All lifeforms on
all other planets and even inanimate objects are looking old
because they are old. There is no such thing as "reversed
aging".
Remarkable quote: "We don't often receive such
distinguished guests here, unless there's been some sort of
accident." (the Doctor to the Drayan ambassador about
sickbay)
Crew losses: 1
Rating: 3
The Thaw Stardate not given: Three individuals have
survived a global disaster in cryogenic chambers, but they are
firmly linked to a computer system. When Harry and B'Elanna enter
the chambers to recover them, they find themselves trapped in a
bizarre virtual reality ruled by a clown called "Fear".
Fear holds all the five persons hostages, and he may kill anyone
by disabling their body functions. Janeway sends the Doctor as a
negotiator, and he can persuade Fear to take her instead of the
other hostages, but it is a trick, since she is not really hooked
up to the system.

Why does Janeway beam up the chambers in the first place
instead of letting them rest in peace, as it would certainly comply with the Prime
Directive? Why
does she put two of her officers into the chambers, not taking
the risks into account? Only if we forgive her these mistakes we
can enjoy the rest of the episode. It's no surprise that it's
again the Doctor who saves the day. Immune to Fear's threats and
not connected to his mind, the Doctor gives a superior
performance. Janeway excels likewise, when she explains that
fear/Fear will eventually vanish. Harry is the poor victim again, at least
temporarily. It is important to notice that it's because of his
thoughts that Fear gets the idea of taking only Janeway hostage
instead of the four other people - because it would apparently be more
attractive. Harry's idea of Janeway must
have been very special. I wonder in how far fear is regarded a
permanent state-of-mind in this episode and not only a temporary
emotion, and in how far Fear is supposed to be a real character
and not only a manifestation of people's emotions that would
vanish with their fear. Note the difference between
"fear" and "Fear".
It is obvious to compare this episode to other occasions where
emotions were incarnated. In TOS: "Day of the Dove" there was an entity consuming hatred,
but only in its explicitly shown form and not as a latent
emotion. TNG: "Skin of Evil" featured a creature that
was the incarnation of the bad emotions of a whole civilization
and therefore accordingly evil, although not really credible. DS9:
"The Storyteller" shows the Dal'Rok, which can be
appeased if people stick together, very much like in "Day of
the Dove". Generally speaking, the manifestation named Fear is more believable than
the above entities, since emotions are always inherent to a
specific being, and are not likely to have a separate, let alone
corporeal existence. On the other hand, in this case Fear would
have lost his personality when he agreed to accept Janeway as his
only hostage. I would have liked to see Janeway's fears, though.
;-)
Rating: 4
Tuvix Stardate 49655.2: Tuvok and Neelix merge to one person because of a transporter accident.
This "Tuvix" is
healthy and has the personalities, knowledge and abilities of
both Neelix and Tuvok, and he fits perfectly into Voyager's crew. When a
procedure is developed to split Tuvix again, he refuses and he
claims that he is about to be murdered. Yet, Janeway rules the
two former crew members have to be retrieved.

Tuvok and Neelix merged to one person. It could have
wound up as extremely silly, but it became an episode dealing with a profound ethic dilemma that is credibly presented.
There is nothing funny at all, except for
the beginning. Interestingly, it is not Tuvix' but mainly Kes' episode. She had many good scenes dealing with her attempts to
cope with the situation. Both the embarrassment about the strange
new crewmate Tuvix and the appreciation of his many abilities
were absolutely convincing, and this can be said about the other crew
members likewise.
Yet, there were several logical and biological oddities: The
basic plot is a bit like "Faces", only with the
reverse effect. I wonder why there
was no reference to the events in the latter episode, and why it
was not considered to apply Vidiian medical techniques to
separate Tuvok and Neelix. The combination of the two individuals
of different species is described as a Vulcan-Talaxian hybrid,
yet, the transporter just assembles and disassembles physically
and would not be capable of biological breeding, even with the
help of a strange alien plant. It is interesting that even the
clothes were merged, maybe the transporter actually entirely
superimposed or mixed the two patterns in a creative fashion, but it is virtually
impossible to create a viable lifeform this way. The thing that
bothered me most is how Tuvok's and Neelix's consciousnesses
could survive besides the new merged version in Tuvix' body.
Even if this was possible, how could the Doctor and Janeway be
sure that it was actually the case? There could have been two
mindless persons after the separation. One way to investigate
this possibility would have been using Tuvok' or Tuvix' or Kes'
telepathic abilities, but this was not even considered an option. It should
have revealed if there was something left of Tuvok and Neelix.
The only scene I really disliked was Tuvix' shouting all over
the bridge, when the decision was made to restore Tuvok and
Neelix. Not that I would deny him to fight for what he thinks is
his life, but he did it in a blatantly cowardly way so as to let
Tuvok and Neelix appear as the better persons who would not have
behaved this way. I would have preferred to see Tuvix reluctantly
but silently face his death, this would have been much more
touching.
Remarkable dialogues: "That 'lovely tune' is a
traditional funeral dirge." - "I know, but it was
the...the most cheerful song I could find in the Vulcan
database." (Tuvok and Neelix), "I assure you, Mr.
Tuvix. There's nothing to worry about. We've accounted for every
variable." - "Except for one. In don't want to
die." (the Doctor and Tuvix)
Rating: 8
Resolutions Stardate not given: Janeway and Chakotay
suffer from an incurable virus disease, and only the atmosphere
of the home planet of the virus can keep them alive. In the meantime Voyager, now under the command of Tuvok, has left the
planet. Despite Janeway's order not to contact the Vidiians
they take the risk and eventually obtain a cure from Danara Pel.

The plot lives from opposite characters facing
one another
rather than the confrontation with viruses and Vidiians. There is Tuvok's
sense of duty vs. Harry's enthusiasm. Why do I have the
impression that Tuvok was waiting for such a clear sign of
support all the time after the Vidiian convoy had been detected?
Janeway's determination vs. Chakotay's fatalism. I wonder in how
far Chakotay's letting go was influenced by his desire to stay
with Janeway, he yielded so easily. He was the one who was rather
pleased when he caressed Janeway, and her statement "We have
to define parameters." should have been a clear sign she
didn't want the same thing. Really? Only a few moments later they
seemed to settle on an agreement, and this was apparently not
about staying away from each other. I was a bit disappointed when
the communicators beeped in virtually the next instant. Janeway
and Chakotay, it remains an impossible combination because
neither of them is giving up their position. Just see the end of
the episode, it's business as usual ("Yes, Ma'am.") and
not much is wrapped up.
Remarkable quote: (Chakotay sees that Janeway is obviously
charmed by a primate) "Looking for a pet?" - "No,
looking for a clue about primate physiology on this planet. They
must have to contend with insect bites too."
Remarkable maneuver: Tuvok Maneuver, ejecting an antimatter
pod and igniting it with a photon torpedo. There has been
confusion about an alleged ventral torpedo launcher, but it is
actually the pod which is supposed to be located exactly there,
while the torpedo launch is not shown.
Remarkable fact: A Type-9 shuttle has a top speed of Warp 4,
according to Tom.
Photon torpedoes used: 3
Rating: 4
Basics I/II Stardate not given/50032.7: Seska transmits
a message, begging Chakotay to rescue her and her child, his
alleged son, from the Kazons. Janeway decides to assume that
Seska and the child are in actual danger. Tierna, who has
apparently fallen out of favor with Culluh, shows them a passage
through Kazon territory, and the ship endures only half-hearted attacks.
However, when Tierna disrupts the ship's power grid with a
suicide bomb, even the self-destruct is disabled after the Kazon
ships have permanently attacked the secondary command processor.
Seska and Culluh take over the ship and drop the Starfleet crew
on a savage planet. Only the Doctor and Ensign Suder stay on board. Paris escapes in a shuttle, while the rest of the crew strives to
stay alive on the hostile planet without any technology. Paris acquires help from the Talaxians, while the Doctor and Suder sabotage
the ship, so that it is disabled when attacked by Paris, and can
be freed from the Kazons. Seska dies and Culluh, the actual
father, takes her new-born child.

A double feature of big changes and big emotions.
Interestingly, to me "Basics" had less coherence than
other two-parters. Many questions were already answered at the
end of part I, and it was no doubt that the crew would somehow
manage to survive on the savage planet and eventually retake the
ship. Not that the second part would have been boring, it just
told a different story. The perhaps most interesting observation
in part I is that Janeway and Chakotay seem to have taken each
other's roles. Janeway, the always skeptical leader, trusts Seska
too much and makes the irrational decision to help her at all
cost. Chakotay, on the other hand, is suspicious like never
before. But he may simply put the welfare of the ship above his personal
interests.
Frankly, despite the many precautions, there isn't really
a plan to free Seska. Why is Janeway so confident they can take on eight massive
Kazon ships, each of them a hundred times as large as
Voyager? In "Caretaker" they had lots of trouble with
only one of them. Part II necessarily required the fall of the
tyrant. It was a bit of a surprise to see that it wasn't Culluh
but Seska who eventually died. She would have been more likely to
accompany the series as the resident villain than the
technologically and tactically challenged Kazons who actually
make their last regular appearance in "Basics". It's a pity
that the characters of Hogan and Lon Suder were abandoned
likewise. Suder's character is fascinating, and it would have been worth at
least another episode with a discussion whether he might be rehabilitated.
Remarkable dialogue: "You're more talented in the art of
deception than you led me to believe." - "I was
inspired by the presence of the master." (Seska and the
Doctor)
Ship landing: #2 and #3
Photon torpedoes used: 5 (at least)
Crew losses: 3 (at least)
Rating: 8
![]() | Last modified: 24.09.11 | |
| http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/episodes/voy2.htm | ||